chrisd
Major Champion
Im as far away from Scotland as you can be in the South East and only one of our main comps is Stableford
New H/C (54) Comp Changes
- Thread starter Crazyface
- Start date
Im as far away from Scotland as you can be in the South East and only one of our main comps is Stableford
I thought there was talk of rule changes to accommodate this in Medal rounds. Pick your ball up and it goes down as a double bogie........or I might be talking out of my backside
rosecott
Money List Winner
I thought there was talk of rule changes to accommodate this in Medal rounds. Pick your ball up and it goes down as a double bogie........or I might be talking out of my backside
You are for the moment, but I'll excuse you as your heart is in the right place.
The player can pick up but he will be N/R although his gross scores on the other holes will determine if he buffers or otherwise.
HankMarvin
Tour Rookie
I thought there was talk of rule changes to accommodate this in Medal rounds. Pick your ball up and it goes down as a double bogie........or I might be talking out of my backside
They are looking to bring a rule in to cover it in 2019 apparently
I thought there was talk of rule changes to accommodate this in Medal rounds. Pick your ball up and it goes down as a double bogie........or I might be talking out of my backside
You can pick up and NR in a stroke play Medal which just puts you out the comp, but you can carry on as it will only count as a nett double bogey and you can still play for your handicap and actually get cut!
Yes I know today's rules, this is something I was told will be coming in the near future.
NWJocko
Tour Winner
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Think we have 1 or 2 weekend comps a season that are stablefords, just like my club back in Scotland
doublebogey7
Head Pro
I thought there was talk of rule changes to accommodate this in Medal rounds. Pick your ball up and it goes down as a double bogie........or I might be talking out of my backside
What would be he difference between that and a stableford?
FairwayDodger
Money List Winner
My only real concern with this is that it will further discourage low handicappers from entering the matchplay. The author of this article addresses it but totally misses the point. He has never in his life given anyone 30+ shots in a match, never mind the 50+ that will now be possible. Contrary to what he says, this is not about winning or losing. It's about wanting to have a sensible competitive match and giving that many strokes makes it a farce, it's about playing a match in which the low handicappers performance has any bearing on the result.
Medals - fine. Bounce games - no problems. Match play - what's the point?
rosecott
Money List Winner
It may not be one of your finest experiences on the golf course, but I would back you to defeat a genuine 50+ handicapper in matchplay.
D
Deleted member 16999
Guest
Karen, have you played in any matchplay events were there is no upper limit? I’m not aware of any in this area, most have an upper limit imposed on matchplay comps.
I can’t believe a “genuine†54 Handicapper would actually enter a matchplay comp.
FairwayDodger
Money List Winner
That's not the point. Nobody seems to understand this, probably because nobody else on here has ever had to give over 30 shots in a match. It is soul destroying - you take 8 on a hole, and win it, you make a birdie at the next hole and lose it.
Not sure how many times I need to say "it's not about winning or losing" before people actually try to think through what I am saying. Cat 1 player vs 50 handicap is two people playing two different games - the result is entirely dependent on how the 50 handicap plays - and simply not any fun.
FairwayDodger
Money List Winner
Yes - at club level it's pretty much open to all members with no limits.
D
Deleted member 16999
Guest
That scenario is more than believable, but I’d still back the Cat 1 to win 10 holes or more in the match.
FairwayDodger
Money List Winner
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaagh!!! It's not about winning or losing!!!! :rofl:
D
Deleted member 16999
Guest
I understand it’s soul destroying and not the winning or losing, but if you did play a 54 Handicapper in that scenario you’ve either decided to suck it up or you’re playing it for fun.
rosecott
Money List Winner
But you're highly unlikely to play a 54 handicapper in more than one round. Look upon it as being Manchester United playing a non-league club in the FA Cup - a bit of a chore, but more of a challenge in the next round - just suck it up.
D
Deleted member 1740
Guest
Where's the fun in giving someone 50 shots?
Imurg
The Grinder Of Pars (Semi Crocked)
I can see where FDs coming from on this, it does change the way you think and play.
But..
Who said competition golf always has to be fun?
Where's the fun in playing like a prat and getting done by a dog licence..?
Where's the fun in going out in the Medal in howling winds and rain at 1°C early on a Sunday morning after a heavy night?
Where's the fun, in a scratch Matchplay, parring a tough par 4 only to see your oppo sink a 20 yarder from a deep pothole bunker to win the hole?
Competition golf isn't always fun.
But..
Who said competition golf always has to be fun?
Where's the fun in playing like a prat and getting done by a dog licence..?
Where's the fun in going out in the Medal in howling winds and rain at 1°C early on a Sunday morning after a heavy night?
Where's the fun, in a scratch Matchplay, parring a tough par 4 only to see your oppo sink a 20 yarder from a deep pothole bunker to win the hole?
Competition golf isn't always fun.
Well with Stableford you win by amassing points, and with Medal it's the lowest net gross, no different than it is today. But what it will do is speed up play as you won't get people having big double digits on their card when they can pick up and put down a net double.
As I said, I think it's something being discussed for the future.
Similar threads
- Deleted member 21784
- The Lounge
