Is this an issue and I haven't noticed?

[Mandofred]

Turned in a general play card yesterday +9. It should have raised my handicap since it knocked a counting score off the last 20 scores. I get up this morning and it has taken that score off and added yesterdays score.....but now they are only calculating 7 counting scores instead of 8. Seems like this happened a few weeks ago but I think it eventually made the change. It had always happened overnight before.

 

[Deleted member 15717]

The score that dropped off…was it part of a 36 hole day?

There used to be an issue with 36 holes on the same course, and the rounds would be displayed in the wrong order on your playing record

 

[Mandofred]

Nope. Just a regular 18 holes. I was looking forward to getting a shot back for this mornings senior rollup, but no recalculation. Funny thing is, they are only calculating 7 scores but when I count how many scores they have on the graph, there are only 19. They added my new score, took my oldest score off.....but somehow one other score is missing. No idea what is going on. This happened a couple of weeks ago as well. Everything used to happen overnight.

 

[Mandofred]

Just counted the list of the top 20 scores.....there are 20 there, but only 7 with the green dots for counting scores. Error in the system?

 

[Neilds]

I put a card in yesterday and it has recalculated properly- used the EG app

 

[Imurg]

Just counted the list of the top 20 scores.....there are 20 there, but only 7 with the green dots for counting scores. Error in the system?

Are you suggesting......WHS doesn't work?

 

[Deleted member 15717]

Just counted the list of the top 20 scores.....there are 20 there, but only 7 with the green dots for counting scores. Error in the system?

Definitely sounds like a glitch in your record….but probably has a reasonable explanation if you reach out to EG

 

[Mandofred]

 

[wjemather]

If you didn't have 2 rounds on the same day, then it's likely that one of the 20 shown is an unacceptable score and the 21st is actually the 20th counting score.

Edit: just checked and score number 4 on your record (from 7 March, not displayed on the graph) is marked as match play, so unacceptable. I assume this was done by your club due to 2 holes (17 & 18) not being played, so you'll need to take it up with them if there is an error.

 

[Deleted member 15717]

And there we have it. A thoroughly reasonable explanation

 

[clubchamp98]

And there we have it. A thoroughly reasonable explanation

If it’s flagged up as non acceptable shouldn’t it put the next acceptable one in automatically?
So his cap will be correct.

 

[clubchamp98]

Are you suggesting......WHS doesn't work?

Not so much WHS but the fact it relies so much on computers.!
When things go wrong the average golfer dosnt know why.

 

[wjemather]

If it’s flagged up as non acceptable shouldn’t it put the next acceptable one in automatically?
So his cap will be correct.

That's exactly what does happen. It just doesn't get displayed correctly in the app.

 

[Deleted member 29109]

Not so much WHS but the fact it relies so much on computers.!
When things go wrong the average golfer dosnt know why.

Surly a quick message to their HC secretary would have solved the mystery?

 

[nickh]

And there we have it. A thoroughly reasonable explanation

It's as if the WHS does work; who knew!!??!!

 

[Alan Clifford]

That's exactly what does happen. It just doesn't get displayed correctly in the app.

Should do on the website if you display more than the last 20 scores.

 

[wjemather]

Should do on the website if you display more than the last 20 scores.

All scores display in the list but only acceptable scores are included in the graph, and there is no indication in the list to show what is an acceptable score and what is not.

 

[Mandofred]

Checked with the pro....he didn't seem to know what was going on either. It would seem to me that if a score isn't ok....then it wouldn't be a counter anyway and the club shouldn't have allowed that to be a qualifying score. One of these was evidently off winter tees.

​

 

[wjemather]

Checked with the pro....he didn't seem to know what was going on either. It would seem to me that if a score isn't ok....then it wouldn't be a counter anyway and the club shouldn't have allowed that to be a qualifying score. One of these was evidently off winter tees.

Your handicap committee is your first point of contact with any handicapping queries. It would be unusual for the pro to be on that committee or be sufficiently knowledgeable about the handicap system to know what is going on or troubleshoot anything on the system.

Your club haven't allowed it to be a "qualifying" score - they have intentionally marked it as match play on the system in order to achieve that, but this is only visible on the admin portal, along with a ⊘ symbol instead of the score differential to highlight the score as not acceptable.


Being off winter tees doesn't automatically mean scores are not acceptable for handicapping. The winter tees at your course are rated, so there would need to be a good reason (e.g. exceptionally poor conditions) for scores from these tees to be made unacceptable.

 

[Springveldt]

Checked with the pro....he didn't seem to know what was going on either. It would seem to me that if a score isn't ok....then it wouldn't be a counter anyway and the club shouldn't have allowed that to be a qualifying score. One of these was evidently off winter tees.

View attachment 53109​

Don't you just love golf that you can go from shooting 93 to 73 just 5 days apart.