2019 Cricket

D

Deleted member 18588

Guest
Woakes should have played

For me Curran seem a more skiddy bowler who gets more swing and lateral movement - certainly not suited to quick hard bouncing pitches but more to England conditions and sub continent but agree about him being in because of the left hand different angle and of course because he is a “Surrey boy”

I believe Woakes may be injured as it was reported that he didn't even bowl in the pre-Test nets.

Sorry but whilst I realise Buttler did well in Tests last year I remain unconvinced but may still be worth persevering with at number 5.

As for the Overtons you need not worry about them being called up.

If Rashid gets picked ahead of Leach then Somerset players clearly haven't got a chance!
 

HomerJSimpson

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Messages
73,206
Location
Bracknell - Berkshire
Visit site
Don't buy into this "Surrey Boy" thing anymore or why isn't there more players in the test side or being pushed from development squads? None of the selectors have any affiliation to the county so where is this bias being driven from? Surely the honest and simple answer is with all the focus on one day cricket the test barrel is having the bottom if it well and truly scraped as there isn't enough test level players out there and the ECB have never planned for the future
 

fundy

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
27,053
Location
Herts/Beds border
Visit site
That'll be the end of Foakes' test career if he is injured. There seems to have been far too much chat about him being almost an inconvenience.

strange isnt it, looked far more a test batter than the other two today, plenty in comm box and set up be happy to go back to one of the other two though
 

Tongo

Journeyman Pro
Joined
May 20, 2013
Messages
3,461
Location
Southampton
Visit site
strange isnt it, looked far more a test batter than the other two today, plenty in comm box and set up be happy to go back to one of the other two though

England set up still smacks of if you face fits. Bairstow's clearly does even though his record over the last 18 months to 2 years is bordering on poor. Throw in the histrionics and rhetoric when he got that 100 in Sri Lanka and there's a whiff of entitlement about him.

I dont think any other test playing nation would be so unwelcoming to a player of Foakes' class as England. But, as i've said before, the team is a series of compromises.
 
D

Deleted member 15344

Guest
I believe Woakes may be injured as it was reported that he didn't even bowl in the pre-Test nets.

Sorry but whilst I realise Buttler did well in Tests last year I remain unconvinced but may still be worth persevering with at number 5.

As for the Overtons you need not worry about them being called up.

If Rashid gets picked ahead of Leach then Somerset players clearly haven't got a chance!

Certainly Buttler has earned the chance to cement the place but will need to build on last year , know he is working very hard on it but understand not being convinced especially after his first stint in the team but think he has matured a bit more

The Overtons are both superb bowlers with Jamie hitting 90mph regulary and Craig excellent when the clouds come in - both have a lot of heart and will keep going all day but i think certain counties players just won’t get a look in - if they played for Surrey or a Yorkshire then they would be in the team but who knows maybe I will be surprised.

I don’t think Leach will play much more for England - I don’t know why they don’t seem to trust him , maybe it’s because he can’t swing a bat - but it’s as much a puzzle as why they ignored Hildreath all through his career

It’s a shame some counties and some players do get ignored despite being more than good enough - Foster , Davies and Read behind the stumps three perfect examples
 

fundy

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
27,053
Location
Herts/Beds border
Visit site
Don't buy into this "Surrey Boy" thing anymore or why isn't there more players in the test side or being pushed from development squads? None of the selectors have any affiliation to the county so where is this bias being driven from? Surely the honest and simple answer is with all the focus on one day cricket the test barrel is having the bottom if it well and truly scraped as there isn't enough test level players out there and the ECB have never planned for the future

i take it you think curran is one of the best 3 seamers available to england then?
 

Dando

Q-School Graduate
Banned
Joined
Nov 3, 2014
Messages
10,613
Location
Se London
Visit site
So the then captain of Kent talked up a Kent player. "Quelle surprise!"

I am sorry but if he's not opening for his county there is little else to suggest that he is a Test opener.

In recent times our selection process has been all over the place with choices for the red ball team being far too heavily influenced by form in the white ball game.

Buttler is one of the very best one day batsmen in the world but is there really much to support his call up to the Test side.

Rashid is a similar case and, I am sorry, but I really cannot see Curran as even a first change seamer in the longer format although in limited overs he is a big plus.

Square pegs and round holes come to mind.

Key still isn’t as bad as Alec Stewart who thinks every single player in Surrey is a world beater
 
D

Deleted member 15344

Guest
strange isnt it, looked far more a test batter than the other two today, plenty in comm box and set up be happy to go back to one of the other two though
Yep - Prior stating that he thinks Bairstow should be behind the stumps and Foakes is causing an issue - I don’t understand how the best keeper and a guy who scores runs causes a problem - someone needs to tell Bairstow that he needs to concentrate on his batting and sort out the number 3 spot
 

fundy

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
27,053
Location
Herts/Beds border
Visit site
Yep - Prior stating that he thinks Bairstow should be behind the stumps and Foakes is causing an issue - I don’t understand how the best keeper and a guy who scores runs causes a problem - someone needs to tell Bairstow that he needs to concentrate on his batting and sort out the number 3 spot

the big cheese lol prob best i dont state my opinion on him on a public forum haha. Last player he thought was causing an issue was the best batter wed had for a decade
 
D

Deleted member 18588

Guest
the big cheese lol prob best i dont state my opinion on him on a public forum haha. Last player he thought was causing an issue was the best batter wed had for a decade

Personally I'd take Prior's opinion on wicket keeping with a very large pinch of salt.

His own abilities with the gloves were, to say the least, limited.
 
Top