To be honest on last year's I just judged it on whether they actually were a good signing then you get a point. I didn't try and judge who was the actual one best signing.
Like Voyager, love the thread but won't be entering - not so much that I'm out of touch, more that I've never really been in touch. But certainly found it interesting that of 18 posts, only three had put Forest in the the bottom 3. Let's hope you're all (well, nearly all) right.