Red devil
Well-known member
Or Lisandro Martinez
clubchamp98
Journeyman Pro
I’d say it’s an orange!
Lots of players would be sent off if that’s a red!
Suprized he wasn’t given a yellow.
Lots of players would be sent off if that’s a red!
Suprized he wasn’t given a yellow.
Don Barzini
Assistant Pro
Does look a bit naughty
Yeah I’m one of the first people to want to elbow Richarlison in the throat, but VVD got away with one there. There was clearly intention to strike with the elbow. Should have been a red. He can consider himself lucky.
Norrin Radd
Tour Winner
I don't normally say much on referee decisions but on this occasion I'm going to.Really ? Why
Accidental isn’t it - no swinging off the arm etc etc
Phil what game were you watching as van dickhead chinned him with an elbow. Take your Liverpool glasses off and look at it properly.
Steve Wilkes
Well-known member
When I read this, I thought someone on here what would say what challenge, looked down a few posts and wasn't disappointed
Steve Wilkes
Well-known member
Just think of the uproar there would be if every Ref, and VAR official bar 2 or 3, lived within a 50 mile radius of London
Arthur Wedge
Well-known member
Every game ?
Is that like the yellow card that should have been handed out to Bergwall in the first leg
Did they not use VAR last night
Neilds
Assistant Pro
Ah yes, that system that the premier League stated, earlier this week, had made quite a few mistakes this season. Just because VAR says no is not the best argument ever
Every game ?
Is that like the yellow card that should have been handed out to Bergwall in the first leg
Did they not use VAR last night
Arthur Wedge
Well-known member
We have been told so many times thatAh yes, that system that the premier League stated, earlier this week, had made quite a few mistakes this season. Just because VAR says no is not the best argument ever
“Mistakes happen”
When it comes to incidents that happened last night it comes down to intent - and how do you judge intent
The idea that we get all the decisions is laughable
Can highlight a number of howlers that have cost us over the years
Just look at the high tackle from Doku
The handball from Odegaard
The offside goal in the Spurs game
I don’t believe that’s a red card from VVD , but it’s one of those calls that if the ref doesn’t give it then they don’t overturn it and if it’s given as a red they don’t overturn it
AmandaJR
Money List Winner
Whataboutery at its finest
Ross61
Challenge Tour Pro
It was explained that the reason the yellow card wasn’t given to Bergvall was because the ref played on. Whether you like the rule or not, the ref couldn’t give it.
Every game ?
Is that like the yellow card that should have been handed out to Bergwall in the first leg
Did they not use VAR last night
Get over it!
Arthur Wedge
Well-known member
Real reason Lucas Bergvall was not sent off during Tottenham vs Liverpool
Lucas Bergvall scored the only goal of the game as tottenham beat Liverpool in the Carabao Cup semi-final first leg
“Attwell did not play advantage. He did not think there was a foul. After Bergvall slides in to make the tackle, Attwell can be seen pointing at the ball, to say the Spurs midfielder won the ball, rather than committing a foul. he did not outstretch his arm to play advantage.”
And the ref can go back a book someone even if they gave advantage if it’s a “cynical tackle”
Let’s not also forget the player was off the pitch getting treatment when the player that injured scored
Ross61
Challenge Tour Pro
So what you’re saying is the ref made a mistake, in your opinion, as to whether it was a foul, so whether he was playing advantage or not he still wouldn’t have given him a yellow card. VAR can only intervene when they think it is a straight red.
So what is your gripe.
Yes Richarlison made a right fuss about the VVD elbow. But VVD looked straight at Richarlison before aiming his elbow at him upper cutting his chin, but that is ok as it is VVD on Richarlison and it suits you that the great Liverpool VVD is untouchable
Swango1980
Well-known member
I think they used VAR when everyone was talking about Martinez the other week. For those that thought he should have been sent off, I don't think VAR was considered a valid argument. In fairness, I can't remember if you felt Martinez should be sent off or not. Presumably you didn't, hence you are providing an objective argument in the VVD incident.
Every game ?
Is that like the yellow card that should have been handed out to Bergwall in the first leg
Did they not use VAR last night
Arthur Wedge
Well-known member
Yes the ref made a mistake and VAR couldn’t get involved
It was a clear yellow card imo and he should have been off and the player then went on to score whilst the player he took out was off the pitch
Someone made a statement that decisions always go in our favour when it’s clearly not true
And why did richarlison roll around holding his face when the contact was on his chest
I don’t believe VVD went to deliberately elbow Ricarlinson in the face but that’s just my opinion on that incident
As some believe it to be a clear red card then VAR can get involved - but didn’t
But then if the ref did send him off I don’t expect it would be overturned because it’s the refs interpretation of the incident
Don Barzini
Assistant Pro
Well Arthur, if nothing else, it’s amusing to see you (yet again) refusing to admit that Liverpool were on the fortunate end of a bad decision!
Arthur Wedge
Well-known member
Because I don’t think it was a fortunate decisionWell Arthur, if nothing else, it’s amusing to see you (yet again) refusing to admit that Liverpool were on the fortunate end of a bad decision!
Or maybe he was lucky not to get a yellow and a foul against him
Ex-referee delivers Virgil van Dijk red card verdict for his challenge on Spurs star in Liverpool's 4-0 win in the EFL Cup S/F
Former referee Keith Hackett has shared his thoughts on Liverpool captain Virgil van Dijk's potential red card incident during the EFL Cup semi-final against Tottenham Hotspur.
www.sportskeeda.com
Arthur Wedge
Well-known member
It’s one of those ones where if the ref gives a red then they don’t overturn it and if the ref doesn’t give a red they don’t get him to check it
It prob should have been a yellow and a foul but I don’t think it’s enough “violent conduct” to be a straight red
Don Barzini
Assistant Pro
Because I don’t think it was a fortunate decision
No. No, you never do, do you? That’s rather my point.
Arthur Wedge
Well-known member
That’s opinions in football eh
We all have them
Could say the same when it comes to your thoughts on Forest decisions
We all think our own team is hard done by and every one else gets away with it
There is no doubt decisions that could have gone either way in many games - that’s one of them
Similar threads
