Waterproof jacket and trousers recommendations

Thanks for the recommendations all. I think I’ll go cheaper on the trousers because I won’t wear them as often, probably go for the craghoppers, and then spend a bit more on a jacket. Much more likely to wear a waterproof jacket more often with an unexpected yes shower or 2.

Is there such a thing as a waterproof jacket that doesn’t make you sweaty on warmer days, but also keeps you warm on cold days?
 
timd77 said:
Thanks for the recommendations all. I think I’ll go cheaper on the trousers because I won’t wear them as often, probably go for the craghoppers, and then spend a bit more on a jacket. Much more likely to wear a waterproof jacket more often with an unexpected yes shower or 2.

Is there such a thing as a waterproof jacket that doesn’t make you sweaty on warmer days, but also keeps you warm on cold days?
Click to expand...
Ermm…I also have a Craghoppers jacket that I use for running when raining, it’s also breathable, it was that good I got another one in a size up for Golf.

 
For value for money I’ve never found anything to beat FJ.
Quality stuff in every department, had same waterproof trousers I think for easy 5 years
 
I've had Craghoppers waterproof trousers. The only flaw I found with them was that the fly wasn't a waterproof zip so it leaked uncomfortably in moderate rain.
30,000 ft waterproofs on Amazon are good value. The winter trousers are great.
 
I have Sunice Gore-Tex waterproofs I bought from Sports Direct a few years ago and still going strong. They did seem to leak a bit at first until I realised I could reactivate the GoreTex in a tumble dryer (very difficult in a heat pump as it keeps turning off).
Comfortable and waterproof now. I also have the Galvin Green "Captain Birdseye" hat which was definitely a good investment.
 
PaulMdj said:
Ermm…I also have a Craghoppers jacket that I use for running when raining, it’s also breathable, it was that good I got another one in a size up for Golf.

Click to expand...
Apologies - when I posted the Craghoppers Trousers, I tried to find the best priced link and it seems as if Craghoppers have walking (rain repellant ) and actual waterproof so here's a better link to the waterproof trousers which I have - though a little dearer

ligo.co.uk

Craghoppers Men's Kiwi Pro II Waterproof Trousers | Black

Stay dry and comfortable with the Men's Kiwi Pro II Waterproof Trousers in Black. Durable, breathable, and perfect for hiking, trekking, and all-weather outdoor activities.
ligo.co.uk ligo.co.uk
 
phils226 said:
Apologies - when I posted the Craghoppers Trousers, I tried to find the best priced link and it seems as if Craghoppers have walking (rain repellant ) and actual waterproof so here's a better link to the waterproof trousers which I have - though a little dearer

ligo.co.uk

Craghoppers Men's Kiwi Pro II Waterproof Trousers | Black

Stay dry and comfortable with the Men's Kiwi Pro II Waterproof Trousers in Black. Durable, breathable, and perfect for hiking, trekking, and all-weather outdoor activities.
ligo.co.uk ligo.co.uk
Click to expand...
I believe your initial post was in response to @timd77 👍🏻
 
I have some craghopper fleece lined trousers which are waterproof and cosy. They are amazing in winter, the only trousers I wear from Dec - Mar.
 
timd77 said:
Thanks for the recommendations all. I think I’ll go cheaper on the trousers because I won’t wear them as often, probably go for the craghoppers, and then spend a bit more on a jacket. Much more likely to wear a waterproof jacket more often with an unexpected yes shower or 2.

Is there such a thing as a waterproof jacket that doesn’t make you sweaty on warmer days, but also keeps you warm on cold days?
Click to expand...

I have 2 waterproof jackets, a thin "paclite" Puma jacket that has no lining and is very lightweight, perfect for summer. And a more robust jacket for winter whcih is also windproof.
 
timd77 said:
Is there such a thing as a waterproof jacket that doesn’t make you sweaty on warmer days, but also keeps you warm on cold days?
Click to expand...
My opinion is not really.

If something is truly waterproof, it's because the material has very small pores (like plastic). Small pores are likely to make you sweat because the pores are so small it keeps the heat you are generating inside. Goretex and similar membrane materials say the size of the pores/holes in the material are small enough that they don't let water particles in but not too small to prevent water vapors from getting out. My experience is that's not really the case. Especially after the water repelling coatings wear away.

Water resistant materials often have just the repelling coatings (silane, silicone, PFAS, wax). They are likely to breath, so you won't sweat as much. They'll work well to keep the water out for a good amount of time. Problem is the coatings wear off and if there is enough water (like submerged or downpours) the material lets water in.

So basically, the better at keeping water out the worse it is at letting out heat, so you get sweaty.
 
stymied said:
My opinion is not really.

If something is truly waterproof, it's because the material has very small pores (like plastic). Small pores are likely to make you sweat because the pores are so small it keeps the heat you are generating inside. Goretex and similar membrane materials say the size of the pores/holes in the material are small enough that they don't let water particles in but not too small to prevent water vapors from getting out. My experience is that's not really the case. Especially after the water repelling coatings wear away.

Water resistant materials often have just the repelling coatings (silane, silicone, PFAS, wax). They are likely to breath, so you won't sweat as much. They'll work well to keep the water out for a good amount of time. Problem is the coatings wear off and if there is enough water (like submerged or downpours) the material lets water in.

So basically, the better at keeping water out the worse it is at letting out heat, so you get sweaty.
Click to expand...
My 28 year old Paramo jacket is still going strong, umpteen tech washes and re proofs . Admittedly its design is not really suitable for golf , although have seen some on golf courses.
If its good enough for Mountain rescue volunteers its obviously doing the business.
Cant remember what I paid for it but would happily pay another one but mine is not showing any signs of giving up yet 😀😉
 
stymied said:
My opinion is not really.

If something is truly waterproof, it's because the material has very small pores (like plastic). Small pores are likely to make you sweat because the pores are so small it keeps the heat you are generating inside. Goretex and similar membrane materials say the size of the pores/holes in the material are small enough that they don't let water particles in but not too small to prevent water vapors from getting out. My experience is that's not really the case. Especially after the water repelling coatings wear away.

Water resistant materials often have just the repelling coatings (silane, silicone, PFAS, wax). They are likely to breath, so you won't sweat as much. They'll work well to keep the water out for a good amount of time. Problem is the coatings wear off and if there is enough water (like submerged or downpours) the material lets water in.

So basically, the better at keeping water out the worse it is at letting out heat, so you get sweaty.
Click to expand...
Agreed. I always just buy the thinner waterproofs for golf, and I can always stick a few more layers under it if it's cold anyway. I don't like trying to play in thick jackets anyway.
 
Smoj said:
Footjoy Hydrolite trousers and jacket (same as in my profile pic) were good, but I haven't found anything better than proquip - although if you want a non-golf brand, Patagonia Torrentshell H2No jackets are incredible.
Click to expand...
I've got a short sleeve proquip top and looking at trousers. Any in particular? Don't want big baggy ones, looking at ultimate htx or storm px8 but they're a bit pricey. Thanks
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

S
Waterproof trousers
Replies
17
Views
2K
abjectplop
A
N
Waterproof Jacket .. recommendations
Replies
13
Views
4K
AussieKB
AussieKB
T
Does Waterproof Golf Actually Exist?
2 3 4
Replies
63
Views
7K
spongebob59
spongebob59
M
Recommend a waterproof jacket?
3 4 5
Replies
88
Views
13K
Lord Tyrion
Lord Tyrion
B
Jacket Advice
Replies
10
Views
2K
Voyager EMH
Voyager EMH
Top