Mel Smooth
Hacker
Think I need to see it before deciding, but if if it was an idea presented on Dragons Den, I'd be declaring "I'm out"
LIV Golf
- Thread starter MarkT
- Start date
Think I need to see it before deciding, but if if it was an idea presented on Dragons Den, I'd be declaring "I'm out"
Looks like Its a Knockout. Rubbish. Why do people think they need to dumb down or reinvent something that needs no reinventing. Get on with the real thing and ditch the crazy golf.
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
Imurg
The Grinder Of Pars (Semi Crocked)
Yeah...they'll be there because the ones that matter have recently won Majors and are, therefore, exempt...Bryson, Brooks, DJ, Read etc etc
The ones that aren't - Westwood, Poulter, Kaymer, Gooch, Na etc etc will have to qualify.
If they're in the top 50 or 60 in the OWGR on a certain date then that will qualify them..if they're not then there are qualifying competitions that they can enter.
The Opens are not going to say to them " Oh, you were once a World #1 ..please come and play....
The pathway is already there for them to qualify...if they don't qualify then they don't play.
Mel Smooth
Hacker
Thought you would definitely be in - it’s a short format ?
Did I see somewhere that it will be on a Monday Evening?
It's definitely aimed at primetime viewing, that's a well repeated phrase in all the press blurb, which will mean it will be happening in the early hours of the morning over here - assuming it's primetime USA viewing.
It's definitely not proper golf on a course, maybe that's why I have my doubts as to whether it will appeal to me.
FourPutt
Head Pro
It would be a shame to see these players rocking up at qualifying for the Open etc. imagine being an elite amateur or lower ranked/club pro and turning up to try and qualify and having to play against DJ et al.
In that sense this could negatively impact those who aren’t even involved in the whole thing.
In that sense this could negatively impact those who aren’t even involved in the whole thing.
Harry Putter
Member
If Dragons Den presented an individual golf format but contrived a team element that nobody cares about, with names like Crushers, Punch and Smash then I'd definitely be out.. in fact you wouldn't even get in the room.
How much are LIV paying you to spout your constant drivel?
Mel Smooth
Hacker
Definitley not enough to compensate for the nonsense I have to put up with on here.
Harry Putter
Member
Definitley not enough to compensate for the nonsense I have to put up with on here.
So you are on the LIV payroll.. that figures
Mel Smooth
Hacker
So you are on the LIV payroll.. that figures
No I'm not Harry. I was being sarcastically ironic.
You cant have a pathway that ignores a tour regardless of the level of player on it. The will make a new pathway ; and Saudi Tour winners, top 10 on the Saudi rankings, anyone who places in the top 3 in the 3 tournys before that major or whatever. If the existing pathway doesnt work, you have to lay a new one.
Come clean though then. I would have assumed your were a paid influencer or some such - you know the liv tour is a pile of poo like everyone else does dont you ?
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
No matter how many times you say it still won’t make it happen
There will be no direct entry from the LIV Tour results into the majors
Harry Putter
Member
Fair enough, I don't agree with your point of view, but I respect your right to air it.
So on Monday, for example, Cantlay, Straka, Zalatoris, Homa, Hatton, Poston, Power, Schauffle, Wise, Noren, Harmon, Kuchar, Kirk, Fleetwood, Lee, List, Glover, English, Young, Hovland, Burns, Finau, Lahiri, Fox, Berger, Stallings, Wise, Bradley, Horschel, Varner, Triangle, Theegala, all take the Sheiks Riyal. It benefits the majors how, not to have those players in their fields ?
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
?
Sorry not sure your point as many of them will gain access via exemptions already and most of them people won’t care about and have little impact on the majors anywayIt doesn’t change that the majors won’t change their qualifying to help LIV Tour players
I can see that you are missing the point - if you saw it, you would agree that the majors will change their criteria. It isnt needed at the moment. The players that matter still get in by the existing routes. BdC, DJ, PR, CS. But once there is a risk of a significant cohort of the worlds best golfers not having automatic access as they do at the moment, then the majors will react. There is no way they will hobble the prestige they hold today.
sunshine
Well-known member
We do need contrarian views for a constructive debate, but I understand your point.
To be fair, this thread is heading for 300 pages and I think we all know what Mel is up to, so people shouldn’t be taking it seriously or getting offended any more. He’s turned into a parody account now with his Twitter “facts”.
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
I’m not missing the point - I know exactly what you are trying to say
But it’s also very clear that the majors imo will not create direct qualifying from LIV events or tours when every single one of them can qualify from other means
If the tour becomes a standard tour with points then there will be further entry
Mel Smooth
Hacker
What’s that then?
I’m just debating the issue from the LIV side of the argument - obviously outnumbered on this platform by those that aren’t fans, but happy to keep contributing despite the seemingly unwavering views shared by both sides.
As for twitter news, Smith, Leishman and Tringale apparently confirmed as going, plus another top 30 player that will be a ‘bombshell’. The twitter account is Argentinian, and lots of speculation it will be Joaquin Niemann, which would be deemed a big signing in that part of the world.
