The Footie Thread

[Skytot]

It was mentioned 11 times before your initial comment. There was really no discussion to be had, because everyone agreed it was the wrong decision.

Had one person thought it was correct, then that would have generated about 4 pages of debate.

Ok . See you all tomorrow.

 

[Pin-seeker]

Of course I 100% get that . The most successful English club in the last 10 years against a team that’s not won a major trophy ( might be wrong) , no one wanted city to win today . But thought a major decision like that deserved a bit of a discussion

What’s to discuss?
EVERYONE says it should have been a red.

 

[Arthur Wedge]

Of course I 100% get that . The most successful English club in the last 10 years against a team that’s not won a major trophy ( might be wrong) , no one wanted city to win today . But thought a major decision like that deserved a bit of a discussion

It was discussed

 

[Swango1980]

Perhaps we are all in the wrong.

Shall we discuss the Henderson handball for the next 4 hours, generate about 10 pages of discussion?

See how many different ways in which we can say that it should have been a red card

 

[Bunkermagnet]

Perhaps we are all in the wrong.

Shall we discuss the Henderson handball for the next 4 hours, generate about 10 pages of discussion?

See how many different ways in which we can say that it should have been a red card

Can we just discuss 115 charges against City instead....
Lets be honest, there won't be anyone who isn't a City fan who is upset City lost.

 

[Billysboots]

Perhaps we are all in the wrong.

Shall we discuss the Henderson handball for the next 4 hours, generate about 10 pages of discussion?

See how many different ways in which we can say that it should have been a red card

I’m really puzzled as to why there not being more discussion has caused such angst, if I’m honest.

A number, myself included, said it was a shocking decision, and that Henderson was a lucky, lucky fella.

Surely a feisty discussion only follows if there is disagreement. There was none. For the first time I can recall on this thread, we all appeared to be in agreement.

 

[Pin-seeker]

Can we just discuss 115 charges against City instead....
Let’s be honest, there won't be anyone who isn't a City fan who is upset City lost.

For the love of god NO!!!!
That’s been done to death

 

[Arthur Wedge]

I’m really puzzled as to why there not being more discussion has caused such angst, if I’m honest.

A number, myself included, said it was a shocking decision, and that Henderson was a lucky, lucky fella.

Surely a feisty discussion only follows if there is disagreement. There was none. For the first time I can recall on this thread, we all appeared to be in agreement.

Maybe it wasn’t a red

 

[Pin-seeker]

I’m really puzzled as to why there not being more discussion has caused such angst, if I’m honest.

A number, myself included, said it was a shocking decision, and that Henderson was a lucky, lucky fella.

Surely a feisty discussion only follows if there is disagreement. There was none. For the first time I can recall on this thread, we all appeared to be in agreement.

Spooky isn’t it

 

[Skytot]

Can we just discuss 115 charges against City instead....
Lets be honest, there won't be anyone who isn't a City fan who is upset City lost.

Omg . Shall we discuss ? No I won’t go there .

 

[Bunkermagnet]

For the love of god NO!!!!
That’s been done to death

lol.....I just thought it might counter the "how hard done by" City have been today..

 

[Pin-seeker]

Maybe it wasn’t a red

Go on Phil,fill your boots

 

[Arthur Wedge]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1923828570884821129

 

[Swango1980]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1923828570884821129

Skytot is currently emailing the BBC and Crystal Palace for not discussing it in enough detail

 

[Deleted member 21784]

Perhaps we are all in the wrong.

Shall we discuss the Henderson handball for the next 4 hours, generate about 10 pages of discussion?

See how many different ways in which we can say that it should have been a red card

We would be if it was liVARpool to be fair

The real thing is if it happened the other way round there would be more outrage as the underdogs didn't get the decision

Will be honest most of us wanted palace to win. Some because they don't like city ( rivals or because of the money) me personally I really wanted someone else to win a cup (IE not the big 6) delighted for palace

 

[Skytot]

Skytot is currently emailing the BBC and Crystal Palace for not discussing it in enough detail

hilarious

 

[Arthur Wedge]

We would be if it was liVARpool to be fair

The real thing is if it happened the other way round there would be more outrage as the underdogs didn't get the decision

Will be honest most of us wanted palace to win. Some because they don't like city ( rivals or because of the money) me personally I really wanted someone else to win a cup (IE not the big 6) delighted for palace

How VAR decisions have affected every Premier League club in 2024-25

We're collating a league table of overturned VAR decisions in 2024-25. Who will benefit most over the course of the Premier League season?

www.espn.co.uk

 

[Swango1980]

hilarious

Thanks. I was proud of that one

 

[Arthur Wedge]

 

[3 jabber]

Loving all the comments about Palace getting lucky regarding Henderson not being sent off. Small team gets a lucky break normally reserved for the big clubs and the internet goes into meltdown. Bloody hilarious, congratulations Palace enjoy your big day