Advice on an East Lothian trip

[Backache]

Apart from the obvious NB, Muirfield, Gullane 1 etc

Luffness?
Monktonhall


Depending on your way home potential options for your last day;

Goswick
Bamburgh
Seahouses
Roxburghe
Peebles

Must say having played Monktonhall and Luffness, they're both decent courses but a bit pricey for what they offer.
Monktonhall is a pleasant parkland course whose equivalent is at least 40% cheaper elsewhere.
Luffness is a really enjoyable links course which basically shares the same bit of land as Gullane 3 and charges a lot more than a day at 2&3.
Not to criticise either course but if you're budget sensitive I'd look elsewhere.

 

[Trapdraw]

If you’re travelling south from East Lothian, if it’s via the A1 play Goswick, if it’s via the M6 play Silloth.

 

[williamalex1]

60? Are you a pro?

I think that's Doon on the right.

 

[williamalex1]

Royal Musselburgh used to be a good course, but I've not played it for a few years.

 

[rudebhoy]

Royal Musselburgh used to be a good course, but I've not played it for a few years.

Played it a couple of years ago. Enjoyable parkland course, great clubhouse. It was cheap as chips, we paid £20 via the James Braid Association.

 

[KenL]

Must say having played Monktonhall and Luffness, they're both decent courses but a bit pricey for what they offer.
Monktonhall is a pleasant parkland course whose equivalent is at least 40% cheaper elsewhere.
Luffness is a really enjoyable links course which basically shares the same bit of land as Gullane 3 and charges a lot more than a day at 2&3.
Not to criticise either course but if you're budget sensitive I'd look elsewhere.

Agreed, Luffness is a lovely links course and always in great condition.
The jacket, shirt & tie clubhouse, the long socks and no women members puts me off a bit.

 

[Backache]

Played it a couple of years ago. Enjoyable parkland course, great clubhouse. It was cheap as chips, we paid £20 via the James Braid Association.

Agree it's enjoyable .According to the website is is now £100 for a midweek round and £125 at weekends which I think is a bit steep.

 

[KenL]

Agree it's enjoyable .According to the website is is now £100 for a midweek round and £125 at weekends which I think is a bit steep.

It is never worth that for a round.

 

[rudebhoy]

Agree it's enjoyable .According to the website is is now £100 for a midweek round and £125 at weekends which I think is a bit steep.

That's mad.

Just checked the current James Braid Assoc price - £25.

 

[need_my_wedge]

A guy I’m working with at the moment is a PGA pro, member at North Berwick. He recommended me Winterfield just last week. Said it’s a really good track, was a council course but the running has been taken over by two of the pro’s from Dunbar and they are apparently doing a great job. Green fee is £33.

Haven’t played it yet myself but now on the list.

 

[moogie]

A guy I’m working with at the moment is a PGA pro, member at North Berwick. He recommended me Winterfield just last week. Said it’s a really good track, was a council course but the running has been taken over by two of the pro’s from Dunbar and they are apparently doing a great job. Green fee is £33.

Haven’t played it yet myself but now on the list.

Were heading up to the area
Last week in March

Funnily enough
A video of winterfield popped up on YouTube the other day, looked interesting, but never heard much mention of the club before.....

Any locals have any input, that have played it lately??

 

[KenL]

I've played Winterfield once. Some nice holes on the back 9 and great views. But, the front 9 is the worst 9 holes I've played anywhere.

 

[KenL]

Craigielaw is not everyone's cup of tea, mainly due to the bonkers greens. But it is worth playing.
Much prefer Kilspindie though.

 

[need_my_wedge]

Craigielaw is not everyone's cup of tea, mainly due to the bonkers greens. But it is worth playing.
Much prefer Kilspindie though.

The same guy that recommended Winterfield to me advised me to stay away from Craigielaw….

I guess each to his own. I will still play it at some time, it’s also on my list.

Note: post edited as I mistakenly put Kilspindie in the original.

 

[KenL]

The same guy that recommended Winterfield to me advised me to stay away from Kilspindie….

I guess each to his own. I will still play it at some time, it’s also on my list.

Was that a golfer? No comparison, Kilspindie is a wee gem. Winterfield front 9 is a featureless field.

 

[KenL]

No contest - Kilspindie every time!

Winterfield’s ok but prob last in the East Lothian links OOM for me.

For me it is last when you include all the courses.

 

[Bazzatron]

The same guy that recommended Winterfield to me advised me to stay away from Kilspindie….

I guess each to his own. I will still play it at some time, it’s also on my list.

We loved Kilspindie when we went, I'd definitely recommend giving that a go.

 

[Bazzatron]

We've got Gullane number 3 booked for the day we arrive, probably Craigielaw 2nd day, Longniddry 3rd day and managed to get Dunbar earlyish before the dreaded drive back.

Thanks all.

 

[KenL]

Might have missed it. Where are you staying?

 

[Bazzatron]

Might have missed it. Where are you staying?

Got a cottage booked in Haddington.