Plane

[Deleted member 35927]

The 747 on the conveyor belt dilemma solved with Simcenter Amesim | Bsim Engineering

bsim-engineering.com

I am confused, you say it can't be proved either way then ask me to prove it then you post an article who conclusion is it will take off.

 

[Hazard]

Nice place to put the engines also handy for generating lift.

Very good, partially correct.

And to generate lift I think you’ll find you also need some forward airspeed (ie. speed through the air )

You’re welcome, hope you’ve learned something today

 

[RichA]

I am confused, you say it can't be proved either way then ask me to prove it then you post an article who conclusion is it will take off.

Funny that groups of scientists disagree and need to use theoretical modelling software to draw any kind of conclusion, yet you think it's obvious.
Almost makes you look like a er.

 

[Deleted member 35927]

Very good, partially correct.

And to generate lift I think you’ll find you also need some forward airspeed (ie. speed through the air )

You’re welcome, hope you’ve learned something today

Yes generated by the engines not the wheels , how fast the wheels are spinning is irrelevant, the plane takes off.

 

[Deleted member 35927]

Funny that groups of scientists disagree and need to use theoretical modelling software to draw any kind of conclusion, yet you think it's obvious.
Almost makes you look like a er.

Nice work my friend.

 

[Imurg]

If the Pilot turned the rudder....would the plane fall off the treadmill........

 

[Arthur Wedge]

I am confused, you say it can't be proved either way then ask me to prove it then you post an article who conclusion is it will take off.

So far all you have said is that people are wrong

Yet not shown anything to suggest they are wrong

That article showed two groups being split and still not coming up with any full blown conclusion without any definitive answer

So I’m sure you will provide us all the proof that you are right

 

[Pin-seeker]

Seriously guys,put your phones down

 

[Crow]

If the engines are providing enough power to move the plane fast enough then it will take off.
The conveyor belt effectively becomes the ground, moving at the same speed as the plane. The air is stationary so lift is generated.

 

[Deleted member 35927]

So far all you have said is that people are wrong

Yet not shown anything to suggest they are wrong

That article showed two groups being split and still not coming up with any full blown conclusion without any definitive answer

So I’m sure you will provide us all the proof that you are right

Ive said multiple times why it will take off. You offer up an article that agrees with me

 

[Hazard]

Yes generated by the engines not the wheels , how fast the wheels are spinning is irrelevant, the plane takes off.

Forget the wheels, red herring in this problem.

If your argument is always, ‘the plane takes off’ then you’ve clearly reached your intellectual limit and I’ve lost interest.

 

[Deleted member 35927]

Forget the wheels, red herring in this problem.

If your argument is always, ‘the plane takes off’ then you’ve clearly reached your intellectual limit and I’ve lost interest.

Oh dear, if all you have is insults I guess youre right

 

[SteveW86]

Banned already?

Forget the wheels, red herring in this problem.

If your argument is always, ‘the plane takes off’ then you’ve clearly reached your intellectual limit and I’ve lost interest.

 

[Deleted member 35927]

Banned already?

Dang , I was just getting to like him

 

[Arthur Wedge]

Banned already?

 

[Deleted member 36735]

If the engines are providing enough power to move the plane fast enough then it will take off.
The conveyor belt effectively becomes the ground, moving at the same speed as the plane. The air is stationary so lift is generated.

What?

The air is not moving relative to the wings.

 

[Fade and Die]

Banned already?

How did that happen?

 

[Deleted member 36735]

Ive said multiple times why it will take off. You offer up an article that agrees with me

You haven't at all.

Maybe you think you have, which would explain the nonsense

 

[Fade and Die]

Pete’s scientific advisor…..

 

[Deleted member 35927]

What?

The air is not moving relative to the wings.

The plane moves forward and takes off. It's not a car or a runner , the conveyor has no effect. The jets are interacting with the air. Id say take some time to read up on it, as opposed to making a snap decision.