Casual water moving the ball

Imurg

The Grinder Of Pars (Semi Crocked)
Joined
Mar 15, 2008
Messages
36,754
Location
Aylesbury Bucks
Visit site
To my mind we're over thinking this....

The ball was on the fairway...
It rained and a stream of water carried the ball into a Water Hazard.
Water is not an outside influence according to the rules - just like wind.
So the ball is taken to the hazard - it's now in the hazard so proceed as such.
The Rules about picking up a moving ball from water applies in a hazard only.
You can't pick up a moving ball otherwise.

Luck of the draw, Rub of The Green - call it what you will

Th CW shouldn't be there but neither should the twig or rock that causes a ball to bounce badly and end up in a hazard.
It could easily have happened the other way - if the stream had carried the ball THROUGH the hazard then you'd play it as it lies.....
 

Colin L

Tour Winner
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
5,269
Location
Edinburgh
Visit site
To my mind we're over thinking this....

The ball was on the fairway...
It rained and a stream of water carried the ball into a Water Hazard.
Water is not an outside influence according to the rules - just like wind.
So the ball is taken to the hazard - it's now in the hazard so proceed as such.
The Rules about picking up a moving ball from water applies in a hazard only.
You can't pick up a moving ball otherwise.

Luck of the draw, Rub of The Green - call it what you will

.

Which is where you were in Post #2, where I was in Post #5 and which I am now getting confirmation of.

But the conversation teasing out other possibilities is, for me at any rate, both interesting and helpful in establishing a firmer grasp of the interpretation and application of the rules. I hope it isn't too confusing for the OP who just wanted an answer to the situation he and his friend were in!
 

Colin L

Tour Winner
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
5,269
Location
Edinburgh
Visit site
OK, the guidance I got was quite clearly that these first responses were correct: the ball may not be stopped in motion and must be be played as it lies when it comes to rest. Our soft-hearted attempts to avoid the player being disadvantaged didn't get any support.

So the next time someone's ball gets carried away in flowing casual water, let's hope he gets a lucky and it ends up in a more favourable position.
 

duncan mackie

Money List Winner
Joined
Feb 19, 2012
Messages
11,135
Visit site
indeed

I accept that the ball moving in casual water is still a moving ball, and hasn't changed it's status in the way it does when it enters moving water in a water hazard, and that my view that the ball could have been removed from the casual water whilst moving would have been incorrect in this instance.
 

Hendo007

Challenge Tour Pro
Joined
May 16, 2011
Messages
724
Location
Wishaw, North Lanarkshire
Visit site
Can someone just confirm that if your ball lies in a large puddle in the middle of the fairway and your taking relief from casual water, do you need to mark the position of the ball in the puddle ?
 

Colin L

Tour Winner
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
5,269
Location
Edinburgh
Visit site
Can someone just confirm that if your ball lies in a large puddle in the middle of the fairway and your taking relief from casual water, do you need to mark the position of the ball in the puddle ?

No you don't. You are only required to mark a ball that you are going to lift and replace i.e. put back in the same place. In this situation you are going to drop your ball in a different place. [Rule 20-1 is your reference]

I'd say it's generally a good idea in relief situations to mark even if it's not required so that you have a reference point, but it's not always going to be practical. For instance, casual water might be too deep or you might not be retrieving your ball from it; you might be deeming a ball under a gorse bush unplayable and be able to pull the ball out with a club but be reluctant to crawl in to mark it.

I think it is a good idea always to leave your ball in place while you weigh up your options just in case the best option turns out to be playing the ball as it lies. (You may have seen a number of players in the Open opting to play from casual water in bunkers either because they wanted to avoid plugging were they to take a free drop or because the nearest point of relief would put them in a worse position.)
 
Last edited:

Hendo007

Challenge Tour Pro
Joined
May 16, 2011
Messages
724
Location
Wishaw, North Lanarkshire
Visit site
No you don't. You are only required to mark a ball that you are going to lift and replace i.e. put back in the same place. In this situation you are going to drop your ball in a different place. [Rule 20-1 is your reference]

I'd say it's generally a good idea in relief situations to mark even if it's not required so that you have a reference point, but it's not always going to be practical. For instance, casual water might be too deep or you might not be retrieving your ball from it; you might be deeming a ball under a gorse bush unplayable and be able to pull the ball out with a club but be reluctant to crawl in to mark it.

I think it is a good idea always to leave your ball in place while you weigh up your options just in case the best option turns out to be playing the ball as it lies. (You may have seen a number of players in the Open opting to play from casual water in bunkers either because they wanted to avoid plugging were they to take a free drop or because the nearest point of relief would put them in a worse position.)

Thanks, I thought that was the case but couldn't find the reference in the rules to be sure. Cheers
 

MashieNiblick

Tour Winner
Joined
Sep 26, 2010
Messages
3,710
Location
Berkshire
Visit site
No you don't. You are only required to mark a ball that you are going to lift and replace i.e. put back in the same place. In this situation you are going to drop your ball in a different place. [Rule 20-1 is your reference]

I'd say it's generally a good idea in relief situations to mark even if it's not required so that you have a reference point, but it's not always going to be practical. For instance, casual water might be too deep or you might not be retrieving your ball from it; you might be deeming a ball under a gorse bush unplayable and be able to pull the ball out with a club but be reluctant to crawl in to mark it.

I think it is a good idea always to leave your ball in place while you weigh up your options just in case the best option turns out to be playing the ball as it lies. (You may have seen a number of players in the Open opting to play from casual water in bunkers either because they wanted to avoid plugging were they to take a free drop or because the nearest point of relief would put them in a worse position.)

Agree best to leave the ball and then use a tee or something to mark nearest point of relief so you can check with your fcs/oppos that it is all Ok before lifting the ball.

On Saturday I was in some CW and it wasn't immediately obvious which side npr would be. By leaving the ball where it lay and putting a tee in the ground either side of the CW where the ball would be for me to play my next shot taking full relief, we were able to tell much more easily where the npr was. Then just marked the club length dropping zone from the relevent tee peg, retrieved the ball and Bob's your uncle.
 
Top