Orikoru
Tour Winner
Well if you were doing a proper comparison of clubs you would get multiple people with all different swings to test both of them, but your average YouTuber isn't going to be sorting that out. When companies do robot testing do they change the robot's swing between clubs?? If Crossfield wants to adjust his swing for each test he should use both swings for both clubs at the very least.Surely it is only those with the skill to modify their swings that can properly compare drivers ?
The most of us have both inconsistent swings, and are unable to modify them in any consistent way. So while we might swing different clubs, we are not at all testing the clubs themselves, but only how well they suit our particular swing (with all our well engrained flaws). Thats why we have to get fitted - to find the club and setup that best suits what we do with it.
By the same token when the club is being changed in these types of comparisons, it is not only unreasonable, but scientifically incorrect to then insist it must be used with the same swing. To expect all clubs to match any one given swing makes no sense. So adapting the swing to get the best out of a given club - which the likes of Crossfield has the skill to do - is the fairest and best test.