WHS doesn't work

[Swango1980]

My club hasn’t told me .
So now they will have to tell me something they havnt told me isn’t happening yet.

Our Club sent e-mails out to members this Tuesday, explaining the changes with WHS come April. Obviously, 4BBB being one of those changes.

I guess they will have to send another e-mail at some point, explaining the 4BBB change may not actually happen.

I'd love to know what the issue is. Behind the scenes, the change to 4BBB has been known for quite a long time. I'd have thought it would be relatively easy for the ISVs to add that to their software long ago, and had plenty of time to be tested. It is not like they are trying to add mathematics that only Will Hunting is capable of solving.

 

[wjemather]

Our Club sent e-mails out to members this Tuesday, explaining the changes with WHS come April. Obviously, 4BBB being one of those changes.

I guess they will have to send another e-mail at some point, explaining the 4BBB change may not actually happen.

I'd love to know what the issue is. Behind the scenes, the change to 4BBB has been known for quite a long time. I'd have thought it would be relatively easy for the ISVs to add that to their software long ago, and had plenty of time to be tested. It is not like they are trying to add mathematics that only Will Hunting is capable of solving.

Judging by what others have heard from their ISVs, until recently, they didn't understand what needs to be sent through to dotgolf.

The work required from the ISVs depends where the assessment calculations are being done.

 

[2blue]

Interesting to hazard a guess at the % of failing clubs and/or committees, resulting in players routinely being able to, let’s say, “not fulfil their responsibilities’ correctly, in addition clubs allowing GP cards (not switching their tees off) when their course is not acceptable..

A quick look on MyEG App shows that most of the courses in Leeds are enabled for Acceptable Scores which is amazing considering only a week ago they were either shut or heavily restricted.

 

[Swango1980]

A quick look on MyEG App shows that most of the courses in Leeds are enabled for Acceptable Scores which is amazing considering only a week ago they were either shut or heavily restricted.

Well, I guess a course is either open for scores or not, no halfway measures. So, maybe the courses are now fully open, and scores are now possible?

Would have been interesting to know what the status of MyEG App was when they were closed or restricted.

 

[D-S]

Well, I guess a course is either open for scores or not, no halfway measures. So, maybe the courses are now fully open, and scores are now possible?

Would have been interesting to know what the status of MyEG App was when they were closed or restricted.

There are lots of halfway measures, Back tees turned off, Forward tees only, Front 9 forward tees only, back 9 only etc.

 

[nickjdavis]

Well, I guess a course is either open for scores or not, no halfway measures. So, maybe the courses are now fully open, and scores are now possible?

Would have been interesting to know what the status of MyEG App was when they were closed or restricted.

Looking at the App for my course it simply says that (when you try to create a scorecard) there are no markers available (marker being the stupid term they use for "tee"....rather than being the person who marks your card!!!).

 

[Swango1980]

There are lots of halfway measures, Back tees turned off, Forward tees only, Front 9 forward tees only, back 9 only etc.

OK, didn't come out the way I meant it.

I meant that you can either sign in for a round or not. There is no option to say "you can sign in for a round, but it'll only have 50% the impact than normal on your record because the course was boggy last week"

As far as I'm aware, there is no option to turn off individual holes? It is still either full round, or a set of 9 holes?

 

[Swango1980]

Looking at the App for my course it simply says that (when you try to create a scorecard) there are no markers available (marker being the stupid term they use for "tee"....rather than being the person who marks your card!!!).

Yeah, I always though "Marker" was a pretty idiotic term to use

 

[2blue]

Well, I guess a course is either open for scores or not, no halfway measures. So, maybe the courses are now fully open, and scores are now possible?

Would have been interesting to know what the status of MyEG App was when they were closed or restricted.

Defo not the case in the vast majority!

 

[HeftyHacker]

I know for a fact that ours never gets turned off on the EG platform, despite the fact its either shut or down to 15 holes when it is open, and playing off temp tees.

The club is terrible at this kind of admin but I appreciate its volunteer run.

 

[clubchamp98]

I know for a fact that ours never gets turned off on the EG platform, despite the fact its either shut or down to 15 holes when it is open, and playing off temp tees.

The club is terrible at this kind of admin but I appreciate its volunteer run.

That’s a major flaw in this system imo.

It’s down to volunteers to administer it in a lot of clubs if not most.

So people’s handicaps rely on volunteers checking on the manipulators.
We were assured that the hcap comittiees workload would not change.
That’s just plainly not true.

 

[mikejohnchapman]

How would they check? Surely it can’t be the responsibility of a committee member to phone up every club to check that a particular tee set was open on a specific date before inputting any manual GP card.

I didn't think anyone would do this but I met a fellow Handicap Chairman who did this for every card submitted from outside his home course. He talked about catching people out with an almost evangelical attitude and generally was opposed to GP scores so wanted to minimise their impact. I was speaking to him during a rain delay so the conversation went on for a while.

He told me with great glee that someone had submitted a card from a local course which he had played recently and complained that some of the tees were outside the 10yds in front of the marker. He actually checked that the club had not moved them on the day in question and disqualified the card due to it not being a measured course.

I asked him about the desire from EG to get people to submit cards whenever possible. His response was "not my problem".

I came to the conclusion that life was too short for this amount of hassle.

 

[clubchamp98]

I didn't think anyone would do this but I met a fellow Handicap Chairman who did this for every card submitted from outside his home course. He talked about catching people out with an almost evangelical attitude and generally was opposed to GP scores so wanted to minimise their impact. I was speaking to him during a rain delay so the conversation went on for a while.

He told me with great glee that someone had submitted a card from a local course which he had played recently and complained that some of the tees were outside the 10yds in front of the marker. He actually checked that the club had not moved them on the day in question and disqualified the card due to it not being a measured course.

I asked him about the desire from EG to get people to submit cards whenever possible. His response was "not my problem".

I came to the conclusion that life was too short for this amount of hassle.

Sounds like he’s doing the right thing but for the wrong reasons.

 

[woofers]

I asked him about the desire from EG to get people to submit cards whenever possible.

Can’t find where EG say that, do you have a link ?

 

[Deleted member 15717]

That’s a major flaw in this system imo.

It’s down to volunteers to administer it in a lot of clubs if not most.

Genuine question….who should administer it, if not people at the club itself?

 

[clubchamp98]

Genuine question….who should administer it, if not people at the club itself?

It’s not the fact they do it.
The workload must have shot up under this system.

It’s fine if you have someone who wants to do this work.
But a lot of clubs havnt and it becomes a problem and not checked.

It’s going to be a paid job imo soon.

 

[AussieKB]

Played in a 4BBB Open yesterday and was on the card 16 times, shot 2 over par and no handicap change,
WHS works for me.....

 

[wjemather]

Played in a 4BBB Open yesterday and was on the card 16 times, shot 2 over par and no handicap change,
WHS works for me.....

I've heard the 4bbb process is a manual one in Aus, so reliant on players and handicap committees?

 

[2blue]

It’s not the fact they do it.
The workload must have shot up under this system.

It’s fine if you have someone who wants to do this work.
But a lot of clubs havnt and it becomes a problem and not checked.

It’s going to be a paid job imo soon.

It would only need a small % to be taken from Comp entry fees for this to happen. After all its in Comps that accurate H/caps matter most!!

 

[D-S]

It would only need a small % to be taken from Comp entry fees for this to happen. After all its in Comps that accurate H/caps matter most!!

We have moved to this but the money isn’t coming from comps just from general club funds. Depending on the number of comps, cost of entry and scope of the role it could be a significant %. 5 hours a week for example at minimum wage is just under 3k.