Replacement car advice

[PhilTheFragger]

Unfortunately the Frag Jag (2011 XF 3 ltr diesel) needs a bit of work on it, which is more than the value of the car, so possible looking to replace…….but with what?

Cash buyer around £15000 must have a boot big enough for a golf bag and trolley, under 5 years old and under 50k miles, petrol.

Been looking at the Skoda Superb and it ticks most boxes,

Also looked at Audi A4 & A6, Peugeot 508
Anything else out there I should be looking out for?

Not interested in PCP or leasing

TIA

 

[Lord Tyrion]

Stop at the Superb, no need to look further. I had one for 4 years, excellent cars.

You could actually also look at an Octavia. Very similar boot size to the Superb, smaller allround package. Still excellent. If you aren't doing big miles then this would make more sense. If you do motorway miles, get the Superb

 

[RichA]

One of only 2 car related regrets of mine is getting rid of a brilliant car because a repair was going to cost more than the car was worth.
If I'd had it repaired it would probably have carried on for at least another 5 years without any further significant depreciation.

 

[spongebob59]

Used Honda Civic 1.5 litre Cars For Sale | AutoTrader UK

Find your perfect Used Honda Civic 1.5 litre today & buy your car with confidence. Choose from over 178 cars in stock & find a great deal near you!

www.autotrader.co.uk

 

[spongebob59]

Used Honda Civic 1.5 litre Cars For Sale | AutoTrader UK

Find your perfect Used Honda Civic 1.5 litre today & buy your car with confidence. Choose from over 178 cars in stock & find a great deal near you!

www.autotrader.co.uk

https://www.honestjohn.co.uk/honda/civic/2017/

 

[full_throttle]

I've had a Superb twin door and now a Superb estate, boot space in both is ample, my regular PP has the Octavia estate boot space is as good as the Superb but a little less room in the cabin,

 

[IanM]

....I'm not pitching up at Queenwood in a Skoda!

I think the point above about not ruling out a repair purely on the value of the car is a good one.

How much life would be left in the repaired car? Is it otherwise good? Cost of repair v the £15k to buy another ??

 

[Lord Tyrion]

....I'm not pitching up at Queenwood in a Skoda!

Skoda drivers hold their heads up high .

 

[IanM]

Anyone who knows me, knows I am car agnostic.

 

[Arthur Wedge]

Recently had a Skodas Karoq and found it awful to drive , same with an Octavia

 

[KenL]

Octavia is worth a look. You'll get a newer one than with the Superb.

 

[jim8flog]

IT's funny, going back a few years and my choice was between a Skoda and Puegeot both estate models and both very very similar in looks etc
It came down to the Puegeot because it was a lot easier to get to.

One of the other cars looked at recently was a Toyota Corolla Touring Sports.

 

[PhilTheFragger]

....I'm not pitching up at Queenwood in a Skoda!

I think the point above about not ruling out a repair purely on the value of the car is a good one.

How much life would be left in the repaired car? Is it otherwise good? Cost of repair v the £15k to buy another ??

Good point well made,
The Jag is 13 years old, 80k miles, 3 litre diesel and non compliant for the ULEZ areas of London, Bristol & Birmingham. Where we have family
Road tax is £320 Pa insurance is £500 pa, Motorway and car wow value it at £2500
It needs a replacement timing belt and the alternator bearings have started to go, looking at least £2500 for those.

I’ve spent 3k on it in the last 2 years
Tyres, brakes, suspension and general servicing.

It could go another 5 or 6 years, or the exhaust or something else might go in 6 months time, it’s at the age of potentially turning into a money pit

 

[Lord Tyrion]

One of the other cars looked at recently was a Toyota Corolla Touring Sports.

Thinking of driving for Uber?

UK or abroad, never been in one yet that wasn't a Corolla estate

 

[Alan Clifford]

I was very suspicious about the tiny engine in the Octavia estate. Took it up to the motorway and put my foot down on the slip road - all doubts gone, bought it. Must be the turbocharger.

Downside is a lot of gear changing - no torque. I have to change right down in places where I'd just stay in 4th in my Mazda MX5. But we do get over 60 mpg on long journeys.

 

[IanM]

It's sounds like a close call... the unknown is the, "what's breaking next?"

 

[PhilTheFragger]

It's sounds like a close call... the unknown is the, "what's breaking next?"

No doubt it’s a lovely car and beautiful to drive, and I will miss it badly…….
Decisions, decisions

 

[Imurg]

The FragSkoda doesn't quite have that ring to it......

 

[Lord Tyrion]

I was very suspicious about the tiny engine in the Octavia estate. Took it up to the motorway and put my foot down on the slip road - all doubts gone, bought it. Must be the turbocharger.

Downside is a lot of gear changing - no torque. I have to change right down in places where I'd just stay in 4th in my Mazda MX5. But we do get over 60 mpg on long journeys.

Might be one where it works better with the auto box. Let that do all the gear changes. Too late now if course, but in case anyone else is thinking of getting one.

Is yours the 1.0 litre engine?

 

[cliveb]

It could go another 5 or 6 years, or the exhaust or something else might go in 6 months time, it’s at the age of potentially turning into a money pit

Reminds me of my Celica GT4. Fabulous car, but it hit 11 years old and all manner things started going wrong, each one of which cost £££ to fix. It just had to go.