You Are The Committee

[Crazyface]

Match play. Player 1 indicates he has covid and is unable to play until the end of the month. Player 2 agrees, but books a tee time in the last week before the due date just in case. Player one plays a game before the last week and texts player 2 to says they are ready to play. Player 2 texts to offer the tee time that was booked three weeks ago. Player 1 refuses as they are unavailable and offers an alternative. Player 2 refuses as they cannot play any other day that week.

What is your decision?

PS this is the Final.

 

[Lord Tyrion]

When Player 2 booked the slot did he inform Player 1 at that moment?

How many date options are they supposed to offer each other before a forfeit?

 

[chico]

If its the final extend the deadline by a week if they can't agree a date between them withhold the trophy and give both a two year ban. (If I was the committee I think the power would change me.)

 

[wjemather]

Match play. Player 1 indicates he has covid and is unable to play until the end of the month. Player 2 agrees, but books a tee time in the last week before the due date just in case. Player one plays a game before the last week and texts player 2 to says they are ready to play. Player 2 texts to offer the tee time that was booked three weeks ago. Player 1 refuses as they are unavailable and offers an alternative. Player 2 refuses as they cannot play any other day that week.

What is your decision?

PS this is the Final.

The decision is dependent on the terms of competition. What are yours?
Our ToC allow for a reasonable (even substantial) extension to the deadline for finals only, since it would be entirely unsatisfactory to have them decided any other way but on the golf course.

 

[2blue]

Just get a date that both can play.... it's a Final during difficult circumstances.

 

[2blue]

The decision is dependent on the terms of competition. What are yours?
Our ToC allow for a reasonable (even substantial) extension to the deadline for finals only, since it would be entirely unsatisfactory to have them decided any other way but on the golf course.

Totally agree!!

 

[jim8flog]

One of our finals was played 6 months after the due finishing date last year due the extenuating circumstances.

 

[Tashyboy]

Am sorry but player one ain’t doing himself any favours. Has he gambled that the play by date may be extended. yes he has had Covid. But decides to play a round before he decides he can play in a final. Why did he not contact player two to see if he can play the game on his practice day.
Has player one actually tried to book any days for the game aside from the one day he did play With someone else. What actually has player 2 done wrong.

 

[Deleted member 15344]

It’s a final - you extend it until the players can find a date that suits both of them

 

[Crazyface]

Just as an addition. Player one played in a competition today when he could have played in the Final with player 2.

 

[Sats]

Third and forth place play to see who wins it, because the other two are being a pair of melts.

 

[Tashyboy]

Just as an addition. Player one played in a competition today when he could have played in the Final with player 2.

Has player 2 said he was available ? Although he would probably say he was.

 

[Crazyface]

Player 2 has waited 3 weeks and now is not available on the one day offered by player 1. Player 1 has played at the club on the day player 2 had booked as a reserve day for the final.

 

[Tashyboy]

Player 2 has waited 3 weeks and now is not available on the one day offered by player 1. Player 1 has played at the club on the day player 2 had booked as a reserve day for the final.

IF they are weekend players let the committee pick a date At a weekend. If none of them turn up ask both losing semi finalists if they want to play in the final.

 

[Crazyface]

Has player 2 said he was available ? Although he would probably say he was.

Player 2 set up a possible date for the final. Player one declined this as he said he could not play, but this has turned out to be only because he wanted to play in the competition that day rather than the final.

 

[fundy]

are you player 1 or player 2?

 

[Orikoru]

are you player 1 or player 2?

Gonna guess he's player 2 by the sounds of it. ?

 

[howbow88]

Player 1 sounds like you could add ker to the end of his name...

 

[Bunkermagnet]

Our knockout finals are all held on the same day where possible.

 

[KenL]

It’s a final - you extend it until the players can find a date that suits both of them

I wouldn't go down that route. Players could try and avoid playing if they have a dose of the shanks.

I would say a sensible delay for illness would be fine.