Captain Tom Knighthood

I'm going to play Devils Advocate here. Certainly he inspired people to donate to him for the NHS which is great, and by dint of that he has raised almost £33m. Fantastic!
I'm just not sure that constitutes receiving a knighthood when other people have given their lives to raising money, saving people, etc. without the publicity or the praise.
 
I'm going to play Devils Advocate here. Certainly he inspired people to donate to him for the NHS which is great, and by dint of that he has raised almost £33m. Fantastic!
I'm just not sure that constitutes receiving a knighthood when other people have given their lives to raising money, saving people, etc. without the publicity or the praise.
I fully get what you are saying and TBH I quite agree. However, it doesn't cost anything to award this honour and in these current times I think any feelgood story is quite welcome.

Arise Sir Tom :)
 
I'm going to play Devils Advocate here. Certainly he inspired people to donate to him for the NHS which is great, and by dint of that he has raised almost £33m. Fantastic!
I'm just not sure that constitutes receiving a knighthood when other people have given their lives to raising money, saving people, etc. without the publicity or the praise.
Perhaps I'm being a tad cynical but surely it was the media that caused the mountain of money.

But I certainly wish him well
 
I'm going to play Devils Advocate here. Certainly he inspired people to donate to him for the NHS which is great, and by dint of that he has raised almost £33m. Fantastic!
I'm just not sure that constitutes receiving a knighthood when other people have given their lives to raising money, saving people, etc. without the publicity or the praise.
Perhaps I'm being a tad cynical but surely it was the media that caused the mountain of money.

But I certainly wish him well
Well, I raised these very thoughts a few week back (when it was still about 15 million). And crikey, the names i got called for doing so ...
 
I'm going to play Devils Advocate here. Certainly he inspired people to donate to him for the NHS which is great, and by dint of that he has raised almost £33m. Fantastic!
I'm just not sure that constitutes receiving a knighthood when other people have given their lives to raising money, saving people, etc. without the publicity or the praise.
Just take a look at the normal Honours lists and see the civil servants and celebrities who have done nothing much of note. Who could deny him his day in the sun.
 
I'm going to play Devils Advocate here. Certainly he inspired people to donate to him for the NHS which is great, and by dint of that he has raised almost £33m. Fantastic!
I'm just not sure that constitutes receiving a knighthood when other people have given their lives to raising money, saving people, etc. without the publicity or the praise.
Plenty people have bought honours using "donations" that have gone to much worse places than the money he's raised for the NHS...

Which is exactly why the honours system should be scrapped immediately along with the House of Lords and the royal family.
 
I knew playing Devils Advocate would get some responses ;):ROFLMAO:
For what it's worth, I think there are lots of knighthoods handed out willy nilly and with some of them just because they're long serving civil servants for example, or handed out as favours by the government.
 
Ye. It's the civil servants I resent most. They are only doing what they are paid for with a guaranteed inflation proof pension.
I speak as an ex civil servant.
 
Wasn't he promoted to major for his birthday? Yet still called captain in the press
 
Top