duncan mackie
Money List Winner
I have not found that to be the case, however it does however depend on your greens. I would always aim to get the shot landing on the green or fringe and running out, landing it short is not a great idea at all and would end up most likely costing you shots.
I think this is what Patick meant! Bump and run implies landing it 'short' to me, and obviously Patrick as well.
Given the shot you describe, played with a 7 iron, implies that you are starting within 4 ft of the fringe for a 40ft overall shot, it's more of a chip than an approach shot. If you have nearly 40ft of green to work with I can't see any point in landing anywhere but on the green - unless you are playing a bump and run (which you wouldn't in these conditions....etc) the fringe is the most inconsistent place to land the ball in soft conditions!