The Belfry Rumour

Ethan

Money List Winner
Joined
Jun 30, 2009
Messages
11,793
Location
Bearwood Lakes, Berks
Visit site
So when I was playing The Derby up at the Belfry, one of the marshall's mentioned he'd been told they were planning on levelling The Derby, to build a new championship course, in order to try and attract bigger tournaments again. To add to this, I also heard that they may be bulldozing all 3 courses there to re-start almost! Although I can't see them bulldozing all 3, it'd cost em an absolute fortune.

Darn, so not returning the whole place to a higher purpose, growing potatoes as before, then?

If they are going to level the not very good courses, they should start with the Brabazon.
 

IanMcC

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 19, 2019
Messages
963
Visit site
The Derby is an abomination, and deserves all it gets, but the PGA National course is superb, and it would be criminal to destroy it. Whatever takes its place, with the Brabazon taking priority, would be inferior.
 

Newtonuti

Active member
Joined
Jun 17, 2021
Messages
349
Location
Birmingham, UK
Visit site
I can see this being a good move from a business perspective. The pay off would take many years given the investment required, but it's hard to imagine that it wouldn't pay off.

As it stands, I'm not bothered about visiting the Belfry on the grounds that the Brabazon doesn't appeal enough to make the other two courses worth playing. The Brabazon plus another championship course though.......

I was bought a round on the Brab for my birthday, and played it although in severe bloody winds! Nice course but apart from the 10th nothing special to be honest.

This has been rumoured for years. It would take a lot of work to make the Derby anything other than the bang average course it is already. The PGA has the potential to be a good course but needs stripping right back. There are some decent holes but if you are going to go the whole hog would you keep anything or start from scratch? The Brabazon has some good holes on and has shown with the British Masters it can still hold a DP event but it is a million miles from hosting another RC or similar. Would it make more commercial sense to focus on two top quality courses and use the Derby course to build purpose built state of the art practice facilities

To be fair the range there is decent, it could do with a larger short game area though.

Bel Air! At least, that was what it was called when we stayed at Belfry on our honeymoon!
I never attended btw! :cautious::rolleyes::ROFLMAO:

They've already started knocking it down to be a new function suite :ROFLMAO:
 
D

Deleted member 1147

Guest
The sight itself, the current courses (design & quality) the flat land, poor drainage, potato field etc, has nothing to do with what it could be.
With the ability to move earth, create elevation changes etc, they could build something brilliant. All it requires is a top designer, enough money, and time for growth and maturing.
It's never going to be a challenger to the top links or heathland courses, because so many people already have ingrained ideas that parklands can't be better than those courses. But a new Sawgrass or Phoenix type stadium course is possible.

If it is true I'd be intrigued to see what might happen.
 

Junior

Tour Winner
Joined
Apr 1, 2007
Messages
5,097
Visit site
The sight itself, the current courses (design & quality) the flat land, poor drainage, potato field etc, has nothing to do with what it could be.
With the ability to move earth, create elevation changes etc, they could build something brilliant. All it requires is a top designer, enough money, and time for growth and maturing.
It's never going to be a challenger to the top links or heathland courses, because so many people already have ingrained ideas that parklands can't be better than those courses. But a new Sawgrass or Phoenix type stadium course is possible.

If it is true I'd be intrigued to see what might happen.

I agree. With enough $$$ it could be turned into something good. "Trump Belfry" anyone???

I think I last played the Brabazon about 5 years ago and whilst I don't disagree with some on here about there only being a few standout holes, it was in immaculate condition. Infact, I go as far as to say one of the best conditioned courses I've ever played.
 

hovis

Tour Winner
Joined
Aug 13, 2010
Messages
6,265
Visit site
I agree. With enough $$$ it could be turned into something good. "Trump Belfry" anyone???

I think I last played the Brabazon about 5 years ago and whilst I don't disagree with some on here about there only being a few standout holes, it was in immaculate condition. Infact, I go as far as to say one of the best conditioned courses I've ever played.
Anyone who says the brabazon is an average course either played it in winter when it's a god awful golf course. Or they got spanked by the course and can't find their dummy. The course for a parkland course is immaculate outside of winter and a challenge to play. The Derby has the potential to be a great course but as long as Angus is there it will never be!!!!! The bloke is a tool!
 

chrisd

Major Champion
Joined
Sep 22, 2009
Messages
24,943
Location
Kent
Visit site
Anyone who says the brabazon is an average course either played it in winter when it's a god awful golf course. Or they got spanked by the course and can't find their dummy. The course for a parkland course is immaculate outside of winter and a challenge to play. The Derby has the potential to be a great course but as long as Angus is there it will never be!!!!! The bloke is a tool!

It was one of the 1st "top courses" I got to play and, to be fair, it was immaculate, with only a few stand out holes but I did like it.
 
D

Deleted member 15344

Guest
Anyone who says the brabazon is an average course either played it in winter when it's a god awful golf course. Or they got spanked by the course and can't find their dummy. The course for a parkland course is immaculate outside of winter and a challenge to play. The Derby has the potential to be a great course but as long as Angus is there it will never be!!!!! The bloke is a tool!

Condition wise anytime I have played it’s been superb

But it’s average in terms of playability, layout and a golfing experience -
 

HomerJSimpson

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Messages
72,541
Location
Bracknell - Berkshire
Visit site
Anyone who says the brabazon is an average course either played it in winter when it's a god awful golf course. Or they got spanked by the course and can't find their dummy. The course for a parkland course is immaculate outside of winter and a challenge to play. The Derby has the potential to be a great course but as long as Angus is there it will never be!!!!! The bloke is a tool!

It is though. Aside from the 10th and 18th there aren't too many memorable holes. It was in great condition and the greens putted well but for the cost it was low value for money. I actually played reasonably well so no sour grapes. YOu see the Ryder Cup there and have some thoughts about what it will be like but it failed to live up to my expectations
 

hovis

Tour Winner
Joined
Aug 13, 2010
Messages
6,265
Visit site
It is though. Aside from the 10th and 18th there aren't too many memorable holes. It was in great condition and the greens putted well but for the cost it was low value for money. I actually played reasonably well so no sour grapes. YOu see the Ryder Cup there and have some thoughts about what it will be like but it failed to live up to my expectations
That's just it. Expectations!!! People expect ring girls to get their boobs out on each hole because it's had the ryder cup so many times.
As for value. Not many people pay green fees. It's about £150 for two rounds of golf with two meals and a night's stay last time I checked (a while ago.)

I personally prefer the pga because the brabazon is one tough course
 

Foxholer

Blackballed
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
24,160
Visit site
I think everyone recognises Brabazon as a superbly presented parkland course. But many, including me, challenge it as 'a memorable test'. As someone who can often reel off the holes of courses I've considered 'great' (Royal Aberdeen excepted, as I was thoroughly beaten up by a 25-30mph wind) I struggle to remember more than a few holes - 3, 9, 10 (not a particular fan) 17, 18 and another on the back 9 that I can't remember the number.
However, as I posted earlier, that doesn't make it a bad Ryder Cup course. Such courses should provide lots of individual risk/reward features for the top guys playing a single round - especially at the end, not the 'overall challenge' over 4 rounds that is the usual recipe for PGA/ET tournaments. In that regard, it works pretty well imo.
 
Top