Scotland Debate

[Dodger]

So as per yesterday instead of actually addressing the main issues it's just a few little cheap digs

Not sure where in my post I have even mentioned me being correct

Not seen these questions you have for the No campaign can you point me to the list ?

You haven't debated - you have ignored and thrown cheap digs at me - did it yesterday and same again today.

So you want me to list my questions so you can disagree with them as being issues?

I have news for you, I am totally uninterested in what your views are and I aint got time to be bored to death again by your "no,no,no,no" posts.

Enjoy the rest of this thread.:thup:

 

[Deleted member 15344]

So you want me to list my questions so you can disagree with them as being issues?

I have news for you, I am totally uninterested in what your views are and I aint got time to be bored to death again by your "no,no,no,no" posts.

Enjoy the rest of this thread.:thup:

I wanted you to list your questions because I haven't seen them :thup:

 

[Foxholer]

I would have though that folks born in Scotland, but living in other parts of the UK should have got a vote, if English folk living in Scotland do! :mmm:

Bit late to the party on this one - just for a change! Though by 4k+ posts is probably a new record!

My view too, and not just living in UK imo. But apparently deemed unworkable by all parties!

 

[williamalex1]

She does for the same reason as Dodger apparently - property ownership. Though in her case, I believe she'll to lose a goodly chunk of 'property' if it's a 'Yes'!

How much would be a fair rent for HER property's, including bedroom tax in Euros or Sterling.oo:

 

[Deleted member 15344]

How much would be a fair rent for HER property's, including bedroom tax in Euros or Sterling.oo:

Is it just the one property ? Balmoral ?

 

[Foxholer]

Not sure where in my post I have even mentioned me being correct

Is that an admission that you might occasionally be less than correct, or perhaps even wrong?

Quick! Call the police! Someone has hijacked LPP's Userid! :rofl:

 

[Deleted member 15344]

Is that an admission that you might occasionally be less than correct, or perhaps even wrong?

Quick! Call the police! Someone has hijacked LPP's Userid! :rofl:

I'm sure there is a kettle around here somewhere

 

[delc]

Bit late to the party on this one - just for a change! Though by 4k+ posts is probably a new record!

My view too, and not just living in UK imo. But apparently deemed unworkable by all parties!

Yes, many of my Scottish friends (living in England) are a bit miffed about not getting a vote!

 

[Foxholer]

Is it just the one property ? Balmoral ?

I think She has most of the place surrounded!

Balmoral is not part of the Crown Estate, but there is plenty that is! Crown Estate income was/is something of a niggle for the Nats who made a grab for the income after they won in 2011

 

[williamalex1]

Is it just the one property ? Balmoral ?

The Royals own a great deal of land and properties in Scotland not sure exactly how much.

If there is a yes vote she will still be the Queen of Scotland [ not counting John Barrowman of course] .

Oh! Balmoral is my address too but a different postcode.

 

[Deleted member 15344]

I think She has most of the place surrounded!

Balmoral is not part of the Crown Estate, but there is plenty that is! Crown Estate income was/is something of a niggle for the Nats who made a grab for the income after they won in 2011

Balmoral is owned by the Royal Family and Trustees - crown estate I don't believe was mentioned :mmm:

 

[williamalex1]

Is that an admission that you might occasionally be less than correct, or perhaps even wrong?

Quick! Call the police! Someone has hijacked LPP's Userid! :rofl:

Frapped i think is the term ?.

 

[Beezerk]

I still want to know exactly what this "fairer society" is which keeps getting mentioned by Yes campaigners.
Can someone expand on it for me?

 

[Deleted member 18588]

Read The White Paper!

Whether that's convincing is up to the individual!

But it certainly seems, to me, that Scotland has been getting a 'mixed' deal and that Independence is a way of getting a deal more in line with how they want to manage their resources. I have no doubt that they would survive and prosper as an independent country, though whether they desire to is up to them.

I have done and a more gloriously vague document is hard to imagine.

The politicians must presumably have provided the Civil Servants with a remit for drafting it and those same Civil Servants must have spent an age trying to make a serious White Paper from that same remit.

Utopia or Status Quo! My what a choice.

 

[FairwayDodger]

Has a vote via property owned in Scotland like a few guys I play golf with ( all voting No )

Can't understand why people who don't live in Scotland have a vote due to owning property there

Know another guy who is English and owns a house near St Andrews and has a vote

Owning property in Scotland does not entitle you to vote, residency is the requirement.

 

[Deleted member 15344]

Owning property in Scotland does not entitle you to vote, residency is the requirement.

Can you not be a registered voter in Scotland though but not residing in Scotland ?

 

[FairwayDodger]

Can you not be a registered voter in Scotland though but not residing in Scotland ?

Yes for a general election (if you are outside the uk) not for the referendum.

 

[Deleted member 15344]

Yes for a general election (if you are outside the uk) not for the referendum.

I'm sure service personnel are able to vote if they are registered to vote in Scotland but currently residing outside of Scotland ?

 

[Dodger]

Can you not be a registered voter in Scotland though but not residing in Scotland ?

Yes you most certainly can.

My residence is my IOB address soley for the purpose of voting in this.

 

[Deleted member 15344]

Yes you most certainly can.

You don't reside in Scotland but have a vote due to being registered to vote in Scotland ? Is that right

So who is living the property where you are registered ?