JonnyGutteridge
Newbie
Not a situation I am involved in but happened to someone I know.
In a foursomes match, one player helped to line up a putt and was standing behind his playing partner. The player took the putt whilst PP had not yet moved away.
I believe this is not permitted, as would be the case if a caddy stood directly in line when the putt was taken?
The opponents called this after googling it on the next hole…
Issue 1: player A says they were in the process of moving away when the putt was taken so it’s not like they’re saying “yeh I didn’t move” and admitting to it, so that’s I guess their word against another?
Issue 2: they didn’t call it immediately, and only once they were half way down the next hole and had confirmed it wasn’t allowed did they flag it up. At that point, is it too late?
Of course, the result was either 1up or A/S depending on if the hole in question was halved or lost due to the penalty.
I personally wouldn’t be calling this at all in a match, and if you do, you better be doing it immediately and making sure you’re acting within the rules for claiming a hole due to an infringement. Things were… a little bit frosty after the match was completed. I would likely be sleeping on it and offering a rematch.
In a foursomes match, one player helped to line up a putt and was standing behind his playing partner. The player took the putt whilst PP had not yet moved away.
I believe this is not permitted, as would be the case if a caddy stood directly in line when the putt was taken?
The opponents called this after googling it on the next hole…
Issue 1: player A says they were in the process of moving away when the putt was taken so it’s not like they’re saying “yeh I didn’t move” and admitting to it, so that’s I guess their word against another?
Issue 2: they didn’t call it immediately, and only once they were half way down the next hole and had confirmed it wasn’t allowed did they flag it up. At that point, is it too late?
Of course, the result was either 1up or A/S depending on if the hole in question was halved or lost due to the penalty.
I personally wouldn’t be calling this at all in a match, and if you do, you better be doing it immediately and making sure you’re acting within the rules for claiming a hole due to an infringement. Things were… a little bit frosty after the match was completed. I would likely be sleeping on it and offering a rematch.