Scotland Debate

Hobbit

Mordorator
Moderator
Joined
Sep 11, 2011
Messages
19,697
Location
Espana
Visit site
No.I'm only looking for a YES victory, nothing more.I have an opinion on currency/Europe/Nato/welfare/defence etc, and very little is in common with The SNP, but in reality, it's all window dressing, all transient jam tomorrow stuff that in the grand scheme of Nation building is unimportant.

I want to live in a country that represents itself internationally, that elects people that reflects our society and make decisions for our benefit.Right now, and i'm sure no one would disagree,Scotland is not accurately reflected by Westminster politiking and with the dramatic change in Labour policy, we never will be again.

If you're interested, Patrick Harvie would be the man I put in charge of Scotland tomorrow, the guy is head and shoulders above ANY politician in Scotland imo.

I rarely agree with your direct expression of your sentiments but you've gone up in my estimation. Spoken from the heart without all the "what's in it for me" rubbish.

I totally agree that independance and self-determination should have nowt to do with finance.

P.S. can I live your side of the wall?
 

chrisd

Major Champion
Joined
Sep 22, 2009
Messages
24,972
Location
Kent
Visit site
I want to live in a country that represents itself internationally, that elects people that reflects our society and make decisions for our benefit.Right now, and i'm sure no one would disagree,Scotland is not accurately reflected by Westminster politiking and with the dramatic change in Labour policy, we never will be again.

I think that I'd like that for us down here too, for the same reasons.
 

Adi2Dassler

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
1,868
Visit site
I rarely agree with your direct expression of your sentiments but you've gone up in my estimation. Spoken from the heart without all the "what's in it for me" rubbish.

I totally agree that independance and self-determination should have nowt to do with finance.

P.S. can I live your side of the wall?

It's often been said I'm too abrasive and I should possibly tone down my 'directfulness' as it's often seen as a negative to my cheery disposition.I think my character could be described as stereotypical Scot, without the reluctance to put his hand in his sporran.

And you'd be more than welcome to live in Scotland any time you want..as long as you support with finances, Hibernian.

I think that I'd like that for us down here too, for the same reasons.

Yup.I think there are many folk in England looking for the same ideas I have for Scotland...there is poverty in England, food banks and folk living on hand outs.And they have my sympathy for the sorry state they've been left in by Westminster.But Scotland has the opportunity to remove itself from all that, cities in England don't and I can't see any way their situation will change...unless they move to iScotland.
 

Doon frae Troon

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Mar 5, 2012
Messages
19,031
Location
S W Scotland
Visit site
Sir Alex congratulated the British curlers at the Scottish Parliament and said that it goes to prove that 'we can all be heros for just one day'.

Quite a few folk on the 'phone ins' seem to think that the Chancellors intervention on the currency last week has filtered down to a boost for the yes vote.
 

lex!

Challenge Tour Pro
Joined
Nov 27, 2013
Messages
565
Visit site
I agree with these heart felt wishes but the big worry is self-determination in the hands of the SNP. They cannot be trusted not to embark on spending spree on social policies that will be underpinned by borrowed money. In the end, mr and mrs average, goes out to work, tax payer will be asked to cough up more to pay it back. Also corporates, when business rates are already punitive, and that is why some are already threatening to leave.
 

CMAC

Blackballed
Banned
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
15,121
Visit site
Sir Alex congratulated the British curlers at the Scottish Parliament and said that it goes to prove that 'we can all be heros for just one day'.

Quite a few folk on the 'phone ins' seem to think that the Chancellors intervention on the currency last week has filtered down to a boost for the yes vote.

I heard the exact antithesis as they want to keep the pound- by all accounts many 'unsures' are now sure.

I seriously worry for us as a nation if we all start abandoning each other. Be different, be unique, but do it together.
 

Adi2Dassler

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
1,868
Visit site
I agree with these heart felt wishes but the big worry is self-determination in the hands of the SNP. They cannot be trusted not to embark on spending spree on social policies that will be underpinned by borrowed money. In the end, mr and mrs average, goes out to work, tax payer will be asked to cough up more to pay it back. Also corporates, when business rates are already punitive, and that is why some are already threatening to leave.

Swinney has balanced his budget every single year, he's never ran a deficit I think?I'm no fan of The SNP, but we need to stick to facts if folk are going to make up their mind.

FACT:SNP will not be the defacto govt of iScotland post Yes...we'll have an election
FACT:SNP have balanced the budget under severe financial constraints every year they've been in power

A spending spree on social policies instead of contributing to white elephant vanity projects would be most welcome in Scotland.And everyone has a go at Salmond the 'failed economist'...his CV in Economics is mightily more impressive than Osbournes.

Business Rates are set by local councils, I'm lucky to qualify for the small business rates relief policy in Edinburgh...if you mean Corporation Tax(?) The SNP have suggested they'd cut Corp tax to a level lower than rUK...if you could direct me to any business who has claimed they'd leave iScotland ( not the myth peddled by media/policitians) I'd appreciate it...
 

One Planer

Global Moderator
Joined
Feb 11, 2011
Messages
13,430
Location
Modsville
Visit site
Swinney has balanced his budget every single year, he's never ran a deficit I think?I'm no fan of The SNP, but we need to stick to facts if folk are going to make up their mind.

FACT:SNP will not be the defacto govt of iScotland post Yes...we'll have an election
FACT:SNP have balanced the budget under severe financial constraints every year they've been in power

A spending spree on social policies instead of contributing to white elephant vanity projects would be most welcome in Scotland.And everyone has a go at Salmond the 'failed economist'...his CV in Economics is mightily more impressive than Osbournes.

Business Rates are set by local councils, I'm lucky to qualify for the small business rates relief policy in Edinburgh...if you mean Corporation Tax(?) The SNP have suggested they'd cut Corp tax to a level lower than rUK...if you could direct me to any business who has claimed they'd leave iScotland ( not the myth peddled by media/policitians) I'd appreciate it...

Didn't BP mention something a while back?
 

Doon frae Troon

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Mar 5, 2012
Messages
19,031
Location
S W Scotland
Visit site
I heard the exact antithesis as they want to keep the pound- by all accounts many 'unsures' are now sure.

I seriously worry for us as a nation if we all start abandoning each other. Be different, be unique, but do it together.

I think the result that would be most damaging would be a close vote for either side.
I cannot see the yes vote running away with it, so a Yes result by a narrow margin would be awful for Scotland.
The No vote appears to have stalled and there also seems to be many Scots who are still undecided.

Anything between 40 to 49% for a yes vote will still cause division.
The No vote must reach 65% to be credible.
 
Top