• Thanks to each and every one of you for being part of the Golf Monthly community! We hope you have a joyous holiday season!

Custom fit v off the shelf

Mozza73

Assistant Pro
Joined
Nov 2, 2012
Messages
169
Visit site
D

Deleted member 15344

Guest
Yes, I am perfectly aware of what I wrote post fitting. I thought it was good - my handicap / level of play has doubled / worsened since!

Maybe that's down to the workman as opposed to the tools

I'm pretty sure that's the sort of attitude you recently displayed to people bemoaning unable to use 3 woods ?
 

pendodave

Tour Rookie
Joined
May 3, 2011
Messages
3,294
Visit site
Poor old Snelly, pichforks and ducking stools incoming... I think he'll be OK, I hope so, we need a bit of grit in the forum oyster now and again..

Just read the first and last pages of this thread. The first is measured and sensible and pretty much fits in with my own experience and observations. Maybe it should have been locked down there.

A couple of other thoughts...

1. Just watched a Crossfield vid where he changed the lie angle at impact of someones swing by a couple of degrees in five minutes. I suspect these and other swing parameters change a lot in any given day/week/month for most handicap golfers. If you just worked off the bog standard ping static charts you probably have a perfectly satisfactory working average without the need to micro-analyse a particular two hour session.

2. If measuring cost effectiveness for improving golf, I would suggest that second hand+lessons is far better than custom fitting+brand new clubs. Especially using the chart mentioned above, ebay, a sensible assessment of you own swingspeed and a browse around AG to see what suits your eye. A brand new set of Ping G irons = £480, G25 on ebay =£225. That would give £250 on lessons with a lovely set of irons. I know which golfer would get better fastest for his £500 notes.
 

karlcole

Q-School Graduate
Joined
Jun 26, 2012
Messages
1,025
Location
Bolton
Visit site
Poor old Snelly, pichforks and ducking stools incoming... I think he'll be OK, I hope so, we need a bit of grit in the forum oyster now and again..

Just read the first and last pages of this thread. The first is measured and sensible and pretty much fits in with my own experience and observations. Maybe it should have been locked down there.

A couple of other thoughts...

1. Just watched a Crossfield vid where he changed the lie angle at impact of someones swing by a couple of degrees in five minutes. I suspect these and other swing parameters change a lot in any given day/week/month for most handicap golfers. If you just worked off the bog standard ping static charts you probably have a perfectly satisfactory working average without the need to micro-analyse a particular two hour session.

2. If measuring cost effectiveness for improving golf, I would suggest that second hand+lessons is far better than custom fitting+brand new clubs. Especially using the chart mentioned above, ebay, a sensible assessment of you own swingspeed and a browse around AG to see what suits your eye. A brand new set of Ping G irons = £480, G25 on ebay =£225. That would give £250 on lessons with a lovely set of irons. I know which golfer would get better fastest for his £500 notes.


Exactly right mate in my opinion but we all love a good custom fit set of new irons ha
 

anotherdouble

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Mar 18, 2010
Messages
3,200
Visit site
Ok, first thing to state is that I'm a bit of a serial club changer.

My last 4 sets of irons have been (from oldest)

Titleist AP2

CallawayX2 Hot

Mizuno JPX850 Forged

Taylormade RSI 1

The first and third set were meticulously custom fit and the other two I just took off the shelf. I hit the off the shelf clubs every bit as well, as solid and score at least as well as the fitted clubs, in fact the Callaways produced my best ever round including a hole in one. I've only had the TM's a couple of weeks but they really feel superb and ive shot 38, 31 and 35 points with them.

It could be that I'm pretty bog standard in fitting but does anyone feel that fittings v off the shelf makes a huge difference?

It could be that you are just a golf god and could use a sledge hammer and croquet mallet (not fitted) and get around a course. You think of that
 
Top