MiurasFan
Blackballed
For me, both are fouls! Some gamesmanship might be involved in 1 of them; Advantage Rule applied to the other
Swango1980
Well-known member
You said "he was almost certainly going to have a 1 on 1 with the keeper"
So, you seem to have posted that, almost exactly word for word. What am I missing?
MiurasFan
Blackballed
The difference between 'going to have a' and 'been'!! Also probably explains your incredulousness in previous posts
Last edited:
Swango1980
Well-known member
So, to clarify:
You do not think he would have BEEN one on one with the keeper had he not been fouled.
However, you think he almost certainly would have had a one and one with the keeper had he not been fouled?
Must say, this makes no sense, as they are effectively two ways of saying exactly the same thing, yet you claim that you didn't say he would have been one on one, but claim he almost certainly would have had a one on one!?
Going back to your original comment, I will happily and confidently say that he certainly would not have been one on one with the keeper had he not been fouled.
You do not think he would have BEEN one on one with the keeper had he not been fouled.
However, you think he almost certainly would have had a one and one with the keeper had he not been fouled?
Must say, this makes no sense, as they are effectively two ways of saying exactly the same thing, yet you claim that you didn't say he would have been one on one, but claim he almost certainly would have had a one on one!?
Going back to your original comment, I will happily and confidently say that he certainly would not have been one on one with the keeper had he not been fouled.
Bdill93
Undisputed King of FOMO
hairball_89
Club Champion
Can hit one of his legs with the other at the perfect moment tho…Even if he had he wouldn't have scored, cant hit a barn door that bloke.
HomecountiesJohn
Well-known member
Jeez, are you LiverpoolPhil under another handle?
Bdill93
Undisputed King of FOMO
HomecountiesJohn
Well-known member
Gets Penalties easy enough.
Bdill93
Undisputed King of FOMO
It'll be worth it if he wins them a pen in the CL final then!
HomecountiesJohn
Well-known member
The thought of Manchester City Sportswashing their way to a CL trophy makes me feel sick.
Swango1980
Well-known member
Why, because I can't understand the point someone is making.
Presumably, if it was felt Grealish was going to be 1v1 with goalkeeper, then the defender would have had a possible red card (given he didn't try and make a challenge)? Of course, not one person ever brought that up, and Grealish was never going to be 1 on 1 with goalkeeper in a million years in that incident.
It would be funny if I WAS Liverpoolphil though, as some of our debates would suggest he has multiple personality disorder
HomecountiesJohn
Well-known member
Why, because I can't understand the point someone is making.
Presumably, if it was felt Grealish was going to be 1v1 with goalkeeper, then the defender would have had a possible red card (given he didn't try and make a challenge)? Of course, not one person ever brought that up, and Grealish was never going to be 1 on 1 with goalkeeper in a million years in that incident.
It would be funny if I WAS Liverpoolphil though, as some of our debates would suggest he has multiple personality disorder
You understand the point Muirasfan is making, your just arguing the semantics, it's petty and tiresome.
Your constant argumentative, must have the last word, persona that is dsiplayed in this thread Is likened to that somewhat of LiverpoolPhil.
Swango1980
Well-known member
It is ironic that you are the one prolonging this conversation then, by being argumentative. Are you Liverpoolphil in disguise?
Big85
Active member
Unbelievable Jeff!! It doesn’t matter what your opinion’s are it won’t change anything! It’s not worth the arguing or disagreement 
go get your golf clubs out and have a round of golf. Happy Monday!!
go get your golf clubs out and have a round of golf. Happy Monday!!
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
Why, because I can't understand the point someone is making.
Presumably, if it was felt Grealish was going to be 1v1 with goalkeeper, then the defender would have had a possible red card (given he didn't try and make a challenge)? Of course, not one person ever brought that up, and Grealish was never going to be 1 on 1 with goalkeeper in a million years in that incident.
It would be funny if I WAS Liverpoolphil though, as some of our debates would suggest he has multiple personality disorder
The obsession is touching
But keep me out of your little pedantic spats please
Tashyboy
Please don’t ask to see my tatts 👍
Which part of Neville’s summary “ that was a poor tackle by the defender” don’t you get. He and every one else goes into meltdown because Grealish theatrically went down. It was a foul, it was a soft foul and it was one of many fouls on Grealish yesterday. If the defender had made a good tackle we wouldn’t be discussing this now. But he didn’t. Talking of tackles how comes no one talks of the excellent Tackle by Dias earlier in the game
PJ87
Journeyman Pro
Staying on your feet gets you nothing
https://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/west-hams-matt-jarvis-hammered-3420556
Jarvis many years ago against arsenal, hacked in the box. Stays on his feet..no pen given
Match of day was very much on the side of it should have been a pen
I mean var these days you "should" get the pen but still the case why stay on your feet?
MiurasFan
Blackballed
Had it been a deliberate foul, then certainly Yellow, possibly Red. However this was simply a 'careless' one, so no further disciplinary action is needed. As it wasn't already an obvious goal scoring opportunity - though, as my first post on the mini-topic I think it would have developed into one if not for the foul - Penalty only was appropriate. Whether that was what the Ref thought, I have no idea!. And remember that opinions are like anuses. . . . everybody has one!
Last edited:
MiurasFan
Blackballed
For me, Football has gone too far the other way and simulation is now far too omnipresent - at least in Premier League. It was refreshing to see very little of it in the World Cup and a bit depressing to see 'back to normal' in EPL!
Similar threads
