Ken3over

[user2010]

Then again you never did respond to post #7 regarding parameters for your common sense ruling.

Shouldn't have had to, it's dog sh1t and any other sh1t ffs

 

[duncan mackie]

Shouldn't have had to, it's dog sh1t and any other sh1t ffs

So from your perspective anytime the ball has any visible green (goose s....) or brown bits on it, anywhere on the course, you should obviously get relief....

 

[user2010]

So from your perspective anytime the ball has any visible green (goose s....) or brown bits on it, anywhere on the course, you should obviously get relief....

Yep, deffo, now you're getting the hang of common sense rulings, well done.:thup:

 

[rulefan]

Yep, deffo, now you're getting the hang of common sense rulings, well done.:thup:

Does this include brown soil or unidentifiable brown or green something?

 

[rulie]

So from your perspective anytime the ball has any visible green (goose s....) or brown bits on it, anywhere on the course, you should obviously get relief....

With him, you'd definitely need to ask on the first tee, "Which Rules aren't we playing by today?"

 

[user2010]

Does this include brown soil or unidentifiable brown or green something?

No, just sh1t.

 

[user2010]

With him, you'd definitely need to ask on the first tee, "Which Rules aren't we playing by today?"

No you wouldn't, but if a fc's ball was covered/lying in dog/goose etc sh1t then he could/should get a free drop/clean if he was playing with me, and i'd expect the same in return, Common sense would apply.

 

[rulie]

No you wouldn't, but if a fc's ball was covered/lying in dog/goose etc sh1t then he could/should get a free drop/clean if he was playing with me, and i'd expect the same in return, Common sense would apply.

Fine, so long as you recognize that you're not playing by the Rules of golf.

 

[user2010]

Fine, so long as you recognize that you're not playing by the Rules of golf.

Yawn:blah::blah::blah:

 

[duncan mackie]

No, just sh1t.

And your preferred method of testing this?

 

[user2010]

And your preferred method of testing this?

Taste, obviously!!:thup:

 

[PhilTheFragger]

Chortle

Think this is one of those occasions where there should be a national rule rather than leaving it up to local rules

 

[rosecott]

Chortle

Think this is one of those occasions where there should be a national rule rather than leaving it up to local rules

There is - despite Scrotie's rule changes.

 

[Crow]

I'd find a nice G15 iron and hit the ball where it was,
it would go like .................