D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
Solid Par
And it’s a No for me
Solid Par
And it’s a No for me
Imurg
The Grinder Of Pars (Semi Crocked)
It's all down to what goes on the card........
hairball_89
Club Champion
On the card, it's a 3. For the purposes of the comp, it's a 3.
But because he didn't stick it OOB on the first go, if it were me I'd be saying I've had one outside the competition.
But because he didn't stick it OOB on the first go, if it were me I'd be saying I've had one outside the competition.
Mel Smooth
Hacker
Nope, it's a 3 unfortunately.
theoneandonly
Blackballed
Having to add a caveat means it's not an ace. Reminds me of the guy on here who tried to claim a 2nd ball as a hole in one because he was playing it to save time in case of a playoff ??
Not a hole-in-one for me. But the best par they will ever make.
Orikoru
Tour Winner
He teed up one ball and hit one shot and it went in the hole. Doesn't count as one in the competition obviously, but I'd 100% be counting it on a personal level.
Voyager EMH
Slipper Wearing Plucker of Pheasants
He holed out for a three.
I think this has been discussed (not on here) many decades ago.
There was no opportunity for him to have a hole-in-one on a hole where he was not taking the tee-shot. You need to accept this as you approach the tee.
I think this has been discussed (not on here) many decades ago.
There was no opportunity for him to have a hole-in-one on a hole where he was not taking the tee-shot. You need to accept this as you approach the tee.
D
Deleted member 29109
Guest
Nope.
I’ve told this before, but it happened against me in a match.
Opponent hit first OB and holed the next for a par. He was adamant that it was for a 1 not a 3 and got rather upset when (after getting others involved) he was told otherwise.
Interesting way to make half though.
I’ve told this before, but it happened against me in a match.
Opponent hit first OB and holed the next for a par. He was adamant that it was for a 1 not a 3 and got rather upset when (after getting others involved) he was told otherwise.
Interesting way to make half though.
theoneandonly
Blackballed
I wouldn't and don't see how anyone can.
Orikoru
Tour Winner
Because he hit one shot, from the tee box that went in. All I'm saying is, if I'm this guy, whenever someone asks me if I got a hole in one my answer's going to start with "yes, but..." As in yes but technically no, or yes but it didn't count as one. Like, you can't claim it without giving the whole story, but I'm still claiming it.
Jacko_G
Blackballed
In the match it's a 3.
On a personal level - you have hit 1 shot on that hole it goes in. It's a hole in one for your own satisfaction and record. People can tell me otherwise all they like. It's a one for me.
As I said and I will reiterate again for the match it's a par 3.
On a personal level - you have hit 1 shot on that hole it goes in. It's a hole in one for your own satisfaction and record. People can tell me otherwise all they like. It's a one for me.
As I said and I will reiterate again for the match it's a par 3.
evemccc
Well-known member
To summarise:
In the match - No - it’s a 3
Personal level - Yes of course
In the bar afterwards - Hell no, it’s a 3 for sure ?
In the match - No - it’s a 3
Personal level - Yes of course
In the bar afterwards - Hell no, it’s a 3 for sure ?
Imurg
The Grinder Of Pars (Semi Crocked)
So....say the first tee shot hits a tree and rebounds into the teeing area..
Player 2 hits it from the teeing area and it goes in.....is that a HiO..?
He's only hit it once....
Player 2 hits it from the teeing area and it goes in.....is that a HiO..?
He's only hit it once....
If it was me I would be counting it. Bet everyone who says no is just mad cause they have never had one.
theoneandonly
Blackballed
I've had several and it's 100% a no. If you have to say yes but..... Then sorry it's a no.
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
It’s a definite no for me and I have had numerous hole in ones
It’s a hole in 3 , nice solid par
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
If the first player has an air shot , then you hit the ball next is it a Hole in one ?
Surely it’s only a hole in one if it says 1 on the scorecard ?
theoneandonly
Blackballed
How many of you would be getting the drinks in as tradition dictates?
I’ve had three. And it’s still a “no” from me. The term hole-in-one infers a hole has been completed in one shot. In this case it wasn’t. So it isn’t.
