As Orikoru says, there has to be a degree of anticipation because he is too close for a realistic reaction to happen. He took a slight gamble and lost. It wasn't a major fault in my eyes.
Swango1980
Well-known member
Just watched it. Sure, had he stayed on his feet and tall, probably would have saved it. But is it a huge error? Not so sure about that. Jota absolutely rifled it from close range. I doubt any keeper would assume they could react after ball has been hit, so he'd made decision it'll go across him, and he was wrong. It is also probably quite a narrow window for Jota to smash it into, which he did brilliantly. It doesn't escape me that both Salah's goals were scored by hitting the ball across him, so maybe he was even more determined to stop Jota repeating that? (Edit: just read Orikoru's post 19098, mind readers)
Some much more worrying errors in that game, such as Salah getting through for that 3rd goal.
D
Deleted member 29109
Guest
Same here. But, like many things it is now considered out of date thinking.
We’re splitting hairs and playing with semantics. How often do we hear a commentator say, “well played the keeper for staying tall.” And, “the keeper made it easy by going early.” The second one isn’t relevant as Jota had no other thought than putting his foot through it. Would it have been saved if Pickford hadn’t gone early? We’ll never know.
We could argue the toss till the cows come home. You believe one thing, quite rightly, and I another, quite rightly.
Liverbirdie
Ryder Cup Winner
Yes, my very first derby - 5-0 at Goodison - what a start.
Even better, me and my dad were in with the blues in the lower Bullens, although many reds around, as was the norm at both derbies then - We'd have about 6-7k in the park end, and another 10k all around the ground.
Swango1980
Well-known member
Was Seaman's shape or position really that bad, as shown below? Yes, he was low, but only because he was preparing to spring into action. And, also got to bare in mind that Giggs was running from outside the box, so the keeper was trying to also narrow the angles, in case Giggs got the shot away earlier. He was 100% not off balance as Giggs struck the ball, and he 100% was not falling backwards when Giggs struck it. However, about 0.01 seconds later, the ball was flying into the roof of the nett, and Seaman only fell backwards as he attempted in vain to throw his hand in the air, and was pretty much only falling backwards as the ball passed him and went into the nett.
He could have just stood tall and might have saved the shot. But, had the shot flown across him, he'd have been criticised for not setting himself.
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
?
?Jensen
Tour Rookie
Absolutely, yes. His weight is well back on his heels as he’s already falling back. He practically looks like he’s sitting on the toilet.
Narrowing the angle is fine, but he’s squatting far too low. He should be standing taller with his weight on the balls of his feet so he can spring into action.
Even before Giggs hits the ball, he’s already falling backwards. Note his spine angle.
Bazz
Q-School Graduate
100% proved me wrong, I was probably so bitter about someone daring to think they could do better than us I couldn't see it. Good luck to that lad, just not on Saturday.
Swango1980
Well-known member
I'll respectively disagree
D
Deleted member 1740
Guest
?? We're all the same.
In fairness i dont think anyone expected Jota to improve as much has he has done.
As an ex-keeper I disagree and think Swango has it right. I has always been something that was drilled into the keepers at every level I played but the harsh reality is it happens. Whether you put it down to keeper error or a good finish is the point of contention and the outfield players will inevitable blame the keeper where the fault may actually lie with their actions in the build up. Either way your side is a goal down
Bazz
Q-School Graduate
Wouldn't be surprised if you're back for Adama in January.
Tashyboy
Please don’t ask to see my tatts 👍
what’s the odds Jota and Adama have had one or two phone calls ?
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
fundy
Ryder Cup Winner
Is a night without that damn squirrell too much to ask for? looking at the teamsheets I worry so.
fundy
Ryder Cup Winner
erm thats a goal, not Arsenals fault Freds done DDG lol
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
That’s got to be a goal hasn’t it ?
Liverbirdie
Ryder Cup Winner
Popcorn.......
