fundy
Ryder Cup Winner
Road tax for electric cars in Hunt's budget this week?
The all things EV chat thread
- Thread starter need_my_wedge
- Start date
PJ87
Journeyman Pro
Imo a good decision, will have to get the balance right ofc no doubt it will be lower
Then again if you lease it doesn't affect you .. the lease company pay it
fundy
Ryder Cup Winner
The following step you would think would be to change the BIK on company electric cars.....
PJ87
Journeyman Pro
I am unsure as they need people to switch , this company car bit gets people in. Quite a few take it even though they never would hVe considered an EV they go for it because of this break
Needs to be carefully thought through
fundy
Ryder Cup Winner
and there lies the problem lol
It does get added into the lease though, you still end up paying.
Pants
Challenge Tour Pro
Beat me to it LT. Some people are so gullible 
Last edited:
PJ87
Journeyman Pro
Quiet, but wouldn't affect current lease deals as they are signed and agreed, the companies would have to front the difference
Going forward they will add it into the cost but what with the cost of the cars, the cost of interest both rising it will bearly be noticeable in real terms.
Bunkermagnet
Journeyman Pro
Why are you comparing an EV to petrol or diesel when they arent going to be sold new in 8 years time?
PJ87
Journeyman Pro
Ok then compare them to hydrogen. Equally as harmful to the environment as EV are.
Both require rare materials
Both require electric to make the "fuel"
Both give off zero emissions
Bunkermagnet
Journeyman Pro
The new Fuel cell being developed by VW and the other German company dont....
Jason.H
Well-known member
Been sitting on the fence with regards EV,s. Decided to have a test drive in a Cupra Born V2 and was quite impressed tbh. I could quite easily live with it with a charge point at home. At around 43k for the spec I’d like and I,d gues it would lose 50% of it’s value over 3 years. So whilst saving money at the pump but then losing big time on depreciation. Where as my VW Transporter will likely hold its value or even creep up Some more.
PJ87
Journeyman Pro
Watch how long it takes to bring to the market
The solid state battery has been in development for ages as has the cell
Pants
Challenge Tour Pro
In answer to the OP, no, I won’t – at least not in the foreseeable future. It doesn’t make any financial or ecological sense at all to change.
Currently I’m spending less than £1,000 on diesel a year and expect this to fall as I’ll probably drive less over the coming years. Currently (excuse the pun) running an EV would probably cost me (say) £3/400 pa in electricity but the cost of electricity is/will escalate. The govt will need to start punitive taxation of EV users fairly soon so we can forget about the “Road Fund Licence” differences. So, effectively, buying a cheapish EV at (say) £36,000, it would take me at least 60 years to benefit from the fuel savings.
The ecological damage from the manufacture of my car happened 5 years ago. Apart from the burning of the diesel, it’s carbon footprint has already happened and is “in the system”. If I buy a new car, the carbon footprint will be enormous by comparison - from the mining and extraction of materials, the use of oil for plastics, the energy in making the thing, the fuel costs in getting the vehicle or parts to this country. And then there’s the carbon footprint costs in producing the electricity to run the thing.
I can see the advantages for those who currently enjoy vastly reduced BIK but they are not really doing it to help the planet, are they? And for those who lease and have a new car every 3 years or so - why?? Modern cars are good for 10/15/20 years or so. Bit like golf clubs I suppose, got to have new shineys every so often.
I’m sure that my logic is flawed somewhere and the EV proponents will be along to put me right ...
Currently I’m spending less than £1,000 on diesel a year and expect this to fall as I’ll probably drive less over the coming years. Currently (excuse the pun) running an EV would probably cost me (say) £3/400 pa in electricity but the cost of electricity is/will escalate. The govt will need to start punitive taxation of EV users fairly soon so we can forget about the “Road Fund Licence” differences. So, effectively, buying a cheapish EV at (say) £36,000, it would take me at least 60 years to benefit from the fuel savings.
The ecological damage from the manufacture of my car happened 5 years ago. Apart from the burning of the diesel, it’s carbon footprint has already happened and is “in the system”. If I buy a new car, the carbon footprint will be enormous by comparison - from the mining and extraction of materials, the use of oil for plastics, the energy in making the thing, the fuel costs in getting the vehicle or parts to this country. And then there’s the carbon footprint costs in producing the electricity to run the thing.
I can see the advantages for those who currently enjoy vastly reduced BIK but they are not really doing it to help the planet, are they? And for those who lease and have a new car every 3 years or so - why?? Modern cars are good for 10/15/20 years or so. Bit like golf clubs I suppose, got to have new shineys every so often.
I’m sure that my logic is flawed somewhere and the EV proponents will be along to put me right ...
Bunkermagnet
Journeyman Pro
The patent has already been applied for. I don't think VW are going to be sitting back do you?
PJ87
Journeyman Pro
Not all patented tech makes it to market ..
You speak like it's going to be on sale next year.
Let's see if it's on the UK market in 5 years
clubchamp98
Journeyman Pro
Logic sounds pretty good to me.
It’s a major question people are asking themselves.
D
Deleted member 29109
Guest
A lot of company cars go back after a certain mileage or after 2 or 3 years.
Also, if people didn’t buy new cars every few years. There would be no decent second hand cars to buy.
Also, if people didn’t buy new cars every few years. There would be no decent second hand cars to buy.
clubchamp98
Journeyman Pro
And a lot of unemployed car workers.
Imurg
The Grinder Of Pars (Semi Crocked)
You do realise that you could have said those words a few years back in the ICE/EV debate.......
