• We'd like to take this opportunity to wish you a Happy Holidays and a very Merry Christmas from all at Golf Monthly. Thank you for sharing your 2025 with us!

The Footie Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 15344
  • Start date Start date
Watching it now on MOTD, and you have a point. That trip on Dennis was 100% a penalty, I can't believe they've not given it. The second one though was barely a nudge, not enough for a penalty that one. Brentford one probably is a penalty. And just seen the Gibbs-White one and that could easily have been given. Wow.

Must agree...VAR inconsistent....if DeBruyne's pen for City v. Fulham (he went down theatrically after a pause after being tapped on the ankle) is given then Forest should have been given at least one, if not two, of their own.
 
I've got a real issue with Gary Neville and his double standards.

First off as player he was a world class right back for almost two decades and criminally underrated. Defensively solid, a real leader and was one of the first full backs to overlap and be able to cross. His trophies and caps as a player say it all.

As a manager he's been a total failure. Got a job through nepotism at Valencia and failed badly. His time as Hodgson's assistant was a joke and oversaw two of the most embarrassing major tournaments in England's history. He's smartly realised he was useless and packed it in.

As owner of Salford City (backed by the guy who gave him the Valencia job) he's bought promotions and titles by vastly outspending all rivals, exactly what he accuses clubs like Chelsea and City of doing. He's sacked numerous managers, exactly what he preaches against on Sky Sports.

His hotel venture with the disgraced Ryan Giggs has been a failure and is millions in the red, yet he preaches about football clubs getting their finances right and avoiding debt. He's suddenly become some sort of self proclaimed moral compass for working class people yet admits to being a 'champagne socialist' and wears Stone Island shorts and jumpers worth £500 like some 50 year old going through a middle aged crisis.

As a pundit he's gone stale and is getting outwitted by Jamie Carragher on a regular basis and even occasionaly by Jamie Redknapp. He's gone away from the tactical side of it and is deluded to think he's the man to change the way football is run :unsure::ROFLMAO:

The stuff about Qatar is just more nonense and icing on the cake. His mate Becks is more dodgy than the Tories and picking up half a billion to be the face of it, yet he doesn't say a word. He's going out there picking up a fortune and cares about nothing workers deaths or rights, just about Gary Neville. The blokes nothing more than a rodent.
Not a fan then? ?
At least he hasn’t spat at a young girl tho ?‍♂️?
 
Watching it now on MOTD, and you have a point. That trip on Dennis was 100% a penalty, I can't believe they've not given it. The second one though was barely a nudge, not enough for a penalty that one. Brentford one probably is a penalty. And just seen the Gibbs-White one and that could easily have been given. Wow.

Exactly this. The push on Yates wasn’t a pen but their penalty is soft as he’s already going to ground when Hendo’s flappy arm appears. But no issue with it being given if he’d been consistent and given the Dennis and MGW ones.
 
The comments regarding the City penalty in here amaze me, sometimes I wonder what people were watching. I expected a controversial dive by KDB having read some comments in here. It was nothing of the sort. It was a clear penalty, and there were barely any complaints by Fulham players, manager, commentators or pundits. Usually a clear sign there is nothing controversial about it. He was kicked in the back of the leg, penalty.

The Cancelo one was also a penalty, and would then need to be a red. But, I do feel it is exactly the sort of challenge referees let go anywhere else on the pitch these days, saying it is a physical game and allowing play to flow.
 
The comments regarding the City penalty in here amaze me, sometimes I wonder what people were watching. I expected a controversial dive by KDB having read some comments in here. It was nothing of the sort. It was a clear penalty, and there were barely any complaints by Fulham players, manager, commentators or pundits. Usually a clear sign there is nothing controversial about it. He was kicked in the back of the leg, penalty.

The Cancelo one was also a penalty, and would then need to be a red. But, I do feel it is exactly the sort of challenge referees let go anywhere else on the pitch these days, saying it is a physical game and allowing play to flow.

He wasn’t kicked in the back of the leg. He was barely touched yet the swan dive came out.

I guarantee anywhere else on the pitch KDB stays on his feet and carries on
 
He wasn’t kicked in the back of the leg. He was barely touched yet the swan dive came out.

I guarantee anywhere else on the pitch KDB stays on his feet and carries on

According to Jermaine Jenas KDB was "Clever"??
 
The comments regarding the City penalty in here amaze me, sometimes I wonder what people were watching. I expected a controversial dive by KDB having read some comments in here. It was nothing of the sort. It was a clear penalty, and there were barely any complaints by Fulham players, manager, commentators or pundits. Usually a clear sign there is nothing controversial about it. He was kicked in the back of the leg, penalty.

The Cancelo one was also a penalty, and would then need to be a red. But, I do feel it is exactly the sort of challenge referees let go anywhere else on the pitch these days, saying it is a physical game and allowing play to flow.


????
 
So they can go through the back of Saka time after time with no punishment, first time he does he gets booked

Cucurella been pinged twice, ref played on once and got away with 2 more so far....
 
So they can go through the back of Saka time after time with no punishment, first time he does he gets booked

Cucurella been pinged twice, ref played on once and got away with 2 more so far....

Maybe it was because Sake's was a petulant retaliatory kick out with no attempt to win the ball?

In other news, VAR adds another contender for the most blatant penalty to be ignored... :rolleyes:
 
Top