rulefan
Tour Winner
Previously it was much clearer as to when a 'winter green' was actually a putting green as then defined, and therefore a wrong green when out of play. (see post #5)I’m sure I read several years ago from a Rules Official that a winter green is a wrong green and relief MUST be taken - in exactly the same way as relief from a ‘summer’ green when winter greens are in play. it doesn’t seem to me to be anything other than common sense as well as care of the course to treat them as wrong greens.
Several of the courses up here in Scotland seem to want to regard them as GIR - with the proviso that relief must be taken from GIR
It was very common (and I suspect still is) to deem them to be "GUR play prohibited" (what is GIR?) as players seemed to understand that. But it was strictly unnecessary under the then rules.
A club could now simply declare them as No Play Zones and GUR or an Abnormal Course Condition. (Effectively GUR pray prohibited). But they should be identified differently to other GUR that is not a NPZ.
I would advise that an appropriate Local Rule is published when the situation arises