Can you practice in an adjacent bunker to your ball ?

Skytot

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 20, 2022
Messages
552
Visit site
I’ve just watched a video with Golf pro Gary Martin . Where he says you can go in a near by bunker ( not where your actual ball is ) and take practice swings hitting the sand . My mate who is pretty clued on on rules disagrees with him .
 

Steven Rules

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 18, 2022
Messages
691
Visit site
Old Decision 13-4/0.5 (pre-2019) unambiguously prohibited touching the sand with a club when making a practice swing in a similar bunker. As Colin has said, the current Rules only prohibit touching the sand with a practice swing in the same bunker the ball is in.
 
D

Deleted member 29109

Guest
I think we’d need to be having a chat about rule 5.6.
 

clubchamp98

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Jan 23, 2014
Messages
17,869
Location
Liverpool
Visit site
I think that should be changed.
green staff have enough to do without letting players practice in bunkers.
so many lazy golfers don’t rake them.

What do you learn hitting sand in a different bunker?
it might be dry and the one your in gets the run off the green so completely different.
 
D

Deleted member 29109

Guest
Why’s that?
Because it’s unnecessary to walk into a bunker, take a practice swing and then have to rake the bunker, possibly clean your club etc.

To me that is an unreasonable delay.
 

SwingsitlikeHogan

Major Champion
Joined
Jul 24, 2012
Messages
33,274
Visit site
And if it’s not delaying anything or anybody?
Is it not delaying the progression to completion of the round?

Beggars the question whether or not rules penalising undue delay relate only to delaying the play of others, or whether you are not permitted to unduly delay your own round irrespective of others.
 

Backsticks

Assistant Pro
Banned
Joined
Aug 7, 2012
Messages
3,852
Visit site
EVERYTHING anyone does other than swinging at the ball slows down play. Putting on and off gloves, lasering, kneeling to survey a putt, walking up a bit to see the lie of the green, etc. It all adds. Its why the the pace of play has decreased consistently. Anything can be criticised if you want to play the slows-down-play-card. Thats too easy. If we want to ban things on that basis, then you have to ban all the superfluous stuff that has been added over the last 30 years, not just cherry pick the ones you dont do yourself, and complain about others doing them. If someone wants a practice swing in an adjacent bunker, that their choice.
 

Steven Rules

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 18, 2022
Messages
691
Visit site
I think we’d need to be having a chat about rule 5.6.
Ok. Let's have a chat about 5.6.

To me, pre-shot routines (including practice swings in other bunkers) would fall under the heading of 5.6b 'prompt pace of play' which covers the time taken to 'prepare for and make each stroke'. While there are recommendations for how to achieve a prompt pace of play, there is no penalty for a breach of 5.6b unless the Committee has adopted a Local Rule setting a pace of play policy.

The 'unreasonable delay' part of the Rule (5.6a), which some have latched onto in this thread, covers a very different set of examples - seeking help from a referee, becoming injured or ill, stopping to get food or drink, consulting with others to determine whether to play out a hole after a normal suspension, returning to another part of the course to retrieve a lost club, searching longer than three minutes for a ball - and doesn't seem relevant to the discussion here.
 

Steven Rules

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 18, 2022
Messages
691
Visit site
Because it’s unnecessary to walk into a bunker, take a practice swing and then have to rake the bunker, possibly clean your club etc.

To me that is an unreasonable delay.
Is it not delaying the progression to completion of the round?

Beggars the question whether or not rules penalising undue delay relate only to delaying the play of others, or whether you are not permitted to unduly delay your own round irrespective of others.
There's a lot of (unnecessary) negative energy being spent and a lot of theorising around this 'practice swing in another bunker' scenario. It has only been permitted for 4.5 years and, in that time, I have never seen it happen. I am not going to use up too much emotion worrying about it.
 
D

Deleted member 29109

Guest
There's a lot of (unnecessary) negative energy being spent and a lot of theorising around this 'practice swing in another bunker' scenario. It has only been permitted for 4.5 years and, in that time, I have never seen it happen. I am not going to use up too much emotion worrying about it.

Where is the negative energy.

Just because people are asking questions or taking a different view doesn’t mean there is negativity or require you to use up any emotion. Whatever that actually means.

Can we not ask questions or challenge an opinion now without people getting upset?
 

Boscoe55

New member
Joined
Aug 6, 2023
Messages
1
Visit site
To me the bigger issue for this question, at least around greenside bunkers, is whether it is good for golf to splash greens with more sand from practice swings.
 

Crow

Crow Person
Joined
Nov 14, 2010
Messages
9,366
Location
Leicestershire
Visit site
There's a lot of (unnecessary) negative energy being spent and a lot of theorising around this 'practice swing in another bunker' scenario. It has only been permitted for 4.5 years and, in that time, I have never seen it happen. I am not going to use up too much emotion worrying about it.

That leads me to ask why the rule was ever changed in the first place?

Most people understood the old rule and happily got on with it, neither you nor I have ever seen anyone do it since it was introduced, it's just created another area of discord in golfers' minds.

Some recent changes to the rules have seemed to me like tinkering with them for the sake of it rather than anything useful.
 

Mel Smooth

Hacker
Joined
May 4, 2017
Messages
4,655
Visit site
I actually don't get the obsession with slow play - some groups will be inherently faster than others, some slower, but as long as a round is completed in 4 to 4 and a half hours (Fourball) then is it really an issue.

Just because some people can play 18 in 3 hours, doesn't mean everybody can.

Watched the video the OP mentions myself and mentioned it to a few guys at the club yesterday - none of them were aware of this rule, but it's one worth knowing especially if you're playing a course you're not familiar with or after some rain atc.
 
Top