• We'd like to take this opportunity to wish you a Happy Holidays and a very Merry Christmas from all at Golf Monthly. Thank you for sharing your 2025 with us!

The Footie Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 15344
  • Start date Start date
Slime said:
I can hardly stop laughing.
So many complaining about a bad refereeing decision, and rightly so, but when there's VAR many just complain and say let's get rid of it!
Officials are humans, they make mistakes, that'll never change
Click to expand...

Well the good thing about the semi auto it remove that’s human element but that offside last night looks very bad - how can they not see that

Can only think they are now programmed to not raise their flag and waiting for VAR to sort it
 
Arthur Wedge said:
Well the good thing about the semi auto it remove that’s human element but that offside last night looks very bad - how can they not see that

Can only think they are now programmed to not raise their flag and waiting for VAR to sort it
Click to expand...
Linesman wasn't looking at it from the TV camera. As I said, he'll see Maguire and a mess of players other side of him. He doesn't have xray vision, so at eye level he is clearly seeing a very different picture

If he was on other side of pitch, he probably gets it right, as he'll see the guys ahead of Maguire are Utd players.

VAR sorts these out every week, where we see goals being ruled out for being a decent amount offside, after linesman doesnt get it right. So, shouldn't come as a shock that linesmen don't get every decision right.

Maybe this will result in a mass demonstration for VAR to be used in all games, rather than scrapping it.
 
Swango1980 said:
Linesman wasn't looking at it from the TV camera. As I said, he'll see Maguire and a mess of players other side of him. He doesn't have xray vision, so at eye level he is clearly seeing a very different picture

If he was on other side of pitch, he probably gets it right, as he'll see the guys ahead of Maguire are Utd players.

VAR sorts these out every week, where we see goals being ruled out for being a decent amount offside, after linesman doesnt get it right. So, shouldn't come as a shock that linesmen don't get every decision right.

Maybe this will result in a mass demonstration for VAR to be used in all games, rather than scrapping it.
Click to expand...

That’s a lot of waffle


IMG_9077.jpeg

Not sure how big Maguire is but he isn’t big enough to block the view of the guy who is even further offside

It’s a howler from the linesman
 
Arthur Wedge said:
That’s a lot of waffle


View attachment 56960

Not sure how big Maguire is but he isn’t big enough to block the view of the guy who is even further offside

It’s a howler from the linesman
Click to expand...
No problem, your opinion. You are welcome to go down the usual angle of "officials are incompetent" every time they make a mistake. And I'll raise an eyebrow next time you talk about respecting the officials.

Seen thousands of worse offside calls than that. Good chance he can't see Zirkzee clearly at all. Maguire isn't exactly 10 yards offside either. So, from my opinion, and error, Utd got lucky, but nothing more than that.

I guess we have not had an incorrect offside to talk about for many years. So it's all good fun.
 
Swango1980 said:
No problem, your opinion. You are welcome to go down the usual angle of "officials are incompetent" every time they make a mistake. And I'll raise an eyebrow next time you talk about respecting the officials.

Seen thousands of worse offside calls than that. Good chance he can't see Zirkzee clearly at all. Maguire isn't exactly 10 yards offside either. So, from my opinion, and error, Utd got lucky, but nothing more than that.

I guess we have not had an incorrect offside to talk about for many years. So it's all good fun.
Click to expand...

You can see the person who is further offside than both Maguire and Zirkzee yes ?
The player that the linesman can see clear as day

I have circled him to help

IMG_9079.jpeg
 
Billysboots said:
Not at the moment, no. We’re worse than we were under ten Hag. But I’m not sure too many expected immediate improvement given the change in system.

There are some positives in all this. Zirkzee’s response to being hooked first half a few weeks ago has been absolutely first class. He’s got his head down, puts a shift in, and I still maintain that he does some decent stuff. He’s slowly finding his feet, although I’m not sure his future is long term. And Mazraoui never disappoints. He’s a really versatile defender.

But Mainoo is a shadow of the player we saw last season. If United have to jettison a homegrown player in the summer to make way for some incomings then, unless he bucks his ideas up, he is likely to be the one shown the door.
Click to expand...


What’s going on with Mainoo , had the world at his feet 12 months ago , clearly a very talented player but looks a shadow of himself

Has he had some injuries or a drop in form or doesn’t suit the way the manager plays ?
 
Swango1980 said:
This debate should end, as I think someone is seriously shifting some goal posts now.

I assumed the complaints were about Maguire being offside. You now seem to.be suggesting it should have been seen as offside as the guy you circled is interfering with play.

He wasn't
Click to expand...

Multiple players were offside

The linesman was right in line , if he can’t see that Maguire was offside and 2 others then he isn’t fit for the job

It’s incompetence, it’s not a subjective call

It’s not even a close one where you can give him a bit of leeway
 
How Mr Potato Head wasn't flagged offside at that level is amazing.
Lino had a shocker there.
 
I listen to desert island discs a lot this morning I put on the time Ian Wright was on. (I have heard it before).

I expect many know about his upbringing and it’s something I can relate to, there’s not many things that have moved me as much as listening to his story.

Back to the football, he couldn’t understand why some players don’t smile anymore when scoring, they seem to like posing more than expressing the sheer joy of which Ian Wright always showed when scoring.
 
Arthur Wedge said:
Multiple players were offside

The linesman was right in line , if he can’t see that Maguire was offside and 2 others then he isn’t fit for the job

It’s incompetence, it’s not a subjective call

It’s not even a close one where you can give him a bit of leeway
Click to expand...
It's incompetence when you think a linesman should flag for players not interfering with play
 
Rlburnside said:
I listen to desert island discs a lot this morning I put on the time Ian Wright was on. (I have heard it before).

I expect many know about his upbringing and it’s something I can relate to, there’s not many things that have moved me as much as listening to his story.

Back to the football, he couldn’t understand why some players don’t smile anymore when scoring, they seem to like posing more than expressing the sheer joy of which Ian Wright always showed.
Click to expand...
He loved playing , you could tell that he just put everything into playing because he seemed to believe he was very lucky to be there and when he did score he just burst

Can’t remember many having too many bad words to say about him - a humble player
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Hobbit
Another footie thread
2
Replies
36
Views
677
WorldHandicapSystem
W
road2ruin
Fantasy Footie 25/26
2 3 4
Replies
67
Views
3K
4LEX
4
SwingsitlikeHogan
Rental Rights Act
2
Replies
24
Views
1K
jim8flog
jim8flog
jim8flog
Golf or football
2
Replies
33
Views
5K
Voyager EMH
Voyager EMH
SaintHacker
The EFL Thread
33 34 35
Replies
688
Views
45K
4LEX
4
Top