The great drive for dough putt for show debate thread.

  • Thread starter Deleted member 29109
  • Start date
D

Deleted member 31467

Guest
I played with a lad off +2 today that is back home from a US college. He said the courses in the States you can smash it anywhere, typical bomb and gouge. However he said those courses are typical of a lot of PGA tour type venues. Once trees, long rough and heather come into the equation it's a different story altogether and accuracy becomes far more important than pure distance.
 
D

Deleted member 25575

Guest
As you putt about 30-40 times in a round and probably only drive about 12-14, it should be simple to see where you can cut more shots by practising :unsure:
While they count for the same number, all shots are not equal.
You need no practice nor ability to knock in a 3 inch putt
 

Bdill93

Undisputed King of FOMO
Joined
Jun 18, 2020
Messages
5,602
Visit site
I played with a lad off +2 today that is back home from a US college. He said the courses in the States you can smash it anywhere, typical bomb and gouge. However he said those courses are typical of a lot of PGA tour type venues. Once trees, long rough and heather come into the equation it's a different story altogether and accuracy becomes far more important than pure distance.

Yeah but he probably hits his 7 iron 180 yards :ROFLMAO:
 
D

Deleted member 31467

Guest
While they count for the same number, all shots are not equal.
You need no practice nor ability to knock in a 3 inch putt
Correct, they all count as 1 shot but if you had hit the previous putt into the hole instead of missing by 3 inches...........
 
D

Deleted member 25575

Guest
But what if the 3" putt is the result of a poor 6' putt?
The point still stands, your 30+ putts per round, is 30+ shots per round, some of those are so small as to count them in your 30+ putts per round is pointless, no amount or practice or lack of practice will make one any better or worse from that range
 
D

Deleted member 25575

Guest
Correct, they all count as 1 shot but if you had hit the previous putt into the hole instead of missing by 3 inches...........
Urm yes, quite right, but that’s not the point we are discussing, it was the 12-14 drives per round versus 30+ putts per round.
The point is some of those 30+ putts aren’t relevant.
 
D

Deleted member 31467

Guest
Yeah but he probably hits his 7 iron 180 yards :ROFLMAO:
Yes he probably does. But sometimes it's better to be 250 yards down the middle of the fairway than 280 yards in the clag. Or behind a tree. Or in the water or OOB. Distance is an advantage, no doubt about that but all those people that claim it is the THE most important way to lower your handicap are wrong. Simple as that.
 

sweaty sock

Hacker
Joined
Mar 2, 2013
Messages
1,147
Visit site
Yes he probably does. But sometimes it's better to be 250 yards down the middle of the fairway than 280 yards in the clag. Or behind a tree. Or in the water or OOB. Distance is an advantage, no doubt about that but all those people that claim it is the THE most important way to lower your handicap are wrong. Simple as that.
Being 280 yards in the clag or behind a tree is better than being 250 yards in the clag or behind a tree though....
 
D

Deleted member 31467

Guest
Urm yes, quite right, but that’s not the point we are discussing, it was the 12-14 drives per round versus 30+ putts per round.
The point is some of those 30+ putts aren’t relevant.
It is relevant. When you total up your score at the end of the round it's just a number. There are no prizes for the person that has the fewest putts or the longest drives.
 

Backsticks

Assistant Pro
Banned
Joined
Aug 7, 2012
Messages
3,852
Visit site
As you putt about 30-40 times in a round and probably only drive about 12-14, it should be simple to see where you can cut more shots by practising :unsure:

Yes, clearly its driving.
12-14 putts will be inconsequential tap ins. 12-14 will be long putts of negligible chance of being holed or affecting the score. 6 or 8 putts actually matter, and are subject to random variation to a great degree outside the influence of the player.

Or put another way, if I puttd for McIlroy he would still be a touring pro. We mightnt know his name though.
If McIlroy putted for me, I would still be a 9 handicap hacker playing for £10 on Sunday morning.
 
Last edited:

Bdill93

Undisputed King of FOMO
Joined
Jun 18, 2020
Messages
5,602
Visit site
Yes he probably does. But sometimes it's better to be 250 yards down the middle of the fairway than 280 yards in the clag. Or behind a tree. Or in the water or OOB. Distance is an advantage, no doubt about that but all those people that claim it is the THE most important way to lower your handicap are wrong. Simple as that.

I would have agreed with you a week ago, but it seems every bit of data provided begs to differ with this statement.

No one on your side of this debate can give statistics that evidence your point.
 
D

Deleted member 31467

Guest
I would have agreed with you a week ago, but it seems every bit of data provided begs to differ with this statement.

No one on your side of this debate can give statistics that evidence your point.
The statistics seem to be gathered by guys in the States based on US courses. Lou Stagner is in the USA and that's where he gets most of his data from. I've played quite a bit over there. I've also played huge amounts of golf on links and heathland tracks with thick rough and heather. Totally different animals, there is a much greater premium on keeping the ball in play on those UK courses than American resort courses.
 

Backache

Assistant Pro
Joined
Jun 26, 2015
Messages
2,629
Visit site
The statistics seem to be gathered by guys in the States based on US courses. Lou Stagner is in the USA and that's where he gets most of his data from. I've played quite a bit over there. I've also played huge amounts of golf on links and heathland tracks with thick rough and heather. Totally different animals, there is a much greater premium on keeping the ball in play on those UK courses than American resort courses.
I suspect that this has an element of truth in it but I think it mainly reflects in the comparative importance of dispersion of tee shots rather than differences between the comparative importance of putting and driving.
 

sweaty sock

Hacker
Joined
Mar 2, 2013
Messages
1,147
Visit site
Some more numbers,

To hit a 30 yard wide fairway at
250 yards = 6.8 degrees accuracy
280 yards = 6.1 degrees accuracy
310 yards = 5.6 degrees accuracy

If you cant hit a fairway at 280, you probably cant hit it at 250 either...
 
Top