• We'd like to take this opportunity to wish you a Happy Holidays and a very Merry Christmas from all at Golf Monthly. Thank you for sharing your 2025 with us!

Clubs missing, presumed unnecessary

rosecott

rosecott

Money List Winner
Joined
May 12, 2011
Messages
7,829
Location
Notts
Visit site
We have a Seniors trophy competition which is played annually at this time of year. The trophy was presented by a past member who had to give up playing some years ago, and he asked that players be limited to carrying and using only 4 clubs and a putter.

We played for the trophy yesterday. I predicted, based on results from previous years, that scores would differ very little from scores played using full sets.

Scores for Division 1 prize money winners were 39/37/35/34 points compared to 39/38/36/35 from the most recent stableford played with a full set. Division 2 scores were 36/34/34/34 yesterday compared to 38/37/35/31 with a full set.

Do we really need all those clubs we lug around the course?
 
Oddsocks said:
I don’t think we do, but more so I also think the pace of play is always quicker with half sets.
Click to expand...

We played a 5 club comp last week. I ended up on 35 points after a silly double on the last that had nothing to do with having the wrong clubs.

I reckon there were 3 times in the round i wish I'd had another club. And 2 of those were as the result of a poor previous shot that meant I had left myself a distance in that I wasn't anticipating.
 
rosecott said:
We have a Seniors trophy competition which is played annually at this time of year. The trophy was presented by a past member who had to give up playing some years ago, and he asked that players be limited to carrying and using only 4 clubs and a putter.

We played for the trophy yesterday. I predicted, based on results from previous years, that scores would differ very little from scores played using full sets.

Scores for Division 1 prize money winners were 39/37/35/34 points compared to 39/38/36/35 from the most recent stableford played with a full set. Division 2 scores were 36/34/34/34 yesterday compared to 38/37/35/31 with a full set.

Do we really need all those clubs we lug around the course?
Click to expand...

I regularly play with only 8 clubs and it doesn't affect my ability to score at all. Definitely makes me more decisive.

I won our 3 club comp last year and came 3rd this year 😂
 
Its a good question.
In each division scores were 0.75 shots better. So on the face of it, there is a clear benefit to full bags.
More interesting possibly would be the average scores per division rather than the best ones. Would you have them ?
Best scores are biased towards those who coped well with the limitation - either through skill or luck, or good day with the putter. I will guess the averages of all players show a greater than 0.75 shot loss.
I think we all carry some clubs that are for occasional use. But help when rare. I have a 60 wedge only for rare shortsided pitches over a bunker or hard or wet sand in bunkers. Used once in 3 rounds maybe. But when I use it, I benefit from it.
 
Totally agree Jim. When carrying in the winter, I'll only have 5/6 clubs in the bag and probably score similarly to using a full set but, of course, I'll be far fresher on the finishing holes. I actually quite enjoy "manufacturing" shots. I rarely have more than 12/13 clubs in my trolley bag as I rarely need any more and, apparently, having a full set on a trolley would make me a slow player ;)
 
I played today with 14 clubs for the first time in many many many months - 34 points and I didn't use 5 of the clubs I lugged to the course

I usually take 9 or 10 in a carry bag and sometimes still don't use all of them

14 is too many
 
I find when I play with just odd number irons I always leave myself a 8/6 iron yardage.
this is good for your game it makes you think more.
14 is to many imo, 20yd club gapping would be better.
me playing a 60* is very rare but it’s in the bag just incase.
 
I very much doubt anyone would score as well if restricted to one club.
Equally I doubt many would notice a reduction from 14 to 13 clubs.
The question arises is how many clubs can you carry before you are on average a shot a round worse. As most people have a dispersion of well over 10 shots between their best and worst scores it would take quite a number of rounds to work it out.
 
I see no reason for the vast majority of amateurs to carry more than 10 clubs. There simply isn't a significant enough distance gap (<<10 yards) between consecutive irons/hybrids, and they generally can't hit any iron longer than a 6 or 7.

However, personally, I'd carry 17 clubs if I could - extra wood, long iron/hybrid and wedge.
 
Just played a three clubs plus putter comp at my club this morning. 22pts after 11 holes, then only 6pts in the remaining seven holes. There were only a half dozen shots where I felt another club would have made a significant difference.
 
clubchamp98 said:
I find when I play with just odd number irons I always leave myself a 8/6 iron yardage.
this is good for your game it makes you think more.
14 is to many imo, 20yd club gapping would be better.
me playing a 60* is very rare but it’s in the bag just incase.
Click to expand...

Yeah I think if we were able to buy loft gaps we 'wanted' for irons then instead of 5-SW being 8 clubs with an average of 4.5 degree gapping as I have, I would be happy with an average 6.5 degree gapping and just need 6 iron clubs and not notice any missed gaps in my distances

Add putter, driver, FW & hybrid and only 10 clubs needed
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

HomerJSimpson
Roll Up Group Handicaps
31 32 33
Replies
646
Views
34K
HomerJSimpson
HomerJSimpson
RangeRat
Clubs not uploading WHS data from competitions
2 3
Replies
41
Views
3K
Swango1980
S
Golfnut1957
Three Day Golf Trip
Replies
5
Views
1K
Golfnut1957
Golfnut1957
D
How many Divisions do you have
6 7 8
Replies
145
Views
18K
Bdill93
Bdill93
N
Filling the Gaps
Replies
6
Views
5K
ntommo
N
Top