4BBB 2's Club scenario

[Lord Tyrion]

I played in a 4bbb with @Beezerk on Saturday. On one of the par 3 holes they were running a 2's club. We both had the same number of shots on the hole.

@Beezerk hit a beauty, about 1-2 ft from the hole, cue suitable doffing of caps. I took my shot and hit it to about 6ft, cue noises of surprise . I went first, shaved the edge of the hole. @Beezerk went next, sunk the putt, gets a share of the pot (although tbc as rain called off the comp later on and we are still waiting to see if the scores in count or not)

The question is, we discussed it but didn't know the answer, if I had sunk my putt, does the team stop then as far as the comp is concerned? I know it does for the scoring but what about the 2's?

Would his 2 still count for the 2's or not? My thinking was that it should, both should, but others were not so sure.

 

[jim8flog]

We use IG and it automatically records all 2s when the scores are entered.
IG requires each players score to be entered separately and it works out the better ball.

 

[Backache]

If you'd both sunk your tee shots would only one of you claim a hole in one?
I should think they should both count for the 2s.

 

[Mel Smooth]

If he makes the putt, it's a 2 so yeah, he'd get a cut right?

You could just mutually agree to share any winnings beforehand I guess, so then the scenario is covered.

 

[Lord Tyrion]

If he makes the putt, it's a 2 so yeah, he'd get a cut right?

You could just mutually agree to share any winnings beforehand I guess, so then the scenario is covered.

I know he gets a share, my question is if both of the pair get a 2 do we both get part of the pot? Posts 2 and 3 suggests yes. 2 equal shares is better than a split share, unless his was the only 2 of the day

His 2, he keeps the money. Up to me to get my own 2.

 

[Mel Smooth]

I know he gets a share, my question is if both of the pair get a 2 do we both get part of the pot? Posts 2 and 3 suggests yes.

His 2, he keeps the money. Up to me to get my own 2.

Well yes, you've got a 2, no reason why you can't complete the hole - infact the logical answer would be that you should complete a full scorecard and submit it for hcap purposes anyway (although I appreciate that doesn't happen)

 

[fenwayrich]

Both 2's would count at our club. Payout is to the individual even in 4bbb.

 

[Deleted member 15717]

Well yes, you've got a 2, no reason why you can't complete the hole - infact the logical answer would be that you should complete a full scorecard and submit it for hcap purposes anyway (although I appreciate that doesn't happen)

Except you can’t submit 4BBB scores.

aside from that..

if OP made a 2, then should have submitted that as well as part of the scoring and you’d get a payout

 

[Beezerk]

@Lord Tyrion
Still not heard anything yet the results of yesterday’s “cancelled” comp are on HDID

 

[AAC]

Both 2's would count at our club. Payout is to the individual even in 4bbb.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ Exactly this at our club.

 

[moogie]

I'd say no
On the basis that in this format, only 1 score is recorded per hole
So I'd say only 1 x 2 per pair per hole

But....I've no idea of the answer to what the clubs policy is, and never came across the situation at any club, to tell you the outcome



TBH.....
I'm more shocked that martyn hit the green

 

[The Fader]

I think it boils down to whether the 2's were paid into as a team or individually.

At our place the team pays in and would only be eligible for one share of the pot per hole.

Given there is only 50% of scores for each hole in 4bbb then the pay out should be bigger. Most pairs split the pay out
regardless of who gets the 2. That's the essence of team sport to me.

 

[Deleted member 15344]

Well yes, you've got a 2, no reason why you can't complete the hole - infact the logical answer would be that you should complete a full scorecard and submit it for hcap purposes anyway (although I appreciate that doesn't happen)

You can’t submit a HC card when playing 4bbb


As for the OP - we give out a two to the person who got the two. If it’s a pair then the person who got the two gets the money.

 

[3offTheTee]

If you both pay to be in the 2’s and you both have a 2 on the same hole your team has 2 2’s.

If not one competitor has paid to enter the 2’s and cannot have a try.

Hope they pay out.

 

[Mel Smooth]

You can’t submit a HC card when playing 4bbb


As for the OP - we give out a two to the person who got the two. If it’s a pair then the person who got the two gets the money.

Both players can complete the hole though Phil, so if they both get two’s - they’d both be entitled to a share of the 2’s pot?

 

[Deleted member 15344]

Both players can complete the hole though Phil, so if they both get two’s - they’d both be entitled to a share of the 2’s pot?

Yes they can complete the hole to go for a 2 if they have both paid to enter the 2’s

 

[Deleted member 30522]

We use IG and it automatically records all 2s when the scores are entered.
IG requires each players score to be entered separately and it works out the better ball.

But you don't enter both scores in a better ball

 

[Deleted member 15344]

But you don't enter both scores in a better ball

You can do when putting scores in on IG

 

[Deleted member 30522]

You can do when putting scores in on IG

I'm sure you can, but you shouldn't be, there's no reason to and it will slow up play

 

[Deleted member 15344]

I'm sure you can, but you shouldn't be, there's no reason to and it will slow up play

What if someone has a shot on a par three and the other doesn’t - one without the shot and gets a 2 - other player still has the chance to gain the extra point- valid for any hole hence why for most 4BBB’s