GM Article - Handicap System Ruining Comps for Low Handicaps

Wabinez

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Mar 21, 2012
Messages
3,445
Visit site
I don’t want to.
I think they should be banned and are a cheats charter!

All my scores are competition scores.

Ah ok…so you complain/mention that handicaps can’t be treated as a show of form like EG want…but then don’t want to do GP cards, which would help your index show recent form.

Gotcha
 

LincolnShep

Head Pro
Joined
Jun 16, 2015
Messages
1,012
Visit site
I don’t want to.
I think they should be banned and are a cheats charter!

All my scores are competition scores.
"I don't want to" is perfectly fine, it's your choice, I doubt anyone is going to pull you up for only submitting competition scores. They might scratch their heads and ponder why you're deliberately making it harder for yourself, but that's entirely your prerogative. However, your decision to ignore the handicapping guidelines may disadvantage you when competing against someone who has followed the guidelines.
 

harpo_72

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Feb 20, 2013
Messages
5,625
Visit site
"I don't want to" is perfectly fine, it's your choice, I doubt anyone is going to pull you up for only submitting competition scores. They might scratch their heads and ponder why you're deliberately making it harder for yourself, but that's entirely your prerogative. However, your decision to ignore the handicapping guidelines may disadvantage you when competing against someone who has followed the guidelines.
I think that’s exactly it, if you don’t 100% participate you really can’t complain about the situation. I don’t think it’s easy to conceal fixing it’s all pretty obvious to everyone and if you look at rounds you can see the holes they are fixing.
 

nickjdavis

Head Pro
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
3,447
Visit site
That’s how easy it is to Get a shot back.
All above board though 😳
To be fair....that can only easily happen if the next score to drop off is significantly better than the rest....in this case it was 5 shots better.

Another 2 bad rounds could see him go up another 0.5 but after that he would need to play 5 more bad rounds to go up another 0.3.
 

Orikoru

Tour Winner
Joined
Nov 1, 2016
Messages
26,023
Location
Watford
Visit site
To be fair....that can only easily happen if the next score to drop off is significantly better than the rest....in this case it was 5 shots better.

Another 2 bad rounds could see him go up another 0.5 but after that he would need to play 5 more bad rounds to go up another 0.3.
He still absolutely did it on purpose though from what you said. In the old system it would have been impossible. To be able to consciously know that four bad scores will put your handicap up a shot, and then deliberately do that without sanction, is a massive flaw in the system to say the least.
 

nickjdavis

Head Pro
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
3,447
Visit site
He still absolutely did it on purpose though from what you said. In the old system it would have been impossible. To be able to consciously know that four bad scores will put your handicap up a shot, and then deliberately do that without sanction, is a massive flaw in the system to say the least.
I only reported the facts that he played four times in the last few days and his best score dropped off as a result....the inference that he deliberately scored badly so his handicap went up is yours and yours alone.
 

rosecott

Money List Winner
Joined
May 12, 2011
Messages
7,708
Location
Notts
Visit site
He still absolutely did it on purpose though from what you said. In the old system it would have been impossible. To be able to consciously know that four bad scores will put your handicap up a shot, and then deliberately do that without sanction, is a massive flaw in the system to say the least.

The Handicap Committee has the tools:

Before making any adjustment to a player’s Handicap Index, the Handicap Committee should carefully consider all available evidence, including:

Where it has been determined that a player’s actions are for the purpose of gaining an unfair advantage.
 

Orikoru

Tour Winner
Joined
Nov 1, 2016
Messages
26,023
Location
Watford
Visit site
The Handicap Committee has the tools:

Before making any adjustment to a player’s Handicap Index, the Handicap Committee should carefully consider all available evidence, including:

Where it has been determined that a player’s actions are for the purpose of gaining an unfair advantage.
Obviously you can't prove anything.
 

clubchamp98

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Jan 23, 2014
Messages
16,588
Location
Liverpool
Visit site
"I don't want to" is perfectly fine, it's your choice, I doubt anyone is going to pull you up for only submitting competition scores. They might scratch their heads and ponder why you're deliberately making it harder for yourself, but that's entirely your prerogative. However, your decision to ignore the handicapping guidelines may disadvantage you when competing against someone who has followed the guidelines.
I don’t have a problem with genuine golfers putting GP cards in if they want to.
But we were discussing a blatant cheat using the system to gain a shot .

My opinion is the system is to easy to manipulate if your that way inclined.
There’s many stories on here about it but they just seem to be accepted by some on here who can’t see a blatant flaw in the system.

Putting all the work onto Hcap comittiees is just passing the buck when most are just volunteers.
 

clubchamp98

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Jan 23, 2014
Messages
16,588
Location
Liverpool
Visit site
I think that’s exactly it, if you don’t 100% participate you really can’t complain about the situation. I don’t think it’s easy to conceal fixing it’s all pretty obvious to everyone and if you look at rounds you can see the holes they are fixing.
I never had a choice to join WHS.
If I want to play competition golf I must comply.
It was forced on me.
That dosnt mean I have to like it.
 

clubchamp98

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Jan 23, 2014
Messages
16,588
Location
Liverpool
Visit site
I only reported the facts that he played four times in the last few days and his best score dropped off as a result....the inference that he deliberately scored badly so his handicap went up is yours and yours alone.
You did say he “sneakily got another shot”😳😳

That’s the problem.
It’s his prerogative to put cards in when he chooses.
But can be seen as manipulation or not depending on your view of GP cards!
 

harpo_72

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Feb 20, 2013
Messages
5,625
Visit site
I never had a choice to join WHS.
If I want to play competition golf I must comply.
It was forced on me.
That dosnt mean I have to like it.
None of us got a choice, it’s life , some person thinks they know best and that decision is foisted on to the rest of us.
Just have to get on with it and call the cheats out … which happens at my club, with name dropping and so on
 

Junior

Tour Winner
Joined
Apr 1, 2007
Messages
5,069
Visit site
Or you could win the event and go out 1.0 shots (which I have seen several times) and the guy who came second lost a shot.....
a very fair system N

I shot 69 3 under nett saturday and went from 6.7 to 6.6. Because I was losing a score from 5 months ago.
I have played in every weekend comp.
Hardly current form .
Ahhh yes, but if you submitted a card for handicap every time you play (and sucked the life out of social golf) you would have got a bigger reduction …..;)
 
Last edited:

Springveldt

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 5, 2018
Messages
1,824
Visit site
I only reported the facts that he played four times in the last few days and his best score dropped off as a result....the inference that he deliberately scored badly so his handicap went up is yours and yours alone.
The evidence would suggest that handicap manipulation is in play. Maybe he’s just started playing more golf though and it going to start putting in regular scores.

If I was betting man though I’d bet on manipulation.
 

bobmac

Major Champion
Joined
Feb 2, 2009
Messages
27,785
Location
Lincolnshire
Visit site
The evidence would suggest that handicap manipulation is in play. Maybe he’s just started playing more golf though and it going to start putting in regular scores.

If I was betting man though I’d bet on manipulation.
Occam's razor... if you have two competing ideas to explain the same phenomenon, you should prefer the simpler one.
 

clubchamp98

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Jan 23, 2014
Messages
16,588
Location
Liverpool
Visit site
Ahhh yes, but if you submitted a card for handicap every time you play (and sucked the life out of social golf) you would have got a bigger reduction …..
I have never put a supplementary or GP card in in 40yrs.
Social golf is just that for me.
I don’t want a card in my hand every time I set foot on a golf course.😳

Suits some but not me.
 

RichA

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 24, 2021
Messages
3,322
Location
UK
Visit site
I have never put a supplementary or GP card in in 40yrs.
Social golf is just that for me.
I don’t want a card in my hand every time I set foot on a golf course.😳

Suits some but not me.
I used to but not any more.
Social golf for me is high tariff hero shots, longest drive challenges on inappropriate holes and flop shot attempts when a sensible bump and run would be the right choice. We don't play for money. If I submitted those rounds my HI would rise by half a dozen shots.
On the rare occasions I enter solo comps I play boring attritional golf and score around my HI. I want to be competitive but not by having an inflated handicap.
 

Orikoru

Tour Winner
Joined
Nov 1, 2016
Messages
26,023
Location
Watford
Visit site
I used to but not any more.
Social golf for me is high tariff hero shots, longest drive challenges on inappropriate holes and flop shot attempts when a sensible bump and run would be the right choice. We don't play for money. If I submitted those rounds my HI would rise by half a dozen shots.
On the rare occasions I enter solo comps I play boring attritional golf and score around my HI. I want to be competitive but not by having an inflated handicap.
I never do either, but now that I have matches coming up and I'm not playing anywhere near my handicap, I wish I had!
 
Top