Indeed, Paul Scholes for me.
Indeed, Paul Scholes for me.
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
Arguably-Open to argument: an arguable question, still unresolved. 2. Capable of being argued plausibly; defensible in argument:
I never said it was a fact :thup:
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
I wouldn't say you was wrong. You could also have said Giggs & I wouldn't disagree.
sandmagnet
Head Pro
Gerrard has carried Liverpool for years! Top top player,fatty has scored goals for fun but would pick gerrard every time but the ginger ninja is the best of them all! Don't think there is any better then him.
I've never been sold on giggs tbh. I sometimes think his longevity makes him seem better. I don't think he scored enough for a winger. Had a few exceptional seasons. Don't get me wrong, was very good. And would probably be in everyones best prem team ever on the left. But when asked to name the top 20 prem players he'd not be on it for me.
sandmagnet
Head Pro
Start a thread with prem best 11 papas should be very good?
This nickname always makes me chuckle, I'd go along with your assessment though. Lampards sheer weight (see what i did there) of goals sometimes make him appear better than he was. A bit like, imo this season with gerrard. I'd probably of had him 3/4 best player this year for liverpool but because he scored so many goals (3/4 penalties) i think people thought he was better than ever.
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
It's all about opinion mate. I wouldn't say Giggs,but you couldn't argue with anyone that did.
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
Not sure he's carried Liverpool when he's played with the likes of Fowler,Owen,Torres,Alonso,Garcia,Hamann,Carra,Carroll....& still hasn't won the league.
Pin-seeker
Well-known member
Oh & Suarez
Fair point. I mean I'd say my favourite was Le Tiss, but many would argue (wrongly imo) he was a big fish in a small pond.
sandmagnet
Head Pro
Champs lge final was gerrard fa cup final the git beat us on his own he is the difference, he plays 80% of the balls for goofy and Sturridge . But one player does not make a championship side,and be fair Man U arsenal, man city and Chelsea have had better players and managers till this season.
i think the olympiacos and west ham game are two of his most Roy of the rover displays. Think cl final carra was best on pitch. Gerrard was everywhere, also think didi was good too.
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
My best CM in the Prem would be
Gerrard
Scholes
Keane
Toure
Makalele
Alonso
Veira
Then Lampard
Gerrard
Scholes
Keane
Toure
Makalele
Alonso
Veira
Then Lampard
