EU Referendum

Hacker Khan

Yurt Dwelling, Yoghurt Knitter
Joined
Aug 28, 2012
Messages
9,376
Visit site
You seem to be getting confused. You are not voting for a person, you are voting for Britain.

You are also confused as we can send a jobless migrant home after 6 months.

You also paint a rather odd view on "helping the poorer countries" - "pulled our socks up and built a once great country whilst they just say around lazing in the sun"? You're on a wind up aren't you?

No I'm afraid he is serious. The have been some good logical arguments to leave which reassures you that they are not all xenophobic little englanders. Then there are his posts....
 

Old Skier

Tour Winner
Joined
May 10, 2013
Messages
9,608
Location
Instow - play in North Devon
Visit site
What Cameron said a year ago doesn't concern me - I am listening to the experts, Cameron isn't one.

Once again you choose to ignore the fact that Corbyn was also saying it .

I have not seen one report from one economist openly stating what the EU will look like in the future so I was asking you. There is more to the EU than the economy.

Come on, give us an insight, you knock the leave because they don't know, what are things going to be like in the future within the EU.

At last on the old TV we have had an honest answere from a person voting remain; "I think I will be better off". (Ps, I have no problem with that as a response).
 

drdel

Tour Rookie
Joined
Aug 28, 2013
Messages
4,374
Visit site
I think I have answered your questions fully. Leave opened the Pandora's box on immigration, making it open season on immigration and migrants; failing to rebutt the most ludicrous statements made by supporters of Leave for fear of losing their vote - and hence allowing a horrible and disturbing 'them and us' environment to develop.

What don't you get about me saying that I trust in the economists - hells teeth - I am not an expert - why should I even pretend to have any idea? I trust in those who do - and in whose expertise we, governments and bodies who need a view of the future always look to - except if you support Leave when all such expert opinion is rubbished as ill-informed, self-serving or a conspiracy. This woul dbe quite pathetic if it wasn't so sad and dispiriting.

What Cameron said a year ago doesn't concern me - I am listening to the experts, Cameron isn't one.


I'm an econometrician of 30yrs and I wouldn't trust the 'big hand, small map' models/predictions that have been bandied about. The EU is an experimental political architecture for those countries who wish to be organised by a paid, not elected, executive of 'experts'.

It is hugely expensive and it getting ever more costly: taking money from the relatively rich north and west countries to the poorer south an eastern nations in probably the most inefficient way possible. This executive has had pay rises at levels only dreamt about by those outside, they have consistently broken their own budgets and rules.

At the moment to ECB is printing money at a phenomenal rate and giving it to the Banks of southern states, if the IMF gets cold feet he 'rich' nations will have to step in (UK included).

If you're happy that the benefits are worth these ever increasing costs stick with it. Its my view that many other member states are very worried over their national debt and, if they could, would dump the Euro but, as they don't have the economic base the UK enjoys they are stuffed.

I'm alright Jack I've earned many Euros from Brussels thanks so whatever the vote it wont impact me but I'm betting your kids will suffer if UK continues subsidising the Executive and other nations as it has done.
 

SwingsitlikeHogan

Major Champion
Joined
Jul 24, 2012
Messages
33,284
Visit site
Once again you choose to ignore the fact that Corbyn was also saying it .

I have not seen one report from one economist openly stating what the EU will look like in the future so I was asking you. There is more to the EU than the economy.

Come on, give us an insight, you knock the leave because they don't know, what are things going to be like in the future within the EU.

At last on the old TV we have had an honest answere from a person voting remain; "I think I will be better off". (Ps, I have no problem with that as a response).

Honestly - I don't know. But I don;t have to know as there are many experts with a great deal of experience whose job it is to forecast the state of things to come; experts that companies big and small take advice from when planning their investment, I trust the opinion of these experts. After all - if we cannot trust what these experts say how is anyone going to make any investment planning in the future. And I might as well extend the list a little further and add the Chief Executive of the London Stock Exchange - who of course has already had his opinion and forecasts rubbished.

And we may as well of course scrap the House of Lords as the whole point of a second chamber is for it to have 'expert' members to consider legislation in light of their experience and knowledge, which it seems counts for nothing as far as Leave are concerned.
 
Last edited:

Foxholer

Blackballed
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
24,160
Visit site
Once again you choose to ignore the fact that Corbyn was also saying it .

I have not seen one report from one economist openly stating what the EU will look like in the future so I was asking you. There is more to the EU than the economy.

Come on, give us an insight, you knock the leave because they don't know, what are things going to be like in the future within the EU.

At last on the old TV we have had an honest answere from a person voting remain; "I think I will be better off". (Ps, I have no problem with that as a response).

How about......Pretty similar to now - but with a few improvements - as negotiated by 'Our Dave'!

Btw. If Economists are unwilling - or perhaps don't see the need because it's pretty bleeding obvious (??) - then what's the point asking someone on the forum to predict the future?!
 

Foxholer

Blackballed
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
24,160
Visit site
a. Because his biggest comeback is that remain cannot say what will happen the future.

and

b. It's raining and don't fancy the golf course today.

Been on the booze again? I think you mean 'Brexit'!

The simple answer, of course, is that no-one can say for certain what will happen in the future, but it's certainly more predictable if UK Remains - as it will be much like now, but with some improvement!
 

Hacker Khan

Yurt Dwelling, Yoghurt Knitter
Joined
Aug 28, 2012
Messages
9,376
Visit site
Worth a look from a professor in EU constitutional law. However I will warn you that if you favour staying you will think it is a very fair and sober view of the choices and what may happen if we vote to leave. If you want to leave you will think he is a lefty communist who is throwing out scare stories.

[video=youtube_share;USTypBKEd8Y]https://youtu.be/USTypBKEd8Y[/video]
 
Last edited:

PhilTheFragger

Provider of Entertainment for the Golfing Gods 🙄
Joined
Oct 29, 2009
Messages
15,424
Location
Aylesbury Bucks
Visit site
We have received a suggestion that this thread is locked whilst the polling stations are open , so 7am -10pm Thursday.

Going to throw this out for comments for and against

My own feeling is that on the day, this thread is unlikely to influence anybody one way or the other
 
D

Deleted member 18588

Guest
We have received a suggestion that this thread is locked whilst the polling stations are open , so 7am -10pm Thursday.

Going to throw this out for comments for and against

My own feeling is that on the day, this thread is unlikely to influence anybody one way or the other

Close it now!

Nobody is in danger of altering their position based on the quality of this debate.
 

Hacker Khan

Yurt Dwelling, Yoghurt Knitter
Joined
Aug 28, 2012
Messages
9,376
Visit site
We have received a suggestion that this thread is locked whilst the polling stations are open , so 7am -10pm Thursday.

Going to throw this out for comments for and against

My own feeling is that on the day, this thread is unlikely to influence anybody one way or the other

Why on earth close it? I kind of think we are taking ourselves a little bit too seriously and showing ourselves a bit too much side if we think we have any influence like the media outlets do who have a news blackout on the day. It's only a bunch of sad old golfers yakking on the internet making the same old points over and over and over and over and over again.

As you say, if you are not sure by that stage and need the help of this forum then god help you. And I suspect no one has been really influenced in the previous 3037 posts, so another few ain't going to make any difference. ;)
 
Last edited:

Crazyface

Tour Winner
Joined
Feb 27, 2010
Messages
7,306
Location
Cheshire
Visit site
You seem to be getting confused. You are not voting for a person, you are voting for Britain.

You are also confused as we can send a jobless migrant home after 6 months.

You also paint a rather odd view on "helping the poorer countries" - "pulled our socks up and built a once great country whilst they just say around lazing in the sun"? You're on a wind up aren't you?

No,Cameron may say we can send them home but we won't be able to. As for the pulled our socks up thing. Just what were other countires doing whislt we had the industrial revolution? You saying we had all the clever people and all the workers?
 
Top