• We'd like to take this opportunity to wish you a Happy Holidays and a very Merry Christmas from all at Golf Monthly. Thank you for sharing your 2025 with us!

The Cricket Thread

Wow - so it appears Leach has higher bounce than the Indian left arm spinners ??
 
If we can keep this going long enough they may have to abandon the match...the whole field is just falling apart..
More divots than a busy muni golf course
 
His foot looked in the air at the time the wicket was broken...
Close call

It’s not a close call if it’s against the Indian Captain playing at home with home umpires

There is no doubt that if that was Root the examination would have been under a bit more scrutiny

England didn’t play well but that pitch is shocking and the umpiring hasn’t been much better

I’m still amazed how Leach managed to get that much extra bounce compared to the Axar
 
Watching the highlights ... Crawley and Foaks did show that batting was possible on the pitch..

Also realised that india did not bowl the third spinner - Washington..
 
His foot looked in the air at the time the wicket was broken...
Close call

I am split on this.. benefit of doubt situation. Use of stump cam would not help either, since you need to see where his foot was when the first stump lights come on. I am assuming stump cam on middle stump and we need to see where the foot was when the off stump was broken. If camera on middle stump, it will show he was in.. if camera on off stump then it would be more useful
 
I am split on this.. benefit of doubt situation. Use of stump cam would not help either, since you need to see where his foot was when the first stump lights come on. I am assuming stump cam on middle stump and we need to see where the foot was when the off stump was broken. If camera on middle stump, it will show he was in.. if camera on off stump then it would be more useful

If you get chance to watch it again, look at Rohit's shoe. It looks boxfresh when the stumps are broken, and the leather then creases heavily just afterward as pressure is placed between foot and ground.
 
If you get chance to watch it again, look at Rohit's shoe. It looks boxfresh when the stumps are broken, and the leather then creases heavily just afterward as pressure is placed between foot and ground.
i agree ... touch and go as we basing it on secondary evidence... the one I am disappointed was the Ben Stokes catch. Looked grassed from far, but I think the third ump jumped the gun, he should have shown the stump camera like they did for the Leach catch. Inconsistency is annoying. Why can’t they have a neutral 3rd umpire who is WFH from Srilanka or Aus?? Does he have to be in the stadium
 
The pitch is a farce ... switched on to see a bloke with a dustpan picking up debries

Any chance of getting India under 200... ignore Rohit (he is playing a different match).. focus on the others. Get Root to bowl
 
Top