Robobum
Money List Winner
If you know what she said then enlighten us.
If she said that her, and the caddies, walking off was not a concession then yep.....s he lied.
Fair Play?
- Thread starter JARS
- Start date
If you know what she said then enlighten us.
If she said that her, and the caddies, walking off was not a concession then yep.....s he lied.
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
It's dangerous ground right now as both players said they didn't concede the putt.
Smiffy
Grand Slam Winner
I've watched the video half a dozen times and all I'm saying is that Hull was definitely walking towards the 18th.
That, for me at least, suggests a concession.
Or do you leave the green while your opponents are still putting???
alexbrownmp
Head Pro
tsped83
Tour Winner
I'm not calling her anything. Put your wooden spoon away you big girl.
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
She was walking towards Peterson who was stood on the edge of the green - she says she was moving out of the way of the putt.
Smiffy
Grand Slam Winner
I would never, ever, leave the green, or attempt to leave the green, whilst my opponent was still putting, whether it was for a birdie or a double bogie.
It's unsporting, and downright bad manners.
I certainly wouldn't attempt to leave the green whilst they still had a putt for a half.
It's unsporting, and downright bad manners.
I certainly wouldn't attempt to leave the green whilst they still had a putt for a half.
alexbrownmp
Head Pro
you are correct they didnt, I dont remember many or anyone getting so upset as Charlie Hull was doing over apparently not saying anything. Why was she crying? was it guilt or did she bow down to captains pressure to say what the captain wanted? one can only speculate.
I'll reiterate though that Golf and particularly the LET have come out with a slight tarnish over this storm in a 'D' cup.
Smiffy
Grand Slam Winner
Have you actually watched the video closely Phil????
Kellfire
Blackballed
Hull was spoken to by the match ref. either she said she conceded or she said she didn't concede. She obviously said she didn't. Thus anyone opposing my opinion is essentially calling Hull a liar. Simple as that!
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
And I never ever pick up my ball unless I have putt it into the hole or I have clear indication from my oppo that the putt has been given
Someone walking isn't clear indication.
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
Or she was upset because of the accusations aimed at her as they still are now
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
Yep loads of times
Hull was walking towards Peterson - Lee picked the ball up before Hull had left the green.
tsped83
Tour Winner
Wow. She might not have "said" she conceded, but he act of walking off IS CONCEDING in my book. Chill out sunshine.
tsped83
Tour Winner
D
Deleted member 15344
Guest
That's where the grey issue is - there is no set rules out for what is classed as a concession of a putt etc
Kellfire
Blackballed
Why didn't she confirm that to the match ref?
C
c1973
Guest
If I had walked away like Hull had it would be because I had conceded the putt.
That's the way it looked to me.
One of those things folks aren't going to agree on though.
Looking at that with no commentary and no prior knowledge of this incident, if someone asked you the question "would you say she has conceded there?" I'd say, if you're being honest with yourself, most would say yes.
That's the way it looked to me.
One of those things folks aren't going to agree on though.
Looking at that with no commentary and no prior knowledge of this incident, if someone asked you the question "would you say she has conceded there?" I'd say, if you're being honest with yourself, most would say yes.
Robster59
Tour Rookie
There is ambiguity about whether the hole was conceded or not on here but at the end of the day, I would NEVER pick up a ball unless I was 100% CERTAIN that it had been conceded. Many's the time I've checked with my opponent that I have got it right that they have conceded the hole. Sometimes you hear a mumble but it's very easy to mistake it so if in doubt, check. If you are not sure, you ask your playing partners for clarification. Conceding the putt may be good manners, etiquette, etc. but it is not a right.
D
Deleted member 18121
Guest
Phil, so you turn your back and start walking away before your opponent has finished the hole? That's bad etiquette in my book.
Still IMO the Europeans were wrong and the US right to be upset.
Still IMO the Europeans were wrong and the US right to be upset.
