Smasher
Medal Winner
I'm not talking about it, 1st rule!
Fight Club: What would you have done?
- Thread starter Slab
- Start date
Sats
Challenge Tour Pro
Idiots. Simple.
duncan mackie
Money List Winner
you should know better than to jump to conclusions...
very true, he might have just been wondering over to say, Calm down old chap" and tripped on his flip flops
Bunkermagnet
Journeyman Pro
Don't you think it's a bit odd that someone just so happened to have a phone video recording there at that precise moment?
I don't think anyone there comes out with much credit.
I don't think anyone there comes out with much credit.
My thoughts too. Me thinks something was said before the recording started which prompted the guy to get his phone out. As for calling someone out, and the ensuing violence, certainly the thug should be out - what would happen if you queried him teeing off in front of the blocks? As for the mouth, I'd remind him of how to bring something to the committee's attention, and then suspend him for a month.
TreeSeeker
Assistant Pro
i would not hesitate to call out a cheat, in whichever manner got the desired result, i have done so at cards and only once for golf. To the committee works for me if it is minor and there may be justification behind it, otherwise name and shame.
Slab
Occasional Tour Caddy
Unofficially I hear it was about his handicap, surprise surprise 
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
Eh ? Sorry that’s confused me
duncan mackie
Money List Winner
Nothing cryptic, maybe I could have added a smilie.
I had thought you involved in the committee side of things in which case concluding that both would be thrown out on the evidence presented so far seemed, to me, to be jumping to conclusions.
Patrick has presented an alternative, entirely rational, set of circumstances that could see a very different outcome...although, on the balance of probabilities, I would be inclined to bet on yours ðŸ‘
HomerJSimpson
Hall of Famer
I agree. It looked as though the camera was ready to go so you have the wonder if there was more before hand. I think the guy throwing the punches (and damaging the window through his actions) needs to get chucked out. You simply can't act like that whatever the provocation. The other guy isn't blameless and needs the committee to take action and understand what provoked the comments and the reactions
bladeplayer
Money List Winner
Dont condone violence but if ya square up to some1 make sure ur willing to accept the outcome..
Bazzatron
Q-School Graduate
Read somewhere that he shot 76 off 23 in the Club Champs
bladeplayer
Money List Winner
Got away lightly so ha haRead somewhere that he shot 76 off 23 in the Club Champs
User20204
Well-known member
I don't think it's odd at all. This incident had clearly been going on before the camera was fired up and unless you've been living on mars for the past ten years people video everything and anything at the slightest whim.
clubchamp98
Journeyman Pro
Always someone on their phone
I have refused to sign a card because of cheating.
It was not nice to do .
clubchamp98
Journeyman Pro
Was he a nomad member?Read somewhere that he shot 76 off 23 in the Club Champs
Wolf
Well-known member
I to have had to refuse to sign a card because of blatant cheating, use of leather wedge and suddenly improved lies, and trying to change his scores. Worse part of it for me was the card I refused to sign belonged to my brother.. Others in our group saw it and it got reported and he got a lengthy ban and we've never played a round together since and I never will I very much doubt.
As for the OP regardless of who has done what you can't behave that way in a golf club it has to be done through proper channels. I'd have thought there will be impending bans coming. But that being said when someone is up in your face threatening you it's hard to just walk away and not want to fight back..
clubchamp98
Journeyman Pro
That must have been tough.
Wolf
Well-known member
It was we still barely talk now years later, but he was guilty of it was seen by a committee member doing it at same time I saw him so I refused to sign it. There were a lot of repercussions of that day but cheating is cheating you just can't do that no matter who you are.
