Pin-seeker
Well-known member
Probably felt like they HAD to put a Liverpool player in to avoid the uproar from their supporters.
Should have just put Nunez in for “bantz”.
Should have just put Nunez in for “bantz”.
PaulMdj
Well-known member
3 players from 3 teams below Lpool in that list, if 1 player from Lpool deserves to be there then I’d go with Van Dyke as he’s been their stand out player imo.
PaulMdj
Well-known member
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
That’s not really how it works Paul
Phil Foden for me is player of the year, to stand out like he has in that Manchester City side is impressive.
Cole Palmer is young player of the year in my opinion, again as said before, where would Chelsea be without him.
Honourable mentions for Rice and Odegaard as well
Just had another look, just some outstanding performances this year, Isak has had a great season, Haaland injured for a good spell and still top goal scorer, Saka on his day as good as any winger.
Cole Palmer is young player of the year in my opinion, again as said before, where would Chelsea be without him.
Honourable mentions for Rice and Odegaard as well
Just had another look, just some outstanding performances this year, Isak has had a great season, Haaland injured for a good spell and still top goal scorer, Saka on his day as good as any winger.
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
Saka just had too many average games for me (compared to last seasons form).Phil Foden for me is player of the year, to stand out like he has in that Manchester City side is impressive.
Cole Palmer is young player of the year in my opinion, again as said before, where would Chelsea be without him.
Honourable mentions for Rice and Odegaard as well
Just had another look, just some outstanding performances this year, Isak has had a great season, Haaland injured for a good spell and still top goal scorer, Saka on his day as good as any winger.
PaulMdj
Well-known member
Stats wise he’s the best defender in the PL, look at the injury problems they’ve had in defence and the youngsters brought in, all the while he’s been the consistent.That’s not really how it works Paul
As for bad games, yes, him and every other player on the list had had them.
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
Which stats are they?
PaulMdj
Well-known member
I’m sure you’re capable of using google but Here’s a couple:
Arthur Wedge
Active member
VVD has been key to the team that’s turned it around after last season and challenged for 4 trophies winning 1 he has been ever present throughout the season despite multiple changes around him - he has returned to near his best this season
The winner imo will be between Foden and Rice
Rice has taken his game up a level this season and it’s prob very close between him and Rodri to who is the best in that role
Foden stepped up when KDB was out and scored some key goals
Because of when it’s voted I think Rice may just grab it but both would be worthy winners , the list is prob about spot on when you look at the season
I’m surprised Haaland is there because I think his season has been a drop from last year and would have expect Rodri in there
The winner imo will be between Foden and Rice
Rice has taken his game up a level this season and it’s prob very close between him and Rodri to who is the best in that role
Foden stepped up when KDB was out and scored some key goals
Because of when it’s voted I think Rice may just grab it but both would be worthy winners , the list is prob about spot on when you look at the season
I’m surprised Haaland is there because I think his season has been a drop from last year and would have expect Rodri in there
I have to question that list though, Paul. How can a player who has barely played a game since the autumn feature in ninth place?
PaulMdj
Well-known member
No idea mate, a lot of the comments against VVD are purely based on the team he plays for, but they are in 3rd and up to 3 weeks ago still in the title race.
Looking at them, imo, he’s been their stand out player.
Edit: Reading the link again @Billysboots it was based on defenders who’ve played over 400 minutes this season and the ratings they’d received in games, shows on another level how much you’s have missed him.
Last edited by a moderator:
Okay, folks. Thread has been locked briefly to allow me to tidy it up and delete a few tit for tat posts. Please let’s keep it civil and move on.
Thanks.
Thanks.
PJ87
Journeyman Pro
Only one I'd say is actually young is maino
Udogie is pushing it at 21
23/24? Oh come on
Tashyboy
Please don’t ask to see my tatts 👍
When Rice has gone on record and said that Rodri is the main man and he don’t get nominated there is something wrong. Have a check how long it is since City last lost with Rodri in the team.
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
What is the age limit?
PJ87
Journeyman Pro
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
Personally I’d go 21.
But definitely not 23/24.
Swango1980
Well-known member
You may be right. After all, Keane thinks his general play is League 2 standard. I trust his judgement
PJ87
Journeyman Pro
You may be right. After all, Keane thinks his general play is League 2 standard. I trust his judgement
Keane's a bit harsh on himself, he could cut it in the championship these days just about in his prime
