Orikoru
Tour Winner
That makes it 16 in #KloppMaths.
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
For the Thiago challenge ? It looked outside from all the replays ?
How is the line from Firminos foot going through the knee of the Leicester player ?
Last edited by a moderator:
Orikoru
Tour Winner
Available from a team that only has 8 points all season.
clubchamp98
Journeyman Pro
Yes but so was the CB ! No need for the keeper imo.
At 0-1 We should have shut up shop ,two banks of four and make them come out ,leave two up front.
The only danger was the ball over the top, or free kicks.
Tiago really needs to stop giving stupid free kicks away.
I didn't see the game so I don't know how this incident played out. I don't even know who is attacking. Based on that angle I'd call that level and crack on. What was the actual decision? Did they have other angles to go off that were clearer?
clubchamp98
Journeyman Pro
They scored straight from the free kick .
The problem is where they measure the lines from .
I thought it was his armpit unless another part is off foot, knee etc.
If that’s the one they used it’s really poor they should have one more inline in a PL ground.
So liverpool are wanting an offside against Leicester based on that picture? Nothing clear and obvious based on that alone unless I'm missing something.
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
It was given as offside by the linesman
The judged the player level because of Firminos foot in var
But the lines they used -
The still was just before the ball was played
The line on the Leicester player appears to not be on the point closest to the goal - if they used that then it would be in front of the line they used on Firminos foot
Doesn’t excuse the folding after Leicester scored even though there was also a clear foul in the build up for the second
Just seems everything going wrong at the moment and confidence is shot - until the first goal it was looking good. Add in another three injuries now as well
Orikoru
Tour Winner
This is why they need to decide by eye rather than lines. It feels so stupid to debate where a line needs to be drawn when you can simply watch the replay in slow motion and see if it they look level or not. It really could be that simple. If it takes this long to work it out with the lines then he's level. End of.
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
WARNING-contains bad language ????
pokerjoke
Money List Winner
Best keeper in the world apparently
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
Definitely ??
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
Who ever thinks of them ???
Piece
Tour Winner
Someone who is great at untying knots is urgently needed at the Etihad as Sanchez is in a bad way ?
Jensen
Tour Rookie
Jose replaces Lucas Moura for Sissoko at 1-0 down. Mourinho must be trying to hold out for a 1-0 defeat ??
Tactical magician....
Tactical magician....
You could hear the disgust in Carragher's voice.
clubchamp98
Journeyman Pro
Not really VAR is a joke it’s virtually impossible to be level.
Your on or off , but imo the attacker should get the benefit of the dought.
But as Phil says there seems to be no consistent placement of the lines.
It was more the time it took for VAR to decide it wasn’t a penalty ,then if he was onside .
It takes far to long and the players are just standing getting cold.
We went to pieces after that decision.
clubchamp98
Journeyman Pro
Exactly so should go with the Lino’s decision .
I thought they only changed it if it was clear and obvious?
D
Deleted member 21784
Guest
That's not what they said or decided at any point with var
Clear and obvious only for missed fouls etc
All goals will be checked for offside, we had one against us given offside then given by var, just one them things
clubchamp98
Journeyman Pro
I think when it’s that tight the benefit should go to the attack anyway .
VAR is causing more problems than it’s solving for me.
