The Footie Thread

[clubchamp98]

Oh, and United thrashed Newcastle 1-4 this evening.
Captain Maguire getting on the score sheet, too!

Just thought I'd mention it, you know, try and change the subject a bit.

Fantastic goal by Rashford.
Just one thing, he had a few chances very similar in the England game where he was past his defender but chose to double back and lost the ball.
He is quick enough but looks a shadow of his normal self in a England shirt.
Is it a confidence thing ? As he is still a young man really.

 

[clubchamp98]

???

You think that’s funny .
What’s your take on it then.

 

[Deleted member 16999]

You think that’s funny .
What’s your take on it then.

I think the conspirancy theories and everyone’s against us is funny, like I said last night, don’t see any of this fuss when you’ve benefitted from dodgy VAR decisions or other clubs have suffered.

If VVD had been onside, penalty to LPool.

 

[clubchamp98]

I think the conspirancy theories and everyone’s against us is funny, like I said last night, don’t see any of this fuss when you’ve benefitted from dodgy VAR decisions or other clubs have suffered.

If VVD had been onside, penalty to LPool.

I think Oliver and the Lino had perfect views.
They just havnt done their job.!
VAR is not fit for purpose And if they viewed that and still don’t think it’s red he should not be in charge of VAR.
And I have said lots of times refs should have to explain themselves after games including the crap ones that have gone in Liverpool’s favour.They are paid to do a job!!

They are doing it to often or we would have nothing to discuss

 

[Lord Tyrion]

as useless as Pogba is, utd have extended His contract ? nowt to do with his value. I would be frustrated with him in my team.

That was done purely, imo, to retain a resale value this January or more likely next summer. I think his contract was up otherwise and that would be negligent in the extreme, known as doing an Arsenal ?, to allow an £80m buy to go for free.

Enjoy him being at the club still, utd are all the poorer for him being there.

 

[Deleted member 16999]

I think Oliver and the Lino had perfect views.
They just havnt done their job.!
VAR is not fit for purpose And if they viewed that and still don’t think it’s red he should not be in charge of VAR.
And I have said lots of times refs should have to explain themselves after games including the crap ones that have gone in Liverpool’s favour.They are paid to do a job!!

They are doing it to often or we would have nothing to discuss

Your turn now, any comment on the 2 Mane incidents? 2 Yellow? 1 Yellow and 1 Red?
First one for sumulation, yes Gomes boot was high, but never made contact, 2nd one? Straight Red for kicking out?

 

[Liverbirdie]

I think the conspirancy theories and everyone’s against us is funny, like I said last night, don’t see any of this fuss when you’ve benefitted from dodgy VAR decisions or other clubs have suffered.

If VVD had been onside, penalty to LPool.

No matter onside/ offside or pen. Red for all scenarios.

 

[SteveW86]

 

[Liverbirdie]

Your turn now, any comment on the 2 Mane incidents? 2 Yellow? 1 Yellow and 1 Red?
First one for sumulation, yes Gomes boot was high, but never made contact, 2nd one? Straight Red for kicking out?

File alongside james waving imaginary yellow cards on 2 occasions, yellow each time, on top of his other booking.

We have been talking massive mistakes on var, not small semantics.

The other terrible one for me was keens goal standing. Pulled thiagos shirt just before he headed it in and again checked on var and okayed.

 

[Pin-seeker]

View attachment 32972

????? special

 

[Imurg]

View attachment 32972

There are people in this world who need a gentle tap on the shoulder and shown the signpost that leads them back to reality...
This is pitiful....

 

[Liverbirdie]

There are people in this world who need a gentle tap on the shoulder and shown the signpost that leads them back to reality...
This is pitiful....

If they were a footballer, they would hold their face, hit the deck poleaxed and ask for a red card, though.

 

[Deleted member 16999]

No matter onside/ offside or pen. Red for all scenarios.

That’s were we disagree, I don’t believe he set out to injure VVD, I saw it as Pickford spreading himself low to block the ball and coming in to contact with VVD.

Clumsy? Absolutely!
Intentional? No, not for me.

 

[Liverbirdie]

That’s were we disagree, I don’t believe he set out to injure VVD, I saw it as Pickford spreading himself low to block the ball and coming in to contact with VVD.

Clumsy? Absolutely!
Intentional? No, not for me.

So are tackles just ruled on intent any more and you class knee high as low?

Imurg, tap on the shoulder required here.

 

[Deleted member 16999]

File alongside james waving imaginary yellow cards on 2 occasions, yellow each time, on top of his other booking.

We have been talking massive mistakes on var, not small semantics.

The other terrible one for me was keens goal standing. Pulled thiagos shirt just before he headed it in and again checked on var and okayed.

No issue if a Club wants to write to the FA for clarification on all VAR incidents in a game, but just the ones they believe went against them is laughable imo.

I’d rather put it all down to incidents that happen in a Derby and file it away, I’m sure both of us can go back many, many years and highlight decisions that we believe were wrong.

Every Club gets good and bad decisions or disagrees with correct decisions that don’t go their way.

 

[Deleted member 16999]

So are tackles just ruled on intent any more and you class knee high as low?

Imurg, tap on the shoulder required here.

Watch the incident, VVD actual pauses as the ball reaches his foot, Pickford is going down from a standing position and they come together.

 

[Liverbirdie]

No issue if a Club wants to write to the FA for clarification on all VAR incidents in a game, but just the ones they believe went against them is laughable imo.

I’d rather put it all down to incidents that happen in a Derby and file it away, I’m sure both of us can go back many, many years and highlight decisions that we believe were wrong.

Every Club gets good and bad decisions or disagrees with correct decisions that don’t go their way.

You keep making points, then when i give a counter argument you move onto something else.

On this point, yes we do, but 3 terrible ones against you in one game, all with var, and we should just show an ,ah well attitude, and in a derby as well, pack in.

Off to golf, you have 6 hours in riposte time on earlier points made.

 

[Liverbirdie]

Watch the incident, VVD actual pauses as the ball reaches his foot, Pickford is going down from a standing position and they come together.

How can he pause, and come together at the same time? Or where they having a bit if hows yer father. Your getting desparate now.

 

[Deleted member 16999]

How can he pause, and come together at the same time? Or where they having a bit if hows yer father. Your getting desparate now.

Not desperate, lets play the picture game as the only one we tend to see is the one after the contact.

Here’s one just before, VVD has touched the ball and Pickford isn’t even looking at him.

 

[Deleted member 16999]

You keep making points, then when i give a counter argument you move onto something else.

On this point, yes we do, but 3 terrible ones against you in one game, all with var, and we should just show an ,ah well attitude, and in a derby as well, pack in.

Off to golf, you have 6 hours in riposte time on earlier points made.

I counteracted your argument by proving we can do this all day, not one Lpool fan has answered the Mane questions, everyone of you has deflected, even yourself by countering it with James waving his arms!