Afghanistan

[woofers]

We would need to be there for 200* years to change the religious ideology of a country such as Afghanistan.


*Made up number as all I know is it would take generations.

Why would we want to change the religious ideology of any country? We haven’t in other middle eastern states.

 

[harpo_72]

Why would we want to change the religious ideology of any country? We haven’t in other middle eastern states.

Looking a little deeper the ideology is fundamentally sound, where religion is weak is in it’s interpretation. So no need to change the ideology but to educate people to interpret the message.
The question is have the Taliban, read and interpreted the teachings differently to their previous interpretations ? If they have then women will have choices freedoms and respect.. time will tell though.

 

[IanM]

Why would we want to change the religious ideology of any country? We haven’t in other middle eastern states.

"Looney fringe ideology" I assume he meant, not the religion.

 

[Deleted member 29109]

"Looney fringe ideology" I assume he meant, not the religion.

Yes.

 

[Jensen]

Sadly I don’t think the Taliban have changed their interpretation. I think it’s all a PR exercise to appease the rest of the world.
When things start to settle down, people will disappear and women will be treated like third class citizens. Why else, if true, have they gone door to door identifying those that helped the West. If all was forgiven, then why the need to identify them.

 

[harpo_72]

Sadly I don’t think the Taliban have changed their interpretation. I think it’s all a PR exercise to appease the rest of the world.
When things start to settle down, people will disappear and women will be treated like third class citizens. Why else, if true, have they gone door to door identifying those that helped the West. If all was forgiven, then why the need to identify them.

I think your right, but let’s wait till they get over confident and see how good the drones are.

 

[SocketRocket]

The Taliban isn't a single homogenous political force, it's a group of disparate tribal groups who will have different ideologies on the way Sharia law should be applied to people's lives.

 

[Bunkermagnet]

Doesn't surpeise me we have more incompetance being uncovered. However, our Governments failings aside, how can we expect a country that is basically 5 clans work together for the collective good when we all saw how divided and polarised we were with a referendum that had only 2 sides?.
We should never have gone there in the first place.

 

[Old Skier]

The stirring of the press and the shear band wagon jumpers are about. If any thinks that such a delicate matter would be discussed over an unsecured telephone line is either thick or just stirring for a reaction. Well you have one. The only question was "Why was he on holiday" .

 

[PhilTheFragger]

We need to keep politics out of this thread, tricky I know, but …….

 

[Deleted member 1147]

The Taliban isn't a single homogenous political force, it's a group of disparate tribal groups who will have different ideologies on the way Sharia law should be applied to people's lives.

Tribal sects seems to be the biggest issue with the whole of the Middle East.
You call somewhere a country, but that country is then split into tribes, each of which has a historic hatred of another.
and of course some tribes cross national boundaries.

 

[ger147]

Tribal sects seems to be the biggest issue with the whole of the Middle East.
You call somewhere a country, but that country is then split into tribes, each of which has a historic hatred of another.
and of course some tribes cross national boundaries.

Sounds a bit like the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland...

 

[SocketRocket]

Sounds a bit like the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland...

Your joking?

 

[Fade and Die]

Sounds a bit like the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland...

You think that GB is like Afghanistan?? Wow!

 

[ger147]

You think that GB is like Afghanistan?? Wow!

No, it was the reference to tribes??

 

[ExRabbit]

No, it was the reference to tribes??

Another wow - can't remember seeing raping and pillaging over here recently.

Maybe it's going to be as 'good' as this.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/...-wasn-t-all-raping-and-pillaging-1643969.html

But somehow I doubt it.

 

[SocketRocket]

No, it was the reference to tribes??

You've really got to be joking!

 

[Jamesbrown]

Interesting link.
I was wondering if we would treat Afghanistan differently if had a precious resource, as we do another country that is ruled by Sharia law, carries out public beheadings and floggings, has strict dress codes, bans alcohol, treats women as second class citizens, was linked to 9/11 and hunts down and murders it’s critics. But we seem to think that the way that country and its rulers operate as acceptable.

People would. But it’s not on the news or in the papers.
Injustices and atrocities across the globe but people only care about what’s on trend.

 

[SocketRocket]

People would. But it’s not on the news or in the papers.
Injustices and atrocities across the globe but people only care about what’s on trend.

What people in general care about across the globe is living their lives by the path of least resistance, what else do you suggest.

 

[Tashyboy]

Sat outside Ely cathedral. It is very busy above my head with massive transport aircraft. Anything to do with afghanistan and Mildehall or not. Or is it the norm.