2019 Cricket

lobthewedge

Challenge Tour Pro
Joined
Oct 15, 2010
Messages
701
Location
Lanarkshire
Visit site
Wow. Simply wow. What a game. What a final super over. OK we got lucky with the bonus runs in the normal chase off the diving bat but what character from Archer and what a throw under pressure. Fabulous for cricket and best ODI ever

I don’t watch much cricket and know nothing about the rules, but something about that 6 when stokes hit the ball on the dive looks wrong to me.

Should they not have given a bye and bowled it again or something? Seems freakishly unlucky for the kiwis or does that happen quite often?
 

fundy

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
27,053
Location
Herts/Beds border
Visit site
I don’t watch much cricket and know nothing about the rules, but something about that 6 when stokes hit the ball on the dive looks wrong to me.

Should they not have given a bye and bowled it again or something? Seems freakishly unlucky for the kiwis or does that happen quite often?


its a bit of an oddity, if the ball doesnt go to the boundary then the batters wont run (its an unwritten rule) but as it went to the boundary there is nothing that can be done under the rules. might be a rule that gets revisited (along with several others the indians dont like) over the next year or two
 

lobthewedge

Challenge Tour Pro
Joined
Oct 15, 2010
Messages
701
Location
Lanarkshire
Visit site
its a bit of an oddity, if the ball doesnt go to the boundary then the batters wont run (its an unwritten rule) but as it went to the boundary there is nothing that can be done under the rules. might be a rule that gets revisited (along with several others the indians dont like) over the next year or two

So normally It wouldn’t have made a difference, it’s just the fact it went for 4 that the umpire had to give the runs?
 

Mudball

Assistant Pro
Joined
Sep 21, 2017
Messages
4,752
Visit site
just checked out the ICC CWC facebook page..... lots of very bitter Indian Fans and some of the crap sprouted is hilariousness

I am sure it is the same with all sports mad nations.. in case of Indian cricket the sheer numbers make it look out of kilter.

What a game today. Just for my understanding.. I don’t think the super over was a tie.. Eng 15/0 while NZ 15/1.

Kane W was gracious and I think the Eng players knew that they got the rub of the green. What a match .. well done boys .. something has finally come home

Next week back to the Aussies and the Ashes..
 

fundy

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
27,053
Location
Herts/Beds border
Visit site
I am sure it is the same with all sports mad nations.. in case of Indian cricket the sheer numbers make it look out of kilter.

What a game today. Just for my understanding.. I don’t think the super over was a tie.. Eng 15/0 while NZ 15/1.

Kane W was gracious and I think the Eng players knew that they got the rub of the green. What a match .. well done boys .. something has finally come home

Next week back to the Aussies and the Ashes..

do me a favour, some of the most delusional fans out there indian cricket fans. plenty of sports mad fans who manage to keep things in perspective, something indian cricket fans havent done for decades

if any fans should be moaning its the kiwis yet they seem to be taking the lead of their skipper and behaving brilliantly, maybe thats why the indian fans dont......
 

backwoodsman

Tour Winner
Joined
Mar 3, 2008
Messages
7,010
Location
sarf Lunnon
Visit site
I am sure it is the same with all sports mad nations.. in case of Indian cricket the sheer numbers make it look out of kilter.

What a game today. Just for my understanding.. I don’t think the super over was a tie.. Eng 15/0 while NZ 15/1.

Kane W was gracious and I think the Eng players knew that they got the rub of the green. What a match .. well done boys .. something has finally come home

Next week back to the Aussies and the Ashes..
Nope, it was a tie - 15 runs each.
If match was tied (ie equal runs) then goes to Super Over. If Super Over tied (ie equal runs) the winner is decided by whichever side hit most boundaries in the match (including the Super Over). Which is about as fair as golf's "countback" ?

What I dont know is whether the "most boundaries" is/was done as a simple tally (eg 6 fours and 4 sixes = 10 boundaries) or if it was the count of runs scored by boundaries (eg 6 fours and 4 sixes = 48 runs, and would be beaten by 4 fours and 6 sixes?). Anyone know?

Any hoo. What a finish? England gotta be thinking they were very fortunate - and you can't help but feel for the Kiwis. Just not too much, eh!
 

chrisd

Major Champion
Joined
Sep 22, 2009
Messages
24,968
Location
Kent
Visit site
Whichever way you do a tie breaker to achieve a result it seems unsatisfactory (countback in golf) but, for me the super over worked as one of the best ways I've seen
 

patricks148

Global Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jun 9, 2009
Messages
24,648
Location
Highlands
Visit site
do me a favour, some of the most delusional fans out there indian cricket fans. plenty of sports mad fans who manage to keep things in perspective, something indian cricket fans havent done for decades

if any fans should be moaning its the kiwis yet they seem to be taking the lead of their skipper and behaving brilliantly, maybe thats why the indian fans dont......

some of the crap sprouted by them just shows the complete lack of any sort of understanding of the basic way cricket is played and governed.

Had me laughing to myself for about an hour yesterday and that was just the posts after the result:ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:
 

patricks148

Global Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jun 9, 2009
Messages
24,648
Location
Highlands
Visit site
I am sure it is the same with all sports mad nations.. in case of Indian cricket the sheer numbers make it look out of kilter.

What a game today. Just for my understanding.. I don’t think the super over was a tie.. Eng 15/0 while NZ 15/1.

Kane W was gracious and I think the Eng players knew that they got the rub of the green. What a match .. well done boys .. something has finally come home

Next week back to the Aussies and the Ashes..
but most sports mad nations would have the basic knowledge of the sport they support, TBH if it were the tiddy winks would cup and india was involved there would still be 1,350,438,098. indians posting on social media not having a clue what they were following:ROFLMAO:
 

Lord Tyrion

Money List Winner
Moderator
Joined
Sep 9, 2014
Messages
28,879
Location
Northumberland
Visit site
So normally It wouldn’t have made a difference, it’s just the fact it went for 4 that the umpire had to give the runs?
As Fundy said. I would like to see the ball called dead then, same as when a fielder hits the wickets and the batters get extra runs. They are freakish events and the fielding side are unfairly penalised imo.
 

HomerJSimpson

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Messages
73,207
Location
Bracknell - Berkshire
Visit site
In the cold light of day, the two pieces of luck (the catch that was a six and the extra runs off the deflection) were pivotal and so we were actually pretty lucky and that must be hard for the Kiwi's to take but they were magnificent in defeat and even their fans on social media have taken it stoically. Unlike the Indians who think the cricketing world starts and stops with them and so the match was an irrelevance as they weren't in it
 
D

Deleted member 15344

Guest
do me a favour, some of the most delusional fans out there indian cricket fans. plenty of sports mad fans who manage to keep things in perspective, something indian cricket fans havent done for decades

if any fans should be moaning its the kiwis yet they seem to be taking the lead of their skipper and behaving brilliantly, maybe thats why the indian fans dont......
The social media from them and also the Pakistani fans as well is hilarious- can only just laugh at the self entitlement. Lost count of the times people have said the IPL is a bigger trophy now 😂😂

Where as the Bangladesh fans as well as the Afghan fans are brilliant.

India and Pakistan are the same when it comes to hockey - no humility in defeat
 
Top