• We'd like to take this opportunity to wish you a Happy Holidays and a very Merry Christmas from all at Golf Monthly. Thank you for sharing your 2025 with us!

The Footie Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 15344
  • Start date Start date
It's extremely rude to butt into a conversation in public, why do you feel its acceptable to do the same on a public forum when my post was aimed directly to AmandaJR?

Little tip, when someone quotes another post, that means the person who quoted the post is talking to that person.
The forum is open, if you want a closed conversation, take it to a pm.

You seem keen to argue with people at every turn. Please don't.
 
You can quote someone's post but others are entitled to join in if they feel it adds to the discussion. The discussion doesn't become exclusive by using the quote function.
That makes no sense on this occassion. I asked Amanda a direct question not the other bloke. See posts 56343 and 56345(y)
 
That makes no sense on this occassion. I asked Amanda a direct question not the other bloke. See posts 56343 and 56345(y)

It’s like a conversation in a pub with your mates. One person might say something to which another replies. A third person then also joins in the conversation. If you look back through the forum you will see thousands upon thousands of similar interjections. It’s an open forum, and that is how it works. If you want a 1-2-1, take it to PM.
 
So for the non handball penalty in the Everton - Forest game, VAR have said that the Everton defenders arm was in a natural position for the move that he was making.

So, when any defender is trying to make themselves big to block a shot they are ok to extend their arms then...after all, it is natural for the move they are making. :D

The only mitigation would surely be that the ball was played towards him from very close range but I think Everton got away with one there.
 
I’d of wanted a penalty (2nd one) if that had been at the other end.

Only bit of doubt watching the half time review had me wondering if it was not given as Young’s arm appeared to be on the way down.

Definitely a pen during the first half though.
 
It’s like a conversation in a pub with your mates. One person might say something to which another replies. A third person then also joins in the conversation. If you look back through the forum you will see thousands upon thousands of similar interjections. It’s an open forum, and that is how it works. If you want a 1-2-1, take it to PM.
On this occassion i was asking Amanda if she would defend other managers like she is Pep as i know she is a Man City Fan. It was a direct question to her.

"I wonder if it had been another manager behaving like Pep you would be defending them?"

At this point PaulMdj piped up "I’m an Everton fan, I’ve got no affinity to Pep.🤷‍♂️" i never asked him.

Is it ok to answer questions directed to other people now?
 
On this occassion i was asking Amanda if she would defend other managers like she is Pep as i know she is a Man City Fan. It was a direct question to her.

"I wonder if it had been another manager behaving like Pep you would be defending them?"

At this point PaulMdj piped up "I’m an Everton fan, I’ve got no affinity to Pep.🤷‍♂️" i never asked him.

Is it ok to answer questions directed to other people now?

If you post on the open forum, others will express their opinion. That’s how forums work. As per my previous reply, look back through the forum and you will see thousands of similar interjections.
 
On this occassion i was asking Amanda if she would defend other managers like she is Pep as i know she is a Man City Fan. It was a direct question to her.

"I wonder if it had been another manager behaving like Pep you would be defending them?"

At this point PaulMdj piped up "I’m an Everton fan, I’ve got no affinity to Pep.🤷‍♂️" i never asked him.

Is it ok to answer questions directed to other people now?
Yes.
 
Top