• We'd like to take this opportunity to wish you a Happy Holidays and a very Merry Christmas from all at Golf Monthly. Thank you for sharing your 2025 with us!

The Cricket Thread

I admire your optimism but what do you base that statement on? Unless Malan and Root keep being allowed to bat instead of others, they could take places 1-6 :LOL:, and our bowlers find a way to stop the Aussies I'm seeing nothing in those first two games that suggest anything other than 5-0.

Throw me a crumb of comfort.

I'm optimistic for lots of reasons:
1. Cummins was missing for this match. All we need is for someone to start coughing near Smith and he'll have to sit out the next match. Maybe also try this with Warner, Labuchagne, Starc etc.
2. There must be some rain forecast at some point. It does rain in Australia sometimes.
3. We took this test match all the way to the final session. There must be hope we can last one session longer in the next 3 matches to scrape a backs to the wall draw.
4. Half of this team will be playing to save their necks in the next match. I bet we will see the batters put a higher price on their wicket. Cynical I know.

The only problem is that if England do secure a battling draw in the next match, the Aussies will come back and crush all that optimism in the 4th match :LOL:
 
I'm optimistic for lots of reasons:
1. Cummins was missing for this match. All we need is for someone to start coughing near Smith and he'll have to sit out the next match. Maybe also try this with Warner, Labuchagne, Starc etc.
2. There must be some rain forecast at some point. It does rain in Australia sometimes.
3. We took this test match all the way to the final session. There must be hope we can last one session longer in the next 3 matches to scrape a backs to the wall draw.
4. Half of this team will be playing to save their necks in the next match. I bet we will see the batters put a higher price on their wicket. Cynical I know.

The only problem is that if England do secure a battling draw in the next match, the Aussies will come back and crush all that optimism in the 4th match :LOL:

All very valid points upon which to rest your hopes. Alas, this is England. And even the patriot in me cannot share your enthusiasm and optimism.

We have been comprehensively outplayed in every facet of the game. And that’s by an Australian side which is good, but by no means great.
 
Is it any surprise that another English coach fails

The last three times with have been successful and won the ashes etc

Fletcher
Flower
Baylis

Foreign coaches who have been around the world gaining experience

You would have expected them to learn tbe lesson from Moores
 
All very valid points upon which to rest your hopes. Alas, this is England. And even the patriot in me cannot share your enthusiasm and optimism.

We have been comprehensively outplayed in every facet of the game. And that’s by an Australian side which is good, but by no means great.

Sadly you may be right. Your last point is key - this isn't even a great Aussie side.
 
Just read this on BBC:
Former Australia captain Ricky Ponting said he "nearly fell off my seat" when he heard Root's comments.
Speaking to Cricket Australia's news site, he said: "Why are you captain then?
"If you can't influence your bowlers on what length to bowl, what are you doing on the field?"

:LOL:
 
Just read this on BBC:
Former Australia captain Ricky Ponting said he "nearly fell off my seat" when he heard Root's comments.
Speaking to Cricket Australia's news site, he said: "Why are you captain then?
"If you can't influence your bowlers on what length to bowl, what are you doing on the field?"

:LOL:

And he’s absolutely spot on.
 
Just read this on BBC:
Former Australia captain Ricky Ponting said he "nearly fell off my seat" when he heard Root's comments.
Speaking to Cricket Australia's news site, he said: "Why are you captain then?
"If you can't influence your bowlers on what length to bowl, what are you doing on the field?"

:LOL:
Ponting was a great skipper. It did help that he had a superb team around him but he was so attacking. He lost games because of it sometimes but it won him loads more than he lost and those wins usually demoralised the opposition.

Root is not the right skipper for the team. He isn’t mongrel enough.
 
Ponting was a great skipper. It did help that he had a superb team around him but he was so attacking. He lost games because of it sometimes but it won him loads more than he lost and those wins usually demoralised the opposition.

Root is not the right skipper for the team. He isn’t mongrel enough.


Pretty sure if you gave Root peak Hayden, Langer, Ponting, Gilchrist, McGrath and Warne he'd do just fine ;) Lot easier to be "mongrel" when you have a side full of world beaters
 
Top