bobmac
Major Champion
I think they obviously spend way too much time playing golf 
One player definitely reminds me of Paula Creamer's swing :thup:
One player definitely reminds me of Paula Creamer's swing :thup:
Rate My Golf Swing: The GM Staff
- Thread starter TomC
- Start date
NeilTappin
GM Staff
Murph, I believe it has. It's a bit like a Lionel Messi shot!
Interestingly, I note that Steph's video has had the most views...
Points-wise, I'll let one of the others answer that as I don't want to be accused of immodesty!
Interestingly, I note that Steph's video has had the most views...
Points-wise, I'll let one of the others answer that as I don't want to be accused of immodesty!
MashieNiblick
Tour Winner
Very easy for us to criticise with their swings up there and ours nowhere to be seen! As we all know its not about how but how many, and as those who have met/played with them at meets know these guys know how to get it round a golf course. That said, Steph still has the best swing
Mikes is the one that interests me most, seems to be a lot of moving parts but a great rhythm, I may be wrong but I'm guessing hand eye co-ordination, rhythm and natural ability trumps technical correctness (and for that I salute you!)
Pretty much what I thought.
Steph's is far the best looking with great tempo and I bet she sends it out there a mile, arrow straight.
It might not be pretty but there is something about Mike's swing that makes me think he'll get it round Ok without getting in too much trouble. Looks like the sort of swing you might see on the champions/seniors tour (that is meant as a compliment!)
cookelad
Tour Winner
Going with the flow I'd put my money on Steph to win but I'd have Mike on an each-way bet!
Mozza73
Assistant Pro
For me personally, Neil Tappin.
Quite a short backswing but this is no bad thing, nice lag, flat wrist at impact and good weight transfer to a balanced finish. Stephanie's is a close second.
Quite a short backswing but this is no bad thing, nice lag, flat wrist at impact and good weight transfer to a balanced finish. Stephanie's is a close second.
bigslice
Tour Winner
right folks watch mikes again, and just as he is about to start swinging. say 'mike do you fancy a nice real ale?' i swear thats why his head twitches
Tiger
Money List Winner
right folks watch mikes again, and just as he is about to start swinging. say 'mike do you fancy a nice real ale?' i swear thats why his head twitches
Absolutely brilliant :rofl:
rickg
Money List Winner
NeilTappin
GM Staff
I was thinking Lionel as well, but it wasn't Messi............
Oh dear, that means it's either Blair or Richie. Neither good!
Kellfire
Blackballed
In_The_Rough
Tour Winner
Watched them all. Neil's is the best by quite a way I reckon. It says in the comments though that Steph is a 23 capper no way does it look like she should be that high.
mcbroon
Journeyman Pro
Have to agree that Steph's swing was the best. She can't be off 23, surely...?
Quite liked Mike's too. He seems to catch ball-then-turf very nicely and has a good rythm.
Fair play for putting them up
Quite liked Mike's too. He seems to catch ball-then-turf very nicely and has a good rythm.
Fair play for putting them up
HotDogAssassin
Tour Rookie
Before I provide an answer can I ask if any of the candidates have any say in the selection for the next big GM opportunity?
In_The_Rough
Tour Winner
Have to agree that Steph's swing was the best. She can't be off 23, surely...?
Quite liked Mike's too. He seems to catch ball-then-turf very nicely and has a good rythm.
Fair play for putting them up
Says in the comments section shes off 23, I couldn't believe it either. Her swing is better than mine and i'm off 8, all I can say to her if it is correct is practice your short game!!
I think they're all excellent. Especially Stephanie's.
When's the next fitting opportunity?
When's the next fitting opportunity?
JustOne
Ryder Cup Winner
When's the next fitting opportunity?
Don't know but I'm going to remodel my swing on Mike's :smirk: :thup: :whoo:
Actually his swing isn't too bad, a bit 'Homeresque' with the upper body in the backswing/transition and brings the club down a little across the line which should produce a pretty straight ball flight with an iron. I'd imagine he struggles to shape it right to left though (draw) and pretty much hits pulls and straight shots with irons and high(ish) fades with the driver. Not bad for an old fella
Tis true for the bottom of the swing but at the top of the swing there is bending too.
Can also depend on hardware and format used (camera wise)
Can also depend on hardware and format used (camera wise)
G1BB0
Money List Winner
Now I am selected for the TM day I can say they are all.............. better than mine 
lets be honest, aslong as it works for each individual who cares how good it looks
lets be honest, aslong as it works for each individual who cares how good it looks
sajkox
Club Champion
after watching them all I got back and examined Neil and Stephanie a lot as I liked them the most (swings I mean).
Could't decide which one I prefer
imo Neil dsnt finish backswing and Stephanie has this thing with left elbow at follow through that makes me afraid of her
Is that what people call chicken wing or is it all ok ?
All in all it was great to watch them all and I will certainly try to copy Stephanie's swings this weekend
Could't decide which one I prefer
imo Neil dsnt finish backswing and Stephanie has this thing with left elbow at follow through that makes me afraid of her
Is that what people call chicken wing or is it all ok ?
All in all it was great to watch them all and I will certainly try to copy Stephanie's swings this weekend
Simbo
Tour Rookie
If steoh plays off 23 swinging like that, 15 minutes here and there with her putter/wedge and the rest of you in that office better "forget" your wallets at your next outing!! Lol
