Pathetic Shark
Tour Rookie
Where you needed to stand when Michelle Wie was putting .....
Thread bingo
- Thread starter sunshine
- Start date
Pathetic Shark
Tour Rookie
A few more:-
Contestants on the Chase.
Is Lewis Hamilton a nob.
Who should be keeping wicket for England.
Should the Open be played at a non-links venue.
Contestants on the Chase.
Is Lewis Hamilton a nob.
Who should be keeping wicket for England.
Should the Open be played at a non-links venue.
BiMGuy
LIV Bot, (But Not As Big As Mel) ?
Jack’s major record is impressive, but was the talent pool wasn’t as deep and he was able to play for much longer.
Major’s are obviously important, but only part of the story.
Boomy
Well-known member
Jack is the GOAT.
Look at the differences from Tiger’s era to Jacks era - the equipment, technology, greens quality, fairway quality, the support teams around modern players… if majors are only part of it then Jack would win it hands down for off course behaviours let’s be honest here. Totally respect what Tiger brought to the game but Jack wins it for me.
Imurg
The Grinder Of Pars (Semi Crocked)
Rule 1 of Comparing Era Club....................
You can't...
You can't...
Last edited:
Orikoru
Tour Winner
We shouldn't be getting into this here but I just wanted to say that this part is totally irrelevant if we're talking about who was the best golfer, and shows you're clutching at straws to swing it for Jack.
Personally I'm Team Tiger, but as I'm only 35 I recognise that Jack was before my time so I'm biased and my opinion is pretty worthless in the debate. But I still think the fact Tiger shagged around and drove intoxicated doesn't make him a less great golfer. ??
D
Deleted member 23270
Guest
Tiger could have become the GOAT but he blew it.
D
Deleted member 23270
Guest
Good one!
Boomy
Well-known member
We shouldn't be getting into this here but I just wanted to say that this part is totally irrelevant if we're talking about who was the best golfer, and shows you're clutching at straws to swing it for Jack.
Personally I'm Team Tiger, but as I'm only 35 I recognise that Jack was before my time so I'm biased and my opinion is pretty worthless in the debate. But I still think the fact Tiger shagged around and drove intoxicated doesn't make him a less great golfer. ??
You need to read further back up the thread to realise why I put that in there - as a point of difference to ‘major wins just being part of the story’ It’s not me who was or is clutching at straws ?
I’m not Team Jack or Tiger, I’m Team Golf - but in my humble opinion, taking into accounts all the factors, then Jack is The GOAT (at present)
Orikoru
Tour Winner
Yeah but surely he meant dominance of the PGA tour etc as opposed to just majors. i.e. still golf-related.
BiMGuy
LIV Bot, (But Not As Big As Mel) ?
Tiger and Jack were both playing the same equipment and courses as their peers, so an irrelevant point.
Tiger dominated like no one else. His stats from 1999 to 2009 are other worldly. Pretty much every stat other than Major wins puts him above Jack. And Tiger had all 4 major trophies at the same time.
And he did all that while spending $250k a weekend on hookers in Vegas.
Boomy
Well-known member
Tiger not streaks ahead with anything there. Some basic numbers which would highlight Jack as The GOAT. Without even having to mention anyones off course behaviour.
Last edited:
Beedee
Assistant Pro
I wondered how long it would be before this thread left the lists behind and became a debate / argument / slanging match (delete as applicable).
Was longer than I expected.
Was longer than I expected.
Pants
Challenge Tour Pro
Professional golfers clubs are the same as Joe Public's.
Voyager EMH
Slipper Wearing Plucker of Pheasants
Walter Hagen's major wins were pre-Augusta. Take away Jack's and Tiger's Masters wins and you get
Nicklaus 12
Hagen 11
Woods 10
Nicklaus 12
Hagen 11
Woods 10
IanM
Journeyman Pro
- Joined
- May 18, 2009
- Messages
- 12,338
- Location
- Monmouthshire, UK via Guildford!
Just because you're wearing tweed, is your etiquette good?
Just cos you're dressed like a yob, is your etiquette bad?
??
Just cos you're dressed like a yob, is your etiquette bad?
??
IanM
Journeyman Pro
- Joined
- May 18, 2009
- Messages
- 12,338
- Location
- Monmouthshire, UK via Guildford!
Should you be allowed on a golf course unless you can quote verbatim from the "Decisions" book?
If you can quote from it, do you play most of your golf as a single?
If you can quote from it, do you play most of your golf as a single?
D
Deleted member 1147
Guest
Rory McIlroy:-
Frustrating
Doesn’t care
Practice wedges
Etc
Etc
Frustrating
Doesn’t care
Practice wedges
Etc
Etc
Backsticks
Assistant Pro
I dont know the answer, but a stat missing to compare Jack and Cat is win ratio in pro events. Jack is a little behind in tour event wins, but I think was more or less injury free throughout a long career. Tiger missed a lot for various reasons, yet has still exceeded Jack there. For me, it a critical measure, as it really shows who was clearly better than the field of his day. If Jack wins that one, though, undoubtedly it would be Jack as the Goat in my view. But if Tiger is better on that one, then it much closer or could even edge Tiger as the better golfer, Jack higher in some measure due to longevity rather than greater golfer.
BiMGuy
LIV Bot, (But Not As Big As Mel) ?
Have we had a “When’s international men’s day?” post today yet?
Every day ?
