St Annes Old Links

Fish

Well-known member
Banned
Joined
Jun 25, 2012
Messages
18,384
Visit site
Pulled up outside the clubhouse nice and early and my first impressions were that of a kid in a sweet shop. The clubhouse looks grand from the front and when entering it, its OK also.

After an excellent warm up on Saturday at The Centurion Club, which I believe has a big impact on how I start and then focus on my day, especially after a long journey, I was disappointed to only find a single net to warm up and hit balls into, OK, before everyone jumps in, I was told by the Pro, or his assistant, that their was a range of sorts in the very far right corner across the course which was about a 10 minute walk away!

I heard a lot about SAOL before arriving, especially the greens, so I was really looking forward to it, and before anyone says that you don't appreciate a course if you've not played well, well that's not the case because I didn't play very well at Wallasey but loved the place to the degree of joining and I enjoyed Formby also but SAOL ticked no boxes for me at all!

I personally found SAOL uninspiring, unattractive and boring! I never stood on one tee box and said to myself, what a great looking hole! They were all so similar, flat, bunkers scattered and positioned well but as long as you hit a straight drive, it was always a mid iron to the green (3w & 6 iron for my par on the si1), and that was in the wet with the ball not rolling!

I felt very much the same after Hoylake, strip away the history and the course wasn't all that, but, it (Hoylake) did have far more definition with raised tee boxes, rise & fall fairways, blind tee and approach shots, SAOL didn't have anything IMO.

I'm aware that the greens had been recently hollow tined which we weren't aware of prior so I didn't experience these fast great greens which was being discussed before, I also thought that there wasn't much definition with any either, no real 2-tier greens that I can remember or large undulating greens where it really mattered if you were at the front or back of them.

When I wasn't playing out a hole, its nice to look around and take in the scenery, but SAOL doesn't offer any, houses, low flying aeroplanes, the airport buildings and a coastal road is all that is on offer, you don't get lost out their in the ambience of a golf course IMO.

So, even after stripping away the pish-poor performance, the horrible rainy conditions, I wouldn't travel back to SAOL, it just did nothing for me as a course and I can't see that changing even if it was a hot summers day.

Not for me.


The roast chicken was excellent though :thup:
 
I am a fan of SAOL but I do get where you are coming from.

Its a real shame about Sunday as we were put on the most forward point of the tee box and this made the course a lot shorter than expected. Off the whites it is a different course. I actually liked the fact it doesn't have any blind tee shots. Its biggest defence is the wind and the rough (in the summer) by a long way and I don't disagree with the disappointment on the greens as they were the best I have played on this season and Sunday was a long way short of what they had been like but understandable as they had been worked on.

Oh and agree the food was cracking.
 
Interesting points made by Fish and LQ. Id like to play the course off the back tees, with firm fairways and when the greens are at their best.

I really enjoyed the course but I dont think we had the whole experience. The approaches to the greens were all short irons and id imagine of the back tees with the wind up it would be a more enjoyable test.

Hard to compare it against Wallasey and Formby as they are in a higher class of course, and the green fees reflect as such. Fwiw, Fairhaven has similar fees and Id prefer to be a member there rather than SAOL.
 
Another point I ust thought of was that a lot of people I kow who have playe the Old course are not that blown away with it. I think SAOL could be the same. You need to play it a few times (in the Summer) to appreciate the strategy in getting it around.
 
Top